Study guide: Justice and Urban Transitions

Course Outline

  1. Environmental Inequality and Coastal Risk
  2. Soil Protection and Land Take
  3. Urban Heat and Climate Adaptation
  4. Ecological Solidarity in Law
  5. Infrastructure Transitions and Change
  6. Just Transitions and Energy
  7. Digital Transitions in Cities
  8. Digital Governance and Infrastructure
  9. Transition Concepts and Imaginaries
  10. Urban Energy Transitions and Justice
  11. South Africa’s Energy Transition
  12. Ecological Solidarity in French Law
  13. Ecological Solidarity and Legal Responsibility
  14. Participation, Flood Risk and Justice
  15. Urban Climate and Heat Mitigation
  16. Soil Protection and No Net Land Take
  17. Environmental Inequality and Resilience

1. Environmental Inequality and Coastal Risk

Key Concepts & Definitions

  • Environmental inequality: V. Deldrève, dictionnary of climate change, 2022 - Unequal relationships between human populations and their environment, including unequal exposure to risks, access to resources and amenities, environmental impacts of production and consumption, capacity to protect the environment through public policy, and ability to benefit from such actions.

Essential Points

  • The Signal, a coastal building in Soulac-sur-Mer completed in 1970, was threatened by shoreline erosion; its residents were evacuated and its owners lost money.

  • French urban law sets a 100-metre building setback from the coast, although buildings constructed before the law may be closer.

  • A public solidarity fund compensates people affected by major hazards and receives a small contribution through home purchases or insurance.

2. Soil Protection and Land Take

★ Must-know

  • Soils provide ecological functions and are resources that benefit human populations, but they remain a blind spot in environmental law.

  • UN Sustainable Development Goal 15.3 calls for restoring degraded land and soil and aims at zero net land degradation.

  • France enforced the no net land take objective, known as ZAN, in 2021.

Further detail

  • Soil is described as approximately 6 metres deep and becomes deeper as it ages.

  • International and European environmental law has largely left land and soil aside, with no direct international convention addressing soil issues and state sovereignty acting as an obstacle.

  • The EU Soil Monitoring and Resilience Directive was adopted in November after approximately twenty years of work, although the course notes that soil health was omitted.

  • The EU Roadmap for a Resource-Efficient Europe set a milestone to halt net land take by 2050 and estimated that new land take needed to average 800 km² per year between 2000 and 2020 to follow a linear path.

  • Since 2000, urban laws increasingly addressed urban sprawl, initially focusing mainly on agricultural land; since 2010, land take has also been linked to environmental concerns such as ecological corridors and flood risks.

Memory Hook

Land take fragments habitats → biodiversity erosion

3. Urban Heat and Climate Adaptation

Key Concepts & Definitions

  • Climate: The statistics of weather over long periods, with at least 30 years given as an example.

★ Must-know

📐 Formula - Urban climate equals local climate plus the urban effect: Urban Climate=Local Climate+Urban Effect\text{Urban Climate} = \text{Local Climate} + \text{Urban Effect}.

  • Urban heat islands are intensified at night because radiation is trapped and reflected between buildings, evapotranspiration is limited, wind is obstructed, and human activities release heat.

  • The urban heat island temperature difference is typically about 3°C, but during the 2026 heat waves the urban-rural difference reached 5–7°C.

  • Urban heat measures include:

    • creating shade first
    • allowing natural ventilation
    • increasing urban albedo
    • adding vegetation
    • managing rainwater

Further detail

  • At thermodynamic equilibrium, energy entering a system equals energy leaving it.

  • Heat transfers by three mechanisms:

    • conduction
    • convection
    • radiation
  • Typical greenhouse gases include:

    • water vapour
    • carbon dioxide
    • methane
    • nitrous oxide
    • chlorofluorocarbons
  • Air conditioning can intensify urban heat islands because greater heat-wave demand leads to more air conditioning and stronger urban heat.

Memory Hook

Trapped radiation, little evapotranspiration, blocked wind, and human heat → stronger urban heat islands

4. Ecological Solidarity in Law

Key Concepts & Definitions

  • Ecological solidarity: The interdependence of territories that share a natural environment and the ecological interactions on which ecosystem functioning relies.

