Study guide: Margins and Investment Returns

Course Outline

  1. Financial View of the Balance Sheet
  2. Cash and the Operating Cycle
  3. Working Capital Needs and Cash
  4. Calculating Net Financial Debt
  5. Capital Employed and Invested Capital
  6. Enterprise Value Versus Equity Value
  7. Economic Value Drivers
  8. Revenue Growth and Earnings Measures
  9. Non-Cash and Non-Recurring Items
  10. Free Cash Flow and Its Interpretation
  11. Investment and Long-Term Performance
  12. Depreciation and Operating Cash Flow
  13. Margins and Operational Performance
  14. Margin Drivers and Differentiation
  15. Return on Invested Capital
  16. Return on Equity

1. Financial View of the Balance Sheet

★ Must-know

📐 Formula - Working capital needs are calculated as WCN=Inventory+Accounts receivable−Accounts payable\mathrm{WCN} = \mathrm{Inventory} + \mathrm{Accounts\ receivable} - \mathrm{Accounts\ payable}.

📐 Formula - Net financial debt is calculated as Net financial debt=Long-term financial debt+Short-term financial debt−Cash and short-term investments\mathrm{Net\ financial\ debt} = \mathrm{Long\text{-}term\ financial\ debt} + \mathrm{Short\text{-}term\ financial\ debt} - \mathrm{Cash\ and\ short\text{-}term\ investments}.

Further detail

  • In JIT's simplified financial balance sheet, fixed assets are €121 million, working capital needs are €3 million, shareholders’ equity is €32 million, and net financial debt is €92 million, giving invested capital and capital employed of €124 million.

Memory Hook

Accounting assets and liabilities become fixed assets, working capital needs, and net financial debt in the financial view.

2. Cash and the Operating Cycle

Key Concepts & Definitions

  • Cash conversion cycle: Berk & DeMarzo, Corporate Finance - The operating-cycle time lag between positive and negative cash flows, arising from production-process length and customer and supplier credit policies.

★ Must-know

  • The cash conversion cycle ties up money in the operating cycle, so working capital needs are a necessary expense that cannot be postponed and have an immediate impact on cash.

Further detail

  • In France, one company in three pays suppliers late, a quarter of corporate defaults are attributed to late payment, and after a delay of 30 days the probability of default is almost six times higher. - Altares

  • Swissair stopped flying because it lacked cash to pay for jet fuel and landing fees and feared creditors would seize its planes at foreign airports. - ELIZABETH OLSON

  • On OCT. 3, 2001, Swissair abruptly stopped flying because it lacked cash to pay for jet fuel and landing fees. - ELIZABETH OLSON

Memory Hook

Picture cash as oxygen: the business needs it while money is frozen in the operating cycle.

3. Working Capital Needs and Cash

★ Must-know

📐 Formula - For JIT in Year 2, working capital needs were 15.3+18.5−(29.9+0.6)=3.315.3 + 18.5 - (29.9 + 0.6) = 3.3 million euros, compared with 14.3+13.2−(24.5+0.4)=2.614.3 + 13.2 - (24.5 + 0.4) = 2.6 million euros in Year 1.

📌 Positive working capital needs consume cash, whereas negative working capital needs can act as financial leverage.

📐 Formula - JIT’s working capital needs are calculated as WCN=Inventory+Accounts receivable−Accounts payable\text{WCN} = \text{Inventory} + \text{Accounts receivable} - \text{Accounts payable}.

  • JIT’s working capital needs increased from €2.6 million in Year 1 to €3.3 million in Year 2, requiring €700,000 to finance the increase.

📌 Negative working capital needs are a financial resource, whereas positive working capital needs consume cash.

Further detail

  • JIT's working capital needs increased by €700,000 from Year 1 to Year 2, requiring the firm to finance the increase.

  • In a consulting-business example with a €2,000 receivable and no payable, working capital needs are positive €2,000; with both a €2,000 receivable and payable they are zero; with no receivable and a €2,000 payable they are negative €2,000.

