Study guide: The Gothic and Women’s Autonomy

Course Outline

  1. The Gothic’s Double Nature
  2. American Gothic Settings and Themes
  3. Poe and the Plot of Ligeia
  4. Narration and Uncertainty in Ligeia
  5. Gothic Isolation and Uncertain Perception
  6. Rowena’s Death and Apparent Return
  7. Ligeia’s Suspense and Monstrosity
  8. Gothic Monstrosity and Normality
  9. Women’s Roles and Social Control
  10. Gilman and The Yellow Wallpaper
  11. The Isolated Mansion and Nursery
  12. The Yellow Wallpaper and Rebellion
  13. Emily Dickinson’s Literary Independence
  14. The Funeral in the Speaker’s Mind
  15. Form and Rebellious Style

1. The Gothic’s Double Nature

★ Must-know

📌 The Gothic is subversive because irrational and supernatural events challenge Enlightenment confidence in reason and human control, creating space for emotions and instincts.

📌 The Gothic is conservative because it warns against irrational behavior and uses its negative consequences to encourage order, morality, conformity to dominant ideology and patriarchy, and maintenance of the status quo.

Further detail

  • English writer Horace Walpole first used “Gothic” in literature in The Castle of Otranto (1765), subtitled “A Gothic Story.”

Memory Hook

Gothic rebellion against rationalism also warns readers back toward order and morality.

2. American Gothic Settings and Themes

★ Must-know

  • Gothic isolation is emphasized and can make a setting a metonymy for a character’s psyche, especially insanity.

  • American Gothic themes include:

    • tension between real and supernatural events
    • the uncanny as something familiar yet strange
    • a combination of horror and romance

Further detail

📌 In American Gothic, wilderness is both a literal setting and a symbol associated with superstition and menace.

  • American Gothic settings include isolated, gloomy places such as decadent, secluded mansions and woods.

  • Gothic atmosphere is eerie and disturbing, with limited visibility created by partial lighting or darkness and by gaps in knowledge or understanding.

  • American Gothic also explores: death and decay, pleasure in the irrational, fascination with the macabre and morbidity, psychological disturbance, including insanity, anxiety, melancholy, and perversion, strange and unstable characters, blurred boundaries and the monster within, terror’s power over the human mind

Memory Hook

A gloomy isolated mansion mirrors a character’s troubled psyche.

3. Poe and the Plot of Ligeia

★ Must-know

  • Edgar Allan Poe (1809–1849) is identified as the master of the Gothic genre in the United States.

  • In “Ligeia,” the narrator recalls his first wife’s mysterious beauty; Ligeia falls ill and dies; he becomes an opium addict, moves to England, and marries Lady Rowena; Rowena falls ill and dies; and, as the narrator watches her corpse under opium, it appears to move and take on Ligeia’s features, which the fallen shroud reveals.

Further detail

  • Poe’s writing combines the irrational with the rational, fantasy with facts, and attention to content with attention to form.

  • Poe’s short story “Ligeia” was written in 1838.

  • The conventional short-story plot moves from an initial situation through escalating complications and suspense to a climax, then to an immediate outcome or resolution and a new status quo.

Memory Hook

Ligeia dies, Rowena dies, and Ligeia returns.

4. Narration and Uncertainty in Ligeia

Key Concepts & Definitions

  • Homodiegetic narrator: Narrator who belongs to the world of the story; the term combines “homo” (same) and “diegesis” (narrative or story).

★ Must-know

📌 Ligeia’s beauty is elusive and enigmatic, and the narrator is both delighted and appalled by it.

  • The narrator’s reliability is undermined by: his confession that his memory is faltering, his opium use, which alters his perceptions, his obsession with Ligeia, which reveals melancholy and a disturbed psyche

  • The narrator is the focaliser: he controls the account, which gives the reader only his perspective and creates an overall lack of visibility and knowledge.

  • Ligeia’s agony reveals a fierce, almost supernatural determination to cling to life and foreshadows the story’s later events.

Further detail

📌 Lady Rowena is presented as Ligeia’s opposite and replacement, with fair hair and blue eyes.

  • In “Ligeia,” the narrator bases his account on personal memories and presents himself as rational and cultivated.

  • The narrator’s intense focus on Ligeia’s eyes fragments her appearance into details, like an insect examined under a microscope, while suggesting that science cannot grasp the irrational.

Memory Hook

The narrator appears rational and cultivated, yet his memories and perceptions are unreliable.

5. Gothic Isolation and Uncertain Perception

★ Must-know

📌 Rowena’s apparent perception of a supernatural presence may result from her delirium, the narrator’s opium-induced hallucinations, or a supernatural event, and the story retains possible rational explanations.

  • The narrator moves to a remote, secluded abbey in England after Ligeia’s death, and its gloomy, dreary setting reflects his feelings of abandonment.