★ Must-know

  • The French legal principle of ecological solidarity, created in 2016, calls for public decision-makers to take into account interactions among ecosystems, living organisms, and natural or developed environments when a decision significantly affects the environment of the areas concerned.

📌 Mathevet et al. (2012) distinguish solidarity of fact, the shared destiny of humans, society, and the environment, from solidarity of action, the recognized willingness of inhabitants, users, and visitors to live with other beings and judge actions by their consequences for the living community.

Further detail

  • France has 11 national parks, whose protected areas can include a core area and a wider membership area that extends dialogue and preventive environmental practices to neighbouring territories.

  • Water governance includes: territorial and financial solidarity among river basin agencies, solidarity among water users, upstream-downstream solidarity

Memory Hook

Solidarity of fact describes shared ecological destiny; solidarity of action expresses a choice to live with other beings

5. Infrastructure Transitions and Change

Key Concepts & Definitions

  • Transitions: Systematic changes in how systems operate, reflecting changes in the fundamental structures and operating logics of infrastructure, politics, institutions, and social life.
  • Lock-in: The difficulty of shifting to alternative pathways because existing infrastructure, institutions, technologies, and investments constrain change.
  • Leapfrogging: The prospect of skipping assumed steps in a development trajectory, presented as an opportunity for particular regions or types of society.

★ Must-know

📌 Transitions can be studied both as material processes of change that can be empirically documented and as discourses that construct narratives around crisis, urgency, and change.

  • The course divides globalization into imperial globalization (1500–1800), industrial globalization (1820–1980), hyper-globalization (1980–2010), and mixed relocalization and hyper-disaggregation since 2010.

Further detail

  • Transition experiences are:

    • nonlinear
    • sociotechnical
    • additive rather than purely substitutive
    • contested
    • interconnected and planetary
    • material as well as discursive
  • Large technological systems create:

    • sunk costs
    • technical dependencies
    • regulatory commitments
    • user habits or cultural norms
  • Contemporary transition processes include:

    • demographic change
    • governance decentralization
    • new financial players and financialization
    • reorganization of global value chains

6. Just Transitions and Energy

★ Must-know

  • The just transition discourse began in the US labour movement in the 1970s–1980s and argued that workers in polluting or hazardous industries should not bear the economic costs of environmental protection.

📌 Mitigation reduces emissions, whereas adaptation responds to climate impacts and prepares affected places for them.

  • Renewable energy costs fell between 2010 and 2020 by 85% for photovoltaic electricity and 56% for onshore wind.

Further detail

  • The 17 Sustainable Development Goals contain an implicit tension between goals requiring expanded economic activity and goals requiring reduced emissions, responsible consumption, or restored fish stocks.

  • SDG 7 reconciles growth and degrowth tensions by promising access to affordable, reliable, sustainable, and modern energy for all.

  • Under the Paris Agreement adopted at COP21, nearly all countries submit nationally determined contributions as part of climate commitments.

  • Africa accounts for 5% of global CO₂ emissions, while South Africa accounts for about 33% of Africa’s emissions.

  • African cities face the combined imperative of expanding energy access, shifting energy sources, and building appropriate governance systems.

7. Digital Transitions in Cities

Key Concepts & Definitions

  • Digital transition: A fundamental, processual sociotechnical change in how society is organized that relies on digital technology and networks.
  • Digital platform: A sociotechnical intermediary and business arrangement that aims to automate market exchanges and mediate social action.
  • Sociotechnical: Describes the mutual influence of social and technical worlds and the inseparability of social and technical processes.

★ Must-know

  • Much collected urban data is not currently used, and some collection is justified speculatively by the expectation that the data will have future value.

Further detail

  • Key milestones in digitalization include microprocessors and personal computers in the 1970s, public access to the World Wide Web in the 1990s, cloud computing in the 2000s, and AI used for prediction, automation, and machine learning in the 2010s.

  • Commonly claimed benefits of digital technology include:

    • optimization
    • efficiency
    • access to knowledge
    • transparency
    • agility
    • convenience
    • innovation or disruption
  • Urban data streams include:

    • mobility
    • health incidents
    • financial flows and spending
  • Digital technologies can support emissions reductions through:

    • smart electricity grids
    • sensors that reduce water and energy waste
    • AI that optimizes transport and logistics
  • Cities also generate data about infrastructure failures such as leakages and breakdowns, as well as ecological conditions.

