Study guide: Explorers or Boys Messing About

Course Outline

  1. Title, Audience and Purpose
  2. Ridicule in the Rescue Account
  3. Cost and Public Resources
  4. Risk, Preparation and Expertise
  5. Infantile Image of the Men
  6. Rescue Language and Professionalism
  7. Credentials and Renewed Criticism
  8. Ending and Overall Characterization

1. Title, Audience and Purpose

★ Must-know

📌 The title contrasts ‘explorers’, which suggests skill and respect, with ‘boys messing about’, which presents the men as a nuisance.

  • The title’s reference to taxpayers suggests that the public will pay for the men’s rescue, helping make readers frustrated with them.

Further detail

  • The analysis describes the Guardian’s readership as typically educated and argues that taxpayers are likely to identify with the article’s concern about the rescue bill.

Memory Hook

‘Explorers’ invites respect; ‘boys messing about’ invites ridicule.

2. Ridicule in the Rescue Account

★ Must-know

  • Calling the men’s previous expedition a ‘farce’ ridicules it and signals the writer’s lack of admiration for them.

Further detail

  • The description of the men being ‘plunged’ into the sea and ‘plucked’ out creates cartoonish imagery that makes their rescue seem ridiculous.

  • The phrase ‘trusty helicopter’ is placed in inverted commas to create a sarcastic tone and mock the men’s confidence in it.

Memory Hook

The men are comically ‘plunged’ into the sea and ‘plucked’ back out.

3. Cost and Public Resources

★ Must-know

  • The article says that the men’s adventure cost taxpayers in Britain and Chile tens of thousands of pounds, while leaving the exact amount unclear.

  • The rescue involved:

    • the Royal Navy
    • the RAF
    • the British Coast Guards

Further detail

  • The analysis argues that the imprecise phrase ‘tens of thousands’ may encourage readers to imagine the highest possible cost.

  • The Ministry of Defence says taxpayers would normally pay for rescues in the UK and abroad, and that recovering the money was highly unlikely.

Memory Hook

A costly adventure → taxpayers face the rescue bill.

4. Risk, Preparation and Expertise

★ Must-know

  • Experts question the wisdom of taking a four-seater Robinson R44 with a single engine into a hostile environment.

Further detail

  • The analysis says the contrast between the helicopter’s limited capacity and the hostile environment supports the experts’ criticism of the men’s judgement.

  • An Antarctic explorer calls the men’s survival ‘nothing short of a miracle’, emphasizing the danger they faced and their recklessness.

  • A spokesman says the flying conditions were excellent despite the helicopter’s failure, which the analysis uses to question the men’s skill.

Memory Hook

A small, single-engine helicopter faces a hostile environment.

5. Infantile Image of the Men

★ Must-know

  • Jo Vesti describes the men as ‘boys messing about’, an infantile phrase that makes them seem naive and unserious.

Further detail

  • The men are identified as being 42 and 40, so their ages contrast with the description of them as boys and can make readers think they should know better.

  • The men’s wives and Brooks’s call to his wife create domestic imagery that contrasts with their imagined identities as action heroes.

  • The phrase ‘emergency people’ makes Brooks sound unprepared and unsure how to refer to the people who could help him.

Memory Hook

Their ‘boys’ image clashes with their ages and domestic lives.

6. Rescue Language and Professionalism

★ Must-know

  • The men’s helicopter is described as having ‘ditched’ and the men as having ‘scrambled’, while rescue professionals ‘deciphered’, ‘surveyed’ and ‘dispatched’, contrasting their apparent disorder with professional competence.

Further detail

  • The men were rescued after a nine-hour operation that began when Brooks contacted his wife by satellite phone.

  • The Royal Navy’s HMS Endurance was 180 miles away, and its two Lynx helicopters were sent towards the scene before a Chilean naval vessel picked up the men.

Memory Hook

The men ‘ditched’; professionals ‘surveyed’ and ‘dispatched’.

7. Credentials and Renewed Criticism

Essential Points

  • Brooks is described as having explored 70 countries in 15 years, travelled solo to every Space Camp and walked barefoot for three days in the Himalayas.

  • Brooks is also described as having kayaked the San BZ River’s whitewater rapids, survived a silverback gorilla charge in the Congo and qualified as a mechanical engineer and pilot.

  • Smith claims to have flown since age five, flown a helicopter around the globe twice and won the world freestyle helicopter flying championship.

  • The article’s account of the men’s successful achievements creates a narrative shift, but the analysis notes that the verb ‘claims’ casts doubt on Smith’s account.

  • Brooks and another explorer were forced to halt a planned crossing of the 56-mile frozen Bering Strait after Russian authorities threatened to use military helicopters to remove them.

  • The analysis presents the men’s aim of demonstrating improved East–West relations through an expedition as naive and potentially egotistical.

  • Gunter Endres, editor of Jane’s helicopter markets and systems, says he would not use an R44 so far over the sea and that the men seemed to be pushing it to the maximum.

8. Ending and Overall Characterization

Essential Points

  • The article ends with Vesti saying the men would probably have their ‘bottoms kicked’ and be sent home, using juvenile language to present them as overgrown children.

  • The analysis characterizes Morris’s portrayal of the men as frustrated, comic and ironic, presenting them as reckless, egotistical and infantile.

Test yourself

Take a 16-question practice quiz on Explorers or Boys Messing About, with every answer explained.

1. A headline calls two men “explorers” or “boys messing about.” What contrast does this wording create?

2. A headline emphasizes that taxpayers will face the bill for rescuing two adventurers. What reader response does this reference help encourage?

Take the quiz →

Study with flashcards

Memorize the key concepts of Explorers or Boys Messing About with 43 flashcards.

What contrast does the title draw between “explorers” and “boys messing about”?

“Explorers” suggests skill and respect, while “boys messing about” presents the men as a nuisance.

What does the title’s reference to taxpayers suggest about the men’s rescue?

The public will pay for it, encouraging readers to feel frustrated with the men.

What does calling the men’s previous expedition a “farce” reveal about the writer?

The writer lacks admiration for them.

See the flashcards →

Related classes

Make your own study guides

Upload your class notes and Revizly writes a study guide, a quiz and flashcards in about a minute.

Study guide maker