  • A firm can reduce working capital needs by taking supplier discounts and paying suppliers in cash, all else being equal.

  • The management objective is to reduce capital invested in the operating cycle without disrupting the firm’s proper functioning.

  • Working capital needs depend on sales, the length and nature of the operating cycle, and the cash conversion cycle, including supplier credit terms, the average collection period, and inventory turnover.

  • Reducing working capital needs generates a positive cash flow, and efficient net working capital management can help avoid cash stress and act as a financial lever.

  • Inventory uses cash through acquisition, ordering, and carrying costs, while holding inventory can prevent stock-outs and address seasonality.

4. Calculating Net Financial Debt

★ Must-know

📐 Formula - Net financial debt equals long- and short-term financial debt minus cash and short-term investments: Net financial debt=LT financial debt+ST financial debt−Cash−ST investments\text{Net financial debt} = \text{LT financial debt} + \text{ST financial debt} - \text{Cash} - \text{ST investments}.

  • JIT’s net financial debt was €52.3 million in Year 1 and €91.8 million in Year 2.

Further detail

📌 Net debt accounts for cash available to repay debt, so gross debt alone does not show the same exposure to default risk.

  • In the simplified EDF–Apple comparison, EDF had gross financial debt of about €65 billion and cash of about €30 billion, while Apple had gross financial debt of about $120 billion and cash of about $250 billion; their stated net debts were about €35 billion and −$140 billion, respectively.

  • The stated reasons for analyzing financial debt are: default risk, management autonomy versus creditor pressure or intervention, financial distress and reputation, cost of capital

5. Capital Employed and Invested Capital

Key Concepts & Definitions

  • Book value of equity: Total assets minus liabilities and an accounting measure of a shareholder’s net worth.

★ Must-know

📌 Capital employed, also called operating assets, is presented as a better indicator than total assets because total assets do not necessarily reflect a firm’s economic real value.

📐 Formula - Capital employed equals invested capital and can be calculated either as fixed assets plus working capital or as shareholders’ equity plus net financial debt: Capital employed=Invested capital=Fixed assets+Working capital=Shareholders’ equity+Net financial debt\text{Capital employed} = \text{Invested capital} = \text{Fixed assets} + \text{Working capital} = \text{Shareholders’ equity} + \text{Net financial debt}.

  • Book value is not a good estimate of a firm’s true value because balance-sheet assets are often recorded at historical cost rather than their current value.

📐 Formula - Market capitalization equals Market Price per Share×Number of Shares Outstanding\text{Market Price per Share} \times \text{Number of Shares Outstanding}.

📐 Formula - The market-to-book ratio equals Market Value of EquityBook Value of Equity\frac{\text{Market Value of Equity}}{\text{Book Value of Equity}}.

Further detail

  • JIT’s capital employed was €83.5 million in Year 1 and €124.0 million in Year 2, with each total matching invested capital calculated from shareholders’ equity and net financial debt.

  • The financial simplified presentation of the balance sheet separates investment policy from financial policy.

  • A firm’s book value of equity can be negative.

  • Valuable assets such as employee expertise, reputation, and relationships with customers and suppliers may not appear on the balance sheet.

  • JIT’s 3.6 million shares trading at €14 per share give it a market capitalization of €50.4 million, compared with book equity of €32.2 million in Year 2.

  • JIT’s market-to-book ratio is 1.5, meaning investors are willing to pay one and a half times the book value of its shares.

  • A market-to-book ratio greater than 1 indicates that the market value of a firm’s assets exceeds their historical cost or liquidation value.

📌 Value stocks have low market-to-book ratios, whereas growth stocks have high market-to-book ratios. - Berk & DeMarzo, Fundamentals of Corporate Finance

Memory Hook

Book value looks backward to historical cost; market value looks forward to expected output.

6. Enterprise Value Versus Equity Value

★ Must-know

  • Capital employed, equal to shareholders’ equity plus net financial debt, is presented as a good estimate of a firm’s value.

  • Enterprise value equals Equity+Debt−Cash\text{Equity} + \text{Debt} - \text{Cash}.