8. Digital Governance and Infrastructure

★ Must-know

  • Digitalization of urban governance and services is often presented as an initial way to use digital innovation to improve relations between local governments and citizens.

  • Undersea internet cables can be damaged when boats drop anchors where they should not, making the infrastructure fragile.

  • Digital transitions can create new sites of injustice: green benefits may be offset by extraction, concentrated power, bias in AI systems and platforms, and persistent digital divides.

Further detail

  • Examples of digital urban-government services include:

    • modernizing revenue payments
    • providing access to government forms
    • documenting and tracking grievances
  • Cities can govern technology by taking positions on platforms such as Airbnb and by supporting or discouraging technology hubs.

  • Digital infrastructure can be sabotaged to capture information or prevent people from accessing information, for example during large mobilizations.

Memory Hook

Fragile cables → vulnerable access and information

9. Transition Concepts and Imaginaries

Key Concepts & Definitions

  • Transition: A systematic change in how systems operate, involving a shift in their structures and operating logics.
  • Lock-in: How existing infrastructures, institutions, technologies, and investments make it difficult to shift to alternative pathways, even when superior alternatives exist.
  • Leapfrogging: The prospect of bypassing assumed steps in a development trajectory, an opportunity often discussed for particular regions or societies, including in the Global South.
  • Disruption: An innovation or process that fundamentally transforms or destabilizes existing markets, institutions, or sociotechnical systems.

★ Must-know

  • Past transitions shape contemporary infrastructure, social and cultural life, and patterns of accumulation and distribution, leaving durable legacies.

📌 Transitions can be examined both as material processes that can be observed and documented and as discourses that construct narratives about change, crisis, or urgency.

📌 Speculation seeks to assess risks and uncertainties, but risk can be measured and quantified whereas uncertainty cannot be quantified.

Further detail

  • Fressoz argues that narratives of energy transition can construct a reassuring history and a seemingly certain future that do not match the complexity of actual change.

  • Large technological systems create:

    • sunk costs
    • technical dependencies
    • regulatory commitments
    • user habits or cultural norms
  • Transitions are non-linear, sociotechnical, additive rather than purely substitutive, contested, interconnected across planetary scales, and both material and discursive.

Memory Hook

Material change is observable; transition discourse frames its meaning

10. Urban Energy Transitions and Justice

Key Concepts & Definitions

  • Just transition: A normative set of claims about how transitions should occur, addressing who bears their costs and benefits and reflecting geographical specificities.

★ Must-know

  • SDG 7 seeks affordable, reliable, sustainable, and modern energy for all, creating tension between expanding universal energy access and reducing emissions and resource consumption.

  • The energy transition is changing extractive landscapes by reshaping where resources are extracted, how energy systems are organized, and which territories become strategically important.

Further detail

  • The 17 Sustainable Development Goals include goals that require expanded economic activity and others that call for reduced emissions, responsible consumption, or restored fish stocks.

  • Coal-related production and value chains are plateauing or declining partly because of international climate commitments and decarbonization policies.

  • Green transitions are increasing demand for associated minerals and creating emerging extractive industries, including new lithium frontiers.

  • Energy transitions reorganize:

    • production
    • distribution
    • transmission
    • storage
    • energy landscapes
  • Decentralized renewable technologies can redistribute energy provision, but they create anxiety for institutions that have held a monopoly on centralized provision.

  • Innovations in renewable energy have driven prices down, while China dominates most of the green value chain through substantial state investment.

  • The just-transition concept was first adopted by the US labor movement in the 1970s to argue that workers in polluting or hazardous industries should not bear the economic costs of environmental protection.

  • In the 1990s, just transition was taken up in climate and fossil-fuel debates to address impacts on affected livelihoods and regions.

  • Just energy-transition programs have generally been national in scope, while cities have been insufficiently considered in these debates.

  • African cities face the challenge of expanding access to energy while working with existing electrical systems and new technologies such as new grids.

