Study guide: Origins of the Troubles

Course Outline

  1. Unionist Rule and Catholic Discrimination
  2. Welfare, Modernisation and British Nonintervention
  3. Catholic Confidence and Political Stagnation
  4. Short-Term Causes of Conflict
  5. NICRA and the Escalation of Violence
  6. Structural and Immediate Causes
  7. Political Protagonists
  8. Internment and Bloody Sunday
  9. Violence and the Sunningdale Era
  10. Bombing Campaigns and Sectarian Violence
  11. Sunningdale Agreement and Collapse
  12. Ulsterization and Managed Violence
  13. Criminalization and Prison Status

Key Dates

  1. 1969The Provisional Irish Republican Army (PIRA) was established.
  2. 1971Northern Irish authorities launched Operation Demetrius to arrest people believed responsible for violence and unrest, amid serious rioting, growing IRA activity and the murder of three Scottish soldiers.
  3. 30 January 1972British paratroopers shot and killed 13 unarmed civilians in Derry during a NICRA civil rights march against internment without trial; a fourteenth victim later died of injuries.
  4. February 1972An IRA bomb at the Parachute Regiment headquarters in Aldershot, planted in retaliation for Bloody Sunday, killed seven people, including five women employed at the barracks, a civilian gardener and a Catholic army chaplain, rather than its intended paratrooper targets.
  5. March 1972The British government suspended the Northern Irish Parliament at Stormont and introduced Direct Rule from London, ending more than fifty years of devolved unionist government.
  6. March 1972A bomb exploded in Belfast’s crowded Abercorn Restaurant, killing two young women and injuring more than 130 people.
  7. 1974The Irish National Liberation Army (INLA) was established.
  8. January 1974the Sunningdale Agreement initially led to the formation of a power-sharing executive
  9. 1986The Continuity IRA (CIRA) emerged from a split.
  10. 1997The Real IRA (RIRA) formed following internal disagreements about the Good Friday Agreement.

1. Unionist Rule and Catholic Discrimination

★ Must-know

  • T. BARTLETT describes the maintenance of partition, rather than the defence of the Union, as the raison d’être of Unionism.

  • Northern Ireland was designed as a Protestant bulwark, and systemic discrimination excluded Catholics from political and economic power.

  • Catholics, who made up 35% of Northern Ireland’s population, accounted for more than 50% of its unemployed.

Further detail

  • After 1921, Catholic nationalism guided Southern Ireland, which became the Republic of Ireland in 1949, while Protestant Unionism guided Northern Ireland.

  • Examples of discrimination included: hostile Protestant workplaces at Belfast docks, underfunded Catholic schools, gerrymandered constituencies, a Protestantized Royal Ulster Constabulary

  • Parallel societies reinforced Protestant-Catholic divisions, allowing people in Belfast or Derry to spend their lives without socialising across the communal divide.

  • The 1920 Government of Ireland Act included safeguards against religious discrimination for both the Catholic minority in Northern Ireland and the Protestant minority in Southern Ireland.

  • Successive Protestant politicians pursued short-term Protestant unity at the expense of accommodating part of the Catholic community, leaving Catholic alienation as the Unionist state’s Achilles’ heel.

2. Welfare, Modernisation and British Nonintervention

★ Must-know

  • British post-Second World War welfare provisions, including the NHS, the welfare state and education Acts for mass education, applied in Northern Ireland regardless of religious confession and blunted some effects of systemic discrimination.

  • London did not introduce policies targeting systemic discrimination in Northern Ireland because it was unwilling to interfere after the Irish question had burdened British politics for centuries.

Further detail

  • British welfare measures modernised Northern Ireland but gave little consideration to its deeply segregated and sectarian society.

  • The Home Rule crisis and the ensuing Irish civil war discouraged London from intervening in Northern Ireland’s community relations for fear of renewed political violence.

Memory Hook

Welfare measures softened discrimination’s effects, while British reluctance left its causes intact

3. Catholic Confidence and Political Stagnation

Key Concepts & Definitions

  • Ecumenism: A modern unity movement among liberal Protestants, Roman Catholics and Eastern Orthodox churches.