  • The narrator is the only focaliser, so the reader receives no independent account of events.

Further detail

  • The Gothic atmosphere combines:
    • isolation
    • death and decay
    • morbidity
    • vampirism

Memory Hook

Supernatural appearance versus rational explanation

6. Rowena’s Death and Apparent Return

★ Must-know

  • 🔄 The events unfold in this order:

    1. The narrator sees three or four ruby-colored drops fall into Rowena’s wine.
    2. Rowena’s illness rapidly worsens.
    3. She dies on the third subsequent night.
    4. On the fourth night, the narrator sits alone with her body.
  • The corpse stirs increasingly vigorously, life-like color returns to its face, and its limbs relax, although its eyelids remain closed and its grave wrappings remain in place.

Further detail

  • The narrator doubts that the ruby-colored drops were real, considering them possibly the product of imagination, Rowena’s terror, opium, and the late hour.

  • While alone with Rowena’s shrouded body, the narrator hears a distinct sob from the bed but detects no movement in the corpse.

Memory Hook

Ruby drops, worsening illness, death, then movement

7. Ligeia’s Suspense and Monstrosity

★ Must-know

  • The final recognition of “LADY LIGEIA” releases the tension by revealing a monstrous amalgamation of Ligeia and Lady Rowena, a hybrid perversion of life-in-death. - Edgar Allan Poe, “Ligeia”, 1838

  • In “Ligeia,” suspense builds by delaying the corpse’s awakening with repeated words, the narrator’s doubtful questions and digressions, and detailed descriptions of the figure’s face, elongating narrative time.

Further detail

📌 The corpse’s unnatural stir is juxtaposed with the narrator’s and reader’s inability to move, which creates a terrified freeze.

📌 The Gothic itself is described as a monstrous amalgamation of reason and mystery that never commits completely to either.

8. Gothic Monstrosity and Normality

★ Must-know

  • Gothic monstrosity reveals what lies beneath the façade of the normal world and exposes normality as a mask.

  • Gothic irrationality is often linked to:

    • grief
    • insanity
    • the oppressiveness of married life
    • female sexuality
    • racism
    • nonconformity
    • perversion
    • criminality
    • superstition

Further detail

  • The irruption of the uncanny and emotional irrationality exposes the hypocrisy of the rational world.

Memory Hook

The normal world wears a façade; the Gothic reveals what it conceals

9. Women’s Roles and Social Control

★ Must-know

📌 Women who complied with restrictive social rules were silenced and controlled, whereas women who showed self-assertion and determination were cast out and labeled monsters.

  • Women were prohibited from:

    • inheriting property
    • signing contracts
    • voting
    • serving on juries
  • Women’s participation in the Abolitionist movement offered a major opportunity to express their political potential.

Further detail

  • The marginalized alternatives were:

    • the spinster
    • the prostitute
    • the madwoman
  • Women were regarded as maternal, pure, decent, and virtuous, a set of qualities associated with the “Angel in the House” trope.

  • The prescribed path ran through these roles:

    • daughter
    • virgin fiancée
    • wife
    • mother
    • widow

Memory Hook

Compliance keeps women within prescribed roles; self-assertion makes them outcasts

10. Gilman and The Yellow Wallpaper

★ Must-know

  • Gilman’s short story “The Yellow Wallpaper” was written in 1892. - Charlotte Perkins Gilman

  • The narrator says her physician husband John believes she has only temporary nervous depression and a slight hysterical tendency, while she believes congenial work, excitement, and change would help her recover.

  • In “The Yellow Wallpaper,” a woman with postpartum depression is taken by her physician husband to a quiet estate for a rest cure, forbidden to do activities, and secretly keeps a journal in a former nursery with disturbing yellow wallpaper. - Charlotte Perkins Gilman, “The Yellow Wallpaper”, 1892

Further detail

  • Charlotte Perkins Gilman (1860–1935) was an internationally famous feminist intellectual, speaker, writer, and editor who ran her own magazine, The Forerunner.

  • Gilman rejected motherhood as women’s destiny and divorced her husband.

  • After her husband faints at the sight of her, the narrator continues creeping over his unconscious body, convinced she has become the freed woman from the wallpaper. - Charlotte Perkins Gilman, “The Yellow Wallpaper”, 1892

  • Her prescribed regimen includes:

    • phosphates or phosphites
    • tonics
    • journeys
    • air
    • exercise
  • The narrator secretly writes despite the opposition and says that writing exhausts her because she must hide it.