  • Urban electrical systems can combine new technologies, transformations of existing grids, new governance regimes, and supplementary electrical systems where centralized grids fail.

11. South Africa’s Energy Transition

★ Must-know

  • South Africa’s Just Energy Transition Partnership was launched at COP26 and was presented as a major international investment partnership for reducing emissions.

  • The partnership was announced with US$8.5 billion in support, including concessional and commercial loans, guarantees and risk-sharing instruments, and equity investments.

  • South Africa’s energy infrastructure has historically supported extractive industries, including mining, and the early expansion of energy systems was centralized around powering mining.

Further detail

  • The partnership program focuses on:

    • retiring coal plants
    • reskilling workers
    • investing in renewable sectors
    • investing in renewable value chains
  • Critics argue that relying on loans rather than grants may leave South Africa carrying the burden of a global emissions-reduction effort and risk creating a debt trap.

  • In 1948, the National Party came to power in South Africa and apartheid began.

  • The Renewable Energy Independent Power Producer Procurement Programme (REIPPP) was proposed as an auction model that joins independent renewable production to the electricity network.

12. Ecological Solidarity in French Law

Key Concepts & Definitions

  • Ecological solidarity: A legal French principle based on the idea that territories depend on one another because they share natural resources, and that ecological systems depend on interactions among species.

★ Must-know

  • In 2006, France’s Law on National Parks first introduced the principle of ecological solidarity into law.

Further detail

  • Ecological solidarity concerns interactions among species rather than a single species; the principle holds that without interaction, the system degrades.

  • The ecological-solidarity provisions appear in the French Environmental Code and distinguish geographical community from ecological connection.

📌 A French national park can include one or more protected terrestrial or marine core areas and an adhesion area made up of municipalities that voluntarily join the park charter and contribute to protection because of geographic continuity or ecological connection.

  • The ecological-solidarity concept was theorized after its legal recognition by researchers including Thomson, Mathevet, and Bonin. - Thomson, Mathevet, Bonin

★ Must-know

  • Ecological solidarity has two interpretations: interaction among ecological components, which environmental law chose as the lighter approach, and interdependency, which is harder to define because ecosystems can evolve, adapt, and become resilient.

  • Raphaël Mathevet distinguishes fact ecological solidarity, describing the shared destiny and coevolution of humans and nature, from ecological solidarity in action, which concerns residents’, users’, and visitors’ recognition that they belong to a community of life and their wish to live alongside other living beings.

  • In France, ecological solidarity was integrated into environmental law in 2016 through Article L. 110-1 of the Code de l’environnement, which requires public decisions with significant effects on an area’s environment to take account of interactions among ecosystems, living organisms, and natural or developed environments.

Further detail

📌 Article L. 110-1 makes ecological solidarity a guide for relevant public decisions, but the principle imposes a light obligation because decision-makers may justify not taking it into account.

  • Ecological solidarity links people’s actions to consequences for the community of life and supports the idea of a debt to future generations and cautious use of the environment.

  • The 1992 Rio Earth Summit, held from June 3–14 in Rio de Janeiro with representatives from 178 countries, made sustainable development a global priority and produced major international environmental treaties.

Memory Hook

Interaction is the lighter legal approach; interdependency expresses a stronger ecological bond.

14. Participation, Flood Risk and Justice

★ Must-know

📌 Flood-risk policy can support exposed residents either by helping them leave risky areas or by adapting territories and housing so residents can remain.

  • In 2018, after a flood killed two people, authorities decided to expropriate residents of 224 parcels and demolish 150 houses in Belleplace-Blandin, Villeneuve-Saint-Georges, to create a flood-expansion wetland; the district flooded again in 2021, 2022, and 2024.

📌 Expropriation for flood management raises a justice concern because poorer residents may be inadequately compensated and may have no viable rehousing option.

Further detail

  • Forms of citizen participation include:

    • public consultations
    • voting
    • participatory budgeting
    • community services
    • protests and rallies
    • advisory boards
  • Citizen participation may be limited by gaps in knowledge and finance, and participation programs may face litigation seeking cancellation when their ineffectiveness is demonstrated.