★ Must-know

  • By the early 1960s, Catholics made up approximately 20% of university students in Northern Ireland.

  • The growth of a Catholic middle class and a more educated, articulate and politically conscious young generation encouraged demands for greater political representation, social equality and economic opportunities.

  • Despite economic modernisation in the 1960s, Northern Ireland’s Unionist establishment remained reluctant to make political reforms addressing longstanding Catholic grievances.

Further detail

  • British educational reforms broadened access to secondary and higher education in Northern Ireland for both Protestants and Catholics, but their effects took nearly two decades to appear.

  • Under Pope John XXIII, the Catholic Church embraced greater ecumenism, particularly through the Second Vatican Council.

  • John F. Kennedy’s election to the American presidency in 1960 carried symbolic significance because an Irish-American Catholic headed one of the world’s two superpowers for the first time.

  • Between partition in 1921 and the early 1960s, Northern Ireland’s political institutions changed remarkably little and Catholics remained largely excluded from political power.

Memory Hook

Social and educational progress contrasted with political stagnation

4. Short-Term Causes of Conflict

★ Must-know

  • Economic modernisation heightened Protestant fears that change would erode Protestant identity and undo the plantation.

  • The increasingly assertive Catholic middle class focused on discrimination in housing allocation and the gerrymandering of electoral constituencies rather than reunification with the Republic of Ireland.

Further detail

  • T. Bartlett described 1966 as “the year when the wheels began to come off the NI experiment in economic modernisation without political reform.”

  • Reverend Ian Paisley, founder and leader of the Free Presbyterian Church, portrayed O’Neill’s tentative overtures as a betrayal of Ulster, Protestantism and the Union.

  • Paisley’s evangelical working-class followers opposed what they saw as mainstream Protestantism’s Romeward slide and feared concessions to Catholics would threaten Protestant survival.

  • Protestant unease coincided with the re-emergence of the Ulster Constitution Defence Committee, the Protestant Volunteer Corps and the re-formed UVF.

  • The 1947 Education Act widened educational opportunities, helping the Catholic middle class grow and become more articulate by the 1960s.

  • The Campaign for Social Justice, established in 1964, was one political campaign through which Catholics expressed their grievances.

Memory Hook

Social and educational progress opposed political stagnation

5. NICRA and the Escalation of Violence

★ Must-know

  • The Northern Irish Civil Rights Associations (NICRA) was formed in 1967 by socialists, left-wing republicans, trade unionists, IRA people and nationalist activists.

  • NICRA asserted that British subjects in Northern Ireland should have the same rights as British subjects in the United Kingdom, avoiding nationalist rhetoric.

  • In October 1968, an unauthorised civil rights march in Derry degenerated into serious rioting after the RUC deployed water cannon and attacked marchers, and the violence was captured on television.

  • British soldiers were sent to Northern Ireland in 1969 to maintain public peace after Stormont failed to maintain law and order.

Further detail

  • NICRA campaigned for: an end to gerrymandering under the slogan “one man, one vote”, fair and transparent allocation of public housing, an end to discrimination

  • Many historians regard 1968 as the beginning of serious political violence in the Troubles.

  • The Battle of the Bogside in Derry in 1969 was one incident associated with the re-emergence of the IRA.

  • Peter Ward, a young Catholic barman, was shot dead by UVF members in Belfast’s Shankill area in 1966, and the “new” UVF was outlawed.

Memory Hook

Campaigns, marches, riots, intervention

6. Structural and Immediate Causes

★ Must-know

  • Bartlett argued that Northern Ireland’s Protestant separatism, superiority and preference made the state unable to embrace reform and inclusion, since it had been established to protect and promote northern Protestant interests. - Thomas BARTLETT

  • Long-term causes of the Troubles included the longstanding marginalisation of Catholics within a Protestant political structure and a society stultified by a siege mentality that treated concessions to Catholics as threats to Ulster Protestantism.