Further detail

  • Equity value is the value shareholders would receive if they sold all the shares.

  • Enterprise value is the amount an investor needs to buy all the shares, take the company’s cash, and repay its debt.

  • With a market capitalization of €50.4 million, JIT’s €106 million of long-term debt, €9 million of short-term debt, and €23.2 million of cash yield an enterprise value of €142.4 million.

Memory Hook

Picture buying the shares, taking the cash, then paying off the debt.

7. Economic Value Drivers

Key Concepts & Definitions

  • EVA: EVA means Economic Value Added.
  • WACC: WACC means Weighted Average Cost of Capital.

Essential Points

  • The value-driver map links market growth, market size, market share, and price to revenue; production, marketing, and distribution costs to profit margin; and non-current assets, inventories, receivables, operating cash, and operating liabilities to invested capital and turnover rate, which feed ROIC and EVA. - Thomas Plenborg and Christian Petersen, 2012

Memory Hook

Market growth and operating choices shape revenue and invested capital, which drive ROIC and EVA.

8. Revenue Growth and Earnings Measures

Key Concepts & Definitions

  • EBITDA: Earnings before interest, taxes, depreciation, and amortization, indicating a firm's capacity to generate wealth through its core business.
  • EBIT: Earnings before interest and taxes, representing earnings generated by investment and operating cycles during a given period.
  • Gross Profit: Net sales less cost of sales, indicating a firm's capacity to generate income after the costs of goods sold.

★ Must-know

  • Revenue growth analysis should distinguish price effects, including inflation, from volume effects and assess new-product commercialization, customer concentration, and whether growth comes from discounting or upmarket positioning.

Further detail

  • EBITDA is not altered by:
    • investment policy
    • depreciation-method accounting choices
    • financial debt
    • taxes
    • non-recurring items

Memory Hook

Price growth can reflect inflation; volume growth reflects units sold.

9. Non-Cash and Non-Recurring Items

★ Must-know

  • Net income does not necessarily equal cash earned because income statements can include non-cash items such as depreciation and amortization.

  • A positive net income does not necessarily indicate good future performance, and a negative net income does not necessarily indicate poor future performance.

📌 To assess earnings quality, analysts should consider the materiality and variability of non-operating income items, including accruals such as unrealized revenues and extraordinary items.

Further detail

  • Multi-period performance measures can be used to assess short-term versus long-term earnings capacity while eliminating the impact of non-recurring items.

  • In 2012 PSA Peugeot Citroen reported a €5 billion loss after booking a €3 billion financial charge; falling demand contributed to a 12.4% slump in new-vehicle sales to €27.8 billion.

  • Two enterprises with revenue of €100 million and depreciation and amortization of €5 million each both reported net earnings of €10 million, although one had EBIT of -€15 million and €30 million in non-recurring items while the other had EBIT of €15 million and no non-recurring items.

Memory Hook

Net income is an accounting result; cash flow records cash movement.

10. Free Cash Flow and Its Interpretation

★ Must-know

📐 Formula - Free Cash Flow=Cash from Operating Activities+Cash from Investing Activities\text{Free Cash Flow} = \text{Cash from Operating Activities} + \text{Cash from Investing Activities}

  • Positive free cash flow means cash generated by operating and investing activities covers operating and investment needs and may be used to pay dividends or reduce debt.

  • Negative free cash flow means additional financial resources must be raised to cover the company's capital requirements.

Further detail

  • In the Just-In-Time example, cash from operating activities was €1.3 million and cash from investing activities was -€39.8 million, giving free cash flow of -€38.5 million.

11. Investment and Long-Term Performance

★ Must-know

  • Amazon took more than 14 years—58 quarters after its May 1997 initial public offering—to earn cumulatively as much profit as it generated in the latest quarter of 2017.

  • Amazon’s revenue rose from $88,988 million in 2014 to $107,006 million in 2015, while net income changed from a loss of $241 million to a profit of $596 million.