  • Ecological solidarity in urban planning calls for territorial cooperation beyond administrative borders because shared resources such as water connect territories, upstream actions affect downstream areas, and environmental risks are unevenly distributed.

Memory Hook

Flood exposure → relocation or adaptation → questions of compensation and justice.

15. Urban Climate and Heat Mitigation

Key Concepts & Definitions

  • Urban heat island: Localized heating in a city relative to its rural surroundings; the phenomenon was first observed in the 19th century by Luke Howard.

★ Must-know

📌 Heat stress is the physiological state in which the human body must work to regulate its temperature, while an urban heat island is a climatic phenomenon.

  • Urban heat islands arise through:
    • radiative trapping
    • reduced evapotranspiration
    • wind obstruction
    • anthropogenic heat

Further detail

  • Heat stress depends on: metabolic activity, clothing insulation, environmental convection, radiation exposure, conduction through direct contact with surfaces

  • In Paris, the urban–rural temperature difference is typically about 3°C and reached 12°C during the 2003 heatwave.

  • External shading is more effective than internal shading at limiting solar gains, while indoor heat also depends on building-envelope heat transfer, air renewal, and internal heat gains.

  • Urban cooling measures include: reflective roofs and pavements, vegetation, shading, ventilation, pavement watering, reducing atmospheric exhaust from air-conditioning systems

16. Soil Protection and No Net Land Take

Key Concepts & Definitions

  • No Net Land Take: A planning objective to halt the net increase in land area occupied by 2050 by balancing new land take with restoration or renaturation.
  • Zero Net Land Degradation: The global goal of preventing a decline in healthy, productive land by balancing new land degradation with an equal amount of land restoration.

★ Must-know

  • France’s Climate and Resilience Law, adopted on 22 August 2021, set the objective of reducing land consumption by 50% by 2031 and reaching zero net artificialisation by 2050.

Further detail

  • The 2025 EU Soil Monitoring Law establishes a framework to monitor and assess soils and to achieve healthy EU soils by 2050.

  • Under SDG indicator 15.3, land degradation is assessed using land cover, land productivity, and carbon stock, with the One-Out All-Out principle treating a significant negative change in any one sub-indicator as degradation.

  • Under the French 2050 objective, each square metre of artificialised land is to be balanced by renaturation of an equivalent surface.

17. Environmental Inequality and Resilience

Key Concepts & Definitions

  • Environmental inequality: Valérie DELDREVE - The unequal distribution among individuals or social groups of environmental risks and harms, access to environmental resources and amenities, contributions to environmental degradation, and capacity to participate in or benefit from environmental policies.
  • Resilience: Marie-Ange Schellekens and Raphaël Mathevet, dictionnaire juridique du changement climatique - A system’s ability to absorb climatic or societal disruptions while questioning the need for profound transformation.
  • Environmental aspect assessment: The process of identifying and evaluating activities, products, or services that can interact with and affect the environment.

★ Must-know

📌 Climate mitigation addresses the root causes of climate change by reducing greenhouse-gas emissions, whereas adaptation adjusts to actual or expected climate impacts.

Further detail

  • Resilience can involve a question of reversibility because some environmental changes, such as erosion, cannot be reversed.

Memory Hook

Mitigation addresses climate causes; adaptation responds to climate impacts.

Test yourself

Take a 11-question practice quiz on Justice and Urban Transitions, with every answer explained.

1. A city’s low-income neighborhoods face greater pollution, have less access to parks, and have fewer resources to influence environmental policy or benefit from improvements. Which concept best describes this pattern?

2. A policy review notes that soil supports ecological functions and benefits people, yet receives little direct attention in environmental law. Which characterization best fits this situation?

Take the quiz →

Study with flashcards

Memorize the key concepts of Justice and Urban Transitions with 10 flashcards.

Which author and 2022 reference define environmental inequality?

V. Deldrève, *Dictionnary of Climate Change*, 2022.

What ecological and human value do soils provide?

Soils provide ecological functions and resources that benefit human populations.

What depth is soil described as having, and how does it change with age?

Approximately 6 metres deep, becoming deeper as it ages.

See the flashcards →

Related classes

Make your own study guides

Upload your class notes and Revizly writes a study guide, a quiz and flashcards in about a minute.

Study guide maker