  • Short-term causes included economic modernisation that alarmed loyalists, lack of political reform that angered an increasingly assertive Catholic middle class, sectarian rhetoric and the re-emergence of loyalist organisations including the UVF.

Further detail

  • Bartlett described poor and unimaginative political leadership as an added difficulty but identified the fundamental causes of collapse as structural and ideological.

  • Escalating sectarian tensions, reciprocal attacks, the revival of paramilitarism and Stormont’s inability to maintain law and order culminated in British military intervention.

Memory Hook

Political exclusion and fear of change → violent resistance

7. Political Protagonists

★ Must-know

  • The British Army played a central role in the conflict after troops were deployed in Northern Ireland in 1969 to restore law and order.

  • Constitutional nationalism was primarily represented by the Social Democratic and Labour Party (SDLP), while constitutional unionism was traditionally embodied by the Ulster Unionist Party (UUP).

  • Republican paramilitary organisations included:

    • the Provisional Irish Republican Army (PIRA)
    • the Continuity IRA (CIRA)
    • the Real IRA (RIRA)
    • the Irish National Liberation Army (INLA)

📌 The PIRA, CIRA and RIRA existed simultaneously as separate organisations that emerged through successive divisions within the broader republican movement.

  • Loyalist paramilitary organisations included:
    • the Ulster Defence Association (UDA)
    • the Ulster Volunteer Force (UVF)
    • the Red Hand Commando (RHC)

📌 The Troubles involved diverse political parties, paramilitary organisations and security forces rather than two homogeneous communities, and their interests, methods and objectives could differ.

Further detail

  • Sinn Féin represented political republicanism, while its relationship with the IRA remained contentious because membership overlap between the organisations was uncertain.

  • Disagreements over political objectives, strategy or the legitimacy of armed struggle could lead paramilitary organisations to split.

  • Political loyalism was notably represented by the Democratic Unionist Party (DUP).

Memory Hook

Political parties pursued constitutional or political aims, while paramilitary organisations engaged in armed struggle.

8. Internment and Bloody Sunday

Key Concepts & Definitions

  • Internment without trial: Allowed people to be imprisoned indefinitely without being formally charged or brought before a court.

★ Must-know

  • Bloody Sunday alienated the nationalist community, undermined the British Army’s credibility, contributed to increased support for the Provisional IRA and exposed the inability of Northern Ireland’s political institutions to contain the conflict.

Further detail

  • Operation Demetrius resulted in the arrest of 342 suspects, all drawn from the republican and nationalist community.

  • Because Operation Demetrius initially targeted republicans exclusively, it reinforced the perception that the state and British Army were acting against the nationalist community rather than impartially restoring law and order.

  • The Bloody Sunday march had been banned by the authorities, but demonstrators went ahead; after rioting broke out, armed units of the Parachute Regiment were deployed.

Memory Hook

Internment targeted nationalists → Bloody Sunday deepened alienation → Direct Rule replaced devolution.

9. Violence and the Sunningdale Era

★ Must-know

  • During the 1970s, violence became an almost daily occurrence in Northern Ireland, with recruits flocking to paramilitary organisations including the PIRA, UVF, RHC and UDA.

Further detail

  • The Shankill Butchers were a particularly brutal loyalist gang that emerged in the mid-1970s and later became an infamous symbol of sectarian violence.

  • Everyday violence included shootings, bomb attacks and sectarian assassinations, often with one or two men murdered in republican or loyalist areas in incidents that attracted little attention beyond the affected communities.

10. Bombing Campaigns and Sectarian Violence

★ Must-know

  • In July 1972, the Provisional IRA detonated 22 bombs across Belfast in approximately 80 minutes, killing nine people and injuring more than a hundred.

  • Operating primarily in Belfast from the mid-1970s, the Shankill Butchers abducted, tortured and murdered Catholics, often selecting victims simply because of their religion.

Further detail

  • The July 1972 bombing operation became known as Bloody Friday and remains one of the most notorious bombing operations of the Troubles.

📌 The nail bomb and the car bomb became recognisable symbols of the violence, and both were particularly associated with republican paramilitary campaigns.