  • Valeant cut research spending to 3% of revenues, compared with about 19% at large pharmaceutical companies, and acquired products by buying companies with debt. - John Gapper, APRIL 23 2014

Further detail

  • Amazon’s research and development expenses increased from $9,275 million in 2014 to $12,540 million in 2015.

  • Amazon’s EBITDA rose from $4,924 million in 2014 to $8,514 million in 2015, while EBIT rose from $178 million to $2,233 million.

  • In an article dated April 23, 2014, John Gapper argued that the future of the pharmaceutical industry lies in research rather than cuts, and that widespread adoption of Valeant’s approach would halt drug discovery.

  • Valeant had taken over more than 35 companies since 2008, including Bausch & Lomb, acquired for $8.7 billion the previous year. - John Gapper, APRIL 23 2014

Memory Hook

Immediate profit is not the same as long-term success

12. Depreciation and Operating Cash Flow

★ Must-know

  • An additional €900,000 of depreciation in JIT’s Year 2, with a 33% tax rate, reduced net earnings from €2.0 million to €1.4 million.

  • In the JIT example, the additional €900,000 depreciation reduced corporate income tax from €1.0 million to €0.7 million and increased year-end cash by €0.3 million.

Further detail

  • Air France extended the useful lives of aircraft and reserve engines from 12 to 20 years and reduced their residual value from 15% to 5%.

📌 Changes to depreciation and amortization affect taxes as well as reported earnings and cash flows.

Memory Hook

Higher depreciation lowers taxable income, which can increase cash after tax

13. Margins and Operational Performance

Key Concepts & Definitions

  • Margin Ratio: A margin ratio measures profit relative to net revenue.
  • Return Ratio: A return ratio measures profit relative to invested capital.

★ Must-know

  • Margin ratios express each income-statement item as a percentage of revenue, helping assess profit generation, cost structure, and operating performance across firms and over time.

  • In JIT’s common-size income statement, gross margin was 52.0% in Year 2 and 54.0% in Year 1, while EBITDA margin was 6.2% and 4.8%, respectively.

  • JIT’s EBIT margin was 5.6% in Year 2 and 4.2% in Year 1, while its net margin was 1.1% in both years.

📌 Margins and other ratios are not very helpful by themselves and need comparison with an appropriate benchmark, such as past performance, competitors and industry peers, or targets.

Further detail

  • Profitability analysis can include:

    • Common-size analysis of revenue, costs, and invested capital
    • Time-series analysis of past performance and trends
    • Cross-sectional comparison with competitors
    • Comparison of realized performance with company targets
    • Comparison with the required rate of return to assess value added
  • JIT’s gross margin fell from 54.0% in Year 1 to 52.0% in Year 2, while its EBITDA margin rose from 4.8% to 6.2% and its EBIT margin rose from 4.2% to 5.6%.

  • JIT’s pretax margin was 1.6% in both Year 1 and Year 2, while its net margin was 1.1% in Year 1 and 1.0% in Year 2.

  • A scissors effect in margins may result from intense competition, mismanagement, or regulatory changes, and may reveal the quality of a company’s strategic market position and its capacity to cope with a sudden cost increase.

  • The operating margins shown for Hermès, LVMH, and Carrefour were 32%, 21%, and 5%, respectively, and differences in operating margins can result from corporate strategy.

  • Kering’s EBIT margin increased from 14.2% in 2015 to 30.1% in 2019 as it progressively exited historical retail and apparel businesses to focus mainly on higher-margin pure luxury business.

  • In the Year 4 target comparison, realized revenue was €2,776,600,000 against a target of €2,787,000,000, a spread of −€10,400,000.

Memory Hook

Past performance shows change over time; industry comparison shows relative position.

14. Margin Drivers and Differentiation

★ Must-know

  • The considerations are:
    • competition
    • cost management
    • innovation
    • differentiation

Further detail

  • The course presents a strategy of dominating first and monetizing afterward as a way to turn competitive position into margin opportunity.

  • The EBITDA margin data for leading listed European companies is attributed to Pierre Vernimmen and sourced from Exane BNP Paribas.