  • The narrator becomes obsessed with the wallpaper’s pattern and sees a trapped woman moving behind it while her husband dismisses her feelings as irrational. - Charlotte Perkins Gilman, “The Yellow Wallpaper”, 1892

  • At the climax, the narrator locks herself in the room and tears the wallpaper to free the woman she imagines inside, then crawls around like an animal as her husband bursts in. - Charlotte Perkins Gilman, “The Yellow Wallpaper”, 1892

Memory Hook

Rest cure, wallpaper obsession, attempted liberation, collapse

11. The Isolated Mansion and Nursery

★ Must-know

  • The narrator describes the nursery as a large, airy room occupying nearly the whole top floor, with windows in every direction, barred windows, and rings in the walls.

  • The story’s mansion is interpreted as haunted and isolated, creating a sense of oppression and confinement.

Further detail

  • The mansion has a large, shady garden with box-bordered paths, grape-covered arbors, and broken greenhouses.

  • The narrator says that her husband made the move for her sake and prescribed rest and as much fresh air as she could get.

Memory Hook

The airy nursery promises rest, yet barred windows and wall rings suggest confinement.

12. The Yellow Wallpaper and Rebellion

★ Must-know

  • In “The Yellow Wallpaper,” the wallpaper room is interpreted as a projection of a patriarchal system that treats women unequally, denies them power, and controls them.

  • The narrator perceives a woman behind the wallpaper pattern who shakes it and struggles to climb through.

  • Recognizing herself in the woman trapped behind the wallpaper is interpreted as an act of rebellion that raises the question of whether the narrator is mad or resisting the male rationality embodied by her husband.

Further detail

📌 The ending is ambivalent: the husband’s fainting reverses gender roles and marks a collapse of patriarchal authority, while the narrator’s apparent liberation comes at the cost of her sanity.

  • The pattern is described as strangling the women who get through it and turning them upside down.

  • The story’s account of its narrator’s condition is interwoven with descriptions of the house and marriage, linking all three.

Memory Hook

A woman trapped behind a wallpaper pattern shakes its bars, mirroring the narrator’s confinement.

13. Emily Dickinson’s Literary Independence

★ Must-know

  • Dickinson redefined the meaning of the patriarchal home from within. - Emily Dickinson

  • Dickinson freely ignored the rules of metrics and versification and created her own style. - Emily Dickinson

Further detail

  • Emily Dickinson (1830–1886) was a nonconformist poet who lived a secluded life and was described as invalid and recluse.

14. The Funeral in the Speaker’s Mind

★ Must-know

  • In “I felt a Funeral, in my Brain” (1862), the speaker observes her funeral from inside a coffin, called the “Box,” suggesting powerlessness and lack of agency. - Emily Dickinson

  • The poem presents dissociation and sensory overload as a profound split between body and mind, with hearing and sound overwhelming the other senses.

Further detail

📌 The poem’s ending leaves the speaker’s final “knowing” ambiguous: it may signal a breakdown, a breakthrough, or both.

  • In the final stanza, the speaker experiences physical and psychological collapse and falls through multiple layers of consciousness.

  • 🔄 The funeral unfolds in three stages:

    1. The mourners tread back and forth.
    2. The mourners sit during the service.
    3. They lift the coffin and begin the procession.

Memory Hook

Mourners tread, a service beats, the coffin moves, then reason breaks and the speaker falls.

15. Form and Rebellious Style

Key Concepts & Definitions

  • Slant rhyme: Slant rhymes are near rhymes that draw imperfect and ambiguous connections, including in the poem’s first and last stanzas.

★ Must-know

  • The poem uses a traditional stanza form and rhyme scheme, while its content remains eerie and unpredictable.

  • The juxtaposition of seemingly unrelated images contrasts the poem’s predictable formal rhythm with its eerie, unpredictable content, illustrating Dickinson’s rebelliousness from within.

Further detail

  • Dashes slow the poem’s rhythm and add significance to particular ideas or images.

  • Capitalization highlights words that Dickinson wants to emphasize.

Memory Hook

Predictable poetic form contrasts with eerie, unpredictable content.

Test yourself

Take a 36-question practice quiz on The Gothic and Women’s Autonomy, with every answer explained.

1. A story presents supernatural events that defeat a protagonist’s attempts to explain and control the world through reason, while giving voice to the protagonist’s instincts. Which function of the Gothic does this illustrate?

2. A Gothic tale depicts the harmful consequences of reckless behavior and uses them to encourage readers to uphold prevailing morality and social conventions. Which function is at work?

Take the quiz →

Study with flashcards

Memorize the key concepts of The Gothic and Women’s Autonomy with 88 flashcards.

Why is the Gothic considered subversive of Enlightenment thought?

Its irrational and supernatural events challenge confidence in reason and human control.

What does the Gothic’s challenge to Enlightenment reason make room for?

Emotions and instincts.

Why is the Gothic considered conservative?

It warns against irrational behavior through its negative consequences.

See the flashcards →

Related classes

Make your own study guides

Upload your class notes and Revizly writes a study guide, a quiz and flashcards in about a minute.

Study guide maker