  • Although the IRA did not invent the car bomb, it used the device extensively, and its destructive potential transformed Northern Ireland’s urban landscape.

  • Car-bomb threats led town centres to adopt checkpoints, barriers and restricted access, systematically reconfiguring many Northern Irish towns.

  • Both republican and loyalist paramilitary organisations committed atrocities, leaving civilians caught in an ongoing cycle of violence.

11. Sunningdale Agreement and Collapse

★ Must-know

  • The 1973 Sunningdale Agreement proposed a power-sharing executive to replace the system of government at Stormont before Direct Rule began in 1972.

  • The agreement sought broader representation for unionists and nationalists through power-sharing and proposed a Council of Ireland to facilitate cooperation between Northern Ireland and the Republic of Ireland.

  • In May 1974, a general strike organised by the Ulster Workers’ Council, supported by loyalist paramilitaries and anti-agreement unionists, brought Northern Ireland to a virtual standstill and precipitated the executive’s collapse.

Further detail

📌 Hardline unionists saw power-sharing and the Council of Ireland as threats to Northern Ireland’s place in the United Kingdom, while republican paramilitaries rejected anything short of Irish unity and remained committed to armed struggle.

  • Sunningdale came to symbolise the obstacles to political compromise and showed that negotiating a settlement did not ensure its implementation in a deeply divided society.

Memory Hook

Strike → executive collapse

12. Ulsterization and Managed Violence

Key Concepts & Definitions

  • Ulsterization: Ulsterization was the British government’s strategy of transferring greater responsibility for managing security to Northern Irish institutions as reliance on military intervention alone was judged unlikely to resolve the conflict.

★ Must-know

  • From the mid-1970s, violence receded somewhat but continued regularly, and the annual death toll generally exceeded one hundred throughout the second half of the decade.

  • Under Ulsterization, the British Army’s visibility and operational role were gradually reduced while the Royal Ulster Constabulary and the locally recruited Ulster Defence Regiment took greater responsibility for countering paramilitary violence.

Further detail

  • The phrase “acceptable level of violence,” associated with British Home Secretary Reginald Maudling, described an approach in which the authorities appeared willing to tolerate reduced, containable violence rather than eliminate it entirely.

13. Criminalization and Prison Status

Key Concepts & Definitions

  • Criminalization: Criminalization was the British government’s policy of presenting paramilitary violence as ordinary criminal activity rather than as a political conflict, in order to deny paramilitaries the political legitimacy they claimed.

★ Must-know

📌 Prisoners convicted of paramilitary offences committed after 1 March 1976 were not entitled to Special Category Status and had to wear prison uniforms and follow the rules for the general prison population.

Further detail

  • Special Category Status, introduced in 1972, gave some paramilitary prisoners privileges resembling those of prisoners of war, including organisationally grouped quarters and the ability to organise classes and aspects of prison life.

📌 Republican prisoners viewed the withdrawal of Special Category Status as a denial of the political nature of their struggle and resisted being treated as ordinary criminals.

Memory Hook

Political prisoners versus ordinary criminals

Test yourself

Take a 11-question practice quiz on Origins of the Troubles, with every answer explained.

1. Which purpose did T. Bartlett identify as Unionism’s raison d’être in Northern Ireland?

2. In a population of 1,000, Northern Ireland has 350 Catholics, and 120 of the 200 unemployed people are Catholic. Which conclusion matches the documented employment disparity?

Take the quiz →

Study with flashcards

Memorize the key concepts of Origins of the Troubles with 10 flashcards.

Which author described partition’s maintenance as Unionism’s raison d’être?

T. BARTLETT.

How did British postwar welfare provisions affect Northern Ireland across religious confessions?

They applied regardless of religious confession and blunted some effects of systemic discrimination.

Why did the Home Rule crisis and Irish civil war discourage London from intervening in Northern Ireland?

London feared renewed political violence.

See the flashcards →

Related classes

Make your own study guides

Upload your class notes and Revizly writes a study guide, a quiz and flashcards in about a minute.

Study guide maker