Memory Hook

Cost management and differentiation shape the margins a firm can sustain.

15. Return on Invested Capital

Key Concepts & Definitions

  • Return on Invested Capital: Measures operating profit relative to invested capital or capital employed.

★ Must-know

📐 Formula - ROIC=EBITCapital Employed=EBITFixed Assets+Working Capital=EBITEquity+Net Financial Debt\mathrm{ROIC} = \frac{\mathrm{EBIT}}{\mathrm{Capital\ Employed}} = \frac{\mathrm{EBIT}}{\mathrm{Fixed\ Assets} + \mathrm{Working\ Capital}} = \frac{\mathrm{EBIT}}{\mathrm{Equity} + \mathrm{Net\ Financial\ Debt}}.

Further detail

  • In JIT’s example, Year 2 capital employed was 124.3, EBIT was 10.4, and ROIC was 8.4%; Year 1 capital employed was 83.6, EBIT was 7.4, and ROIC was 8.9%.

  • Using EBIT as the operating-profit measure in the ROIC calculation is an oversimplification; the course says NOPAT is used in practice.

  • In the capital-provider example, invested capital is 100, funded by shareholders’ equity of 20 and net financial debt of 80, and operating profit after tax of 20 is the wealth created.

📐 Formula - In the capital-provider example, return on invested capital is 20100=20%\frac{20}{100}=20\%, return on debt is 880=10%\frac{8}{80}=10\%, and return on equity is 1220=60%\frac{12}{20}=60\%.

16. Return on Equity

Key Concepts & Definitions

  • Return on Equity: Measures owners’ accounting return on their investments in a company.

★ Must-know

📐 Formula - ROE=Net IncomeEquity\mathrm{ROE} = \frac{\mathrm{Net\ Income}}{\mathrm{Equity}}.

Further detail

  • JIT’s ROE was 6.2% in Year 2, calculated from net earnings of 2.0 and total shareholders’ equity of 32.2, and 6.1% in Year 1, from net earnings of 1.9 and equity of 31.2.

  • The stated limitations of ROE are: it can be misleading, it is prone to manipulation, book value may be meaningless, a one-period return may be meaningless, financial return cannot be judged independently of risk

  • ROE can be heavily influenced by financial leverage.

Synthesis Tables

Equal Net Earnings, Different Earnings Quality

MeasureEnterprise 1Enterprise 2
Revenue€100 million€100 million
EBIT-€15 million€15 million
Non-recurring items€30 millionNone
Net earnings€10 million€10 million

Margin and Return Ratios

RatioNumeratorDenominator
Margin ratioProfitNet revenue
Return ratioProfitInvested capital

Test yourself

Take a 40-question practice quiz on Margins and Investment Returns, with every answer explained.

1. A retailer has inventory of €18 million, accounts receivable of €12 million, and accounts payable of €20 million. What are its working capital needs?

2. A firm has €40 million of long-term financial debt, €15 million of short-term financial debt, and €8 million in cash and short-term investments. What is its net financial debt?

Take the quiz →

Study with flashcards

Memorize the key concepts of Margins and Investment Returns with 91 flashcards.

How is working capital needs (WCN) calculated?

WCN=Inventory+Accounts receivable−Accounts payable\mathrm{WCN} = \mathrm{Inventory} + \mathrm{Accounts\ receivable} - \mathrm{Accounts\ payable}

How is net financial debt calculated?

Net financial debt=Long-term financial debt+Short-term financial debt−Cash and short-term investments\mathrm{Net\ financial\ debt} = \mathrm{Long\text{-}term\ financial\ debt} + \mathrm{Short\text{-}term\ financial\ debt} - \mathrm{Cash\ and\ short\text{-}term\ investments}

What is the cash conversion cycle, according to Berk & DeMarzo, Corporate Finance?

The operating-cycle lag between positive and negative cash flows.

See the flashcards →

Related classes

Make your own study guides

Upload your class notes and Revizly writes a study guide, a quiz and flashcards in about a minute.

Study guide maker