Study guide: Small Group Roles and Leadership

Course Outline

  1. Small Group Definitions and Elements
  2. Group Formation, Cohesion, Storming, and Conflict
  3. Norming and Group Stability
  4. Performing and Adjourning Phases
  5. Small Group Goals and Tasks
  6. Norms, Functions, and Types
  7. Explicit Norms and Group Expectations
  8. Positions, Roles, and Group Functions
  9. Leadership Emergence and Traits
  10. Autocratic and Democratic Leadership
  11. Working Climate and Group Success
  12. Small Group Communication Networks
  13. Small Group Benefits and Challenges
  14. Creative Problem-Solving Techniques
  15. Conformity and Groupthink

1. Small Group Definitions and Elements

Key Concepts & Definitions

  • Small group communication: Zeuschner, as cited in Cleary (2003: 37), defines small group communication as a collection of 3–12 individuals involved in face-to-face interaction to achieve a common goal.

Essential Points

  • The elements that enable a small group to achieve its purpose are:
    • a small number of members
    • intragroup interaction
    • a connection through a common goal
    • organising rules understood by all members

2. Group Formation, Cohesion, Storming, and Conflict

Key Concepts & Definitions

  • Group cohesion: Hargie, 2011 - Members' commitment to the group's purpose and the degree of attraction among individuals within the group.

★ Must-know

📌 Functional conflict strengthens interpersonal relationships and understanding and can increase performance and productivity, whereas dysfunctional conflict breaks down communication, produces little or no understanding, and is associated with poor performance and productivity.

  • During forming, members identify: who is involved, what must be achieved, why the task was given, when it is due, how it will be achieved, one another's strengths and weaknesses, communication patterns

  • During storming, members negotiate the group's objectives and strategies, and differing ideas or perspectives may cause conflict.

Further detail

  • Groups return to forming when membership changes, spending time re-establishing relationships and the group's work even when only one or two people join.

  • Factors influencing the early tone and climate of a group include (Ellis & Fisher, 1994):

    • members' personalities
    • members' skills
    • available resources
    • group size
    • the group's charge
  • An external charge, in which people outside the group decide its goal or purpose, can reduce uncertainty about the task and group roles, but excessive imposed structure can create resentment or powerlessness.

  • Conflict does not occur in every group, and a group can survive storming when members understand one another's perceptions and priorities.

  • The four phases of group development, in order, are forming, storming, norming, and performing; adjourning is an additional phase when members have completed the task and are no longer expected to work together.

3. Norming and Group Stability

Key Concepts & Definitions

  • Group norms: Ellis & Aubrey, 1994 - Behaviours that become routine without being explicitly taught or stated, helping set expectations for what members ought to do and how they ought to behave.
  • Group rules: Explicitly stated guidelines for members that may specify expected performance levels or output, attitudes, or dress codes.

★ Must-know

  • Conformity pressure can help or harm a group; people often conform to avoid feeling abnormal, while excessive pressure can cause isolation and a negative group climate (Ellis & Fisher, 1994: 128).

  • During norming, members collaborate more, establish basic group rules and procedures, and solidify shared practices and expectations, increasing group stability, productivity, and cohesion.

Further detail

📌 Violations of group rules typically receive more explicit punishment than violations of group norms.

  • Group norms commonly concern:

    • politeness
    • lateness
    • communication patterns
  • Challenging a norm that is not working may return a group to storming, while challenging norms without good reason may lead to punishment or conflict.

  • During norming, members increasingly agree on their roles, typical interaction patterns, and the group's direction; emerging leaders gain support and group identity solidifies.

  • Group rules may be communicated through (Hargie, 2011):

    • verbal instructions
    • employee handbooks
    • membership policies
    • codes of conduct
  • Groups may use procedures such as Robert’s Rules of Order to manage conversation flow and decision-making.

Memory Hook

Shared norms create predictability → stability and readiness to perform.

4. Performing and Adjourning Phases

Key Concepts & Definitions

  • Adjourning stage: The phase in which a group dissolves after completing its purpose, losing membership or support, or being dissolved for another internal or external cause.

★ Must-know

📌 In the performing phase, roles may be assigned according to members’ experience and competence to support specialization and effectiveness, or assigned randomly without regard to those qualifications.

  • In the performing phase, group members become goal-oriented and are assigned specific roles and functions to perform.

Further detail

  • Some groups continue indefinitely without experiencing the adjourning stage, while severe storming conflict can lead other groups to dissolve before norming or performing.

  • For groups with high social cohesion, adjourning may be emotionally difficult, while groups with negative experiences may welcome it.

  • Group experiences may develop:

    • interpersonal skills
    • listening skills
    • empathetic skills
    • cultural knowledge
    • new perspectives
  • Guided reflection during adjourning helps groups recognize accomplishments and learn lessons that may benefit future interactions.

5. Small Group Goals and Tasks

Key Concepts & Definitions

  • Goal: The final outcome or end-product that a group hopes to achieve, and it should be realistic and attainable.
  • Task: An activity implemented to achieve a group’s goal.

Essential Points

  • A company seeking to increase annual profits may meet with its marketing department to plan more advertisements as a task supporting that goal.

6. Norms, Functions, and Types

Key Concepts & Definitions

  • Group norms: Recognized rules of behavior that guide how members act, communicate, and participate, and they may be conscious and formal or unconscious and informal.

★ Must-know

📌 Norms may be explicit or implicit; implicit norms are hidden until transgressed, while explicit norms are stated or written directly.

  • According to Hackman (1996), norms govern behavior rather than private thoughts and feelings, so public compliance is sufficient even without private acceptance.

  • Feldman (1984) identifies four functions of workgroup norms:

    • facilitating group survival
    • simplifying expected behavior
    • helping members avoid embarrassing situations
    • identifying the group and expressing its central values to others
  • Engelberg and Winn (2021) identify four types of group norms:

    • interaction norms guide communication
    • procedure-oriented norms guide group operations and rituals
    • status norms concern hierarchy and power
    • achievement norms set performance and productivity standards

Further detail

  • Group members may be expected to attend meetings, focus on group work rather than personal distractions, and finish their assigned work by the established deadline.

  • Norm violations can frustrate group members and negatively affect the group’s overall goal.

  • According to Hackman (1996), workgroup norms regulate and regularize member behavior by summarizing and simplifying group influence processes.

  • According to Hackman (1996), norms usually concern behaviors considered important by most group members and develop gradually, although group needs can accelerate their development.

  • According to Hackman (1996), a norm may apply only to particular group members, such as newcomers or senior members, or vary by gender or race.

  • Implicit norms may be communicated through:

    • facial expressions
    • body language
    • posture

7. Explicit Norms and Group Expectations

Key Concepts & Definitions

  • Explicit norm: A rule stated or written clearly and directly, leaving little room for confusion or misunderstanding.

Essential Points

  • Examples of group norms include: respecting others’ viewpoints, being on time, having each member participate and contribute to discussion

8. Positions, Roles, and Group Functions

Key Concepts & Definitions

  • Position: The part a member plays in a group, together with the responsibilities and rights attached to it.
  • Role: The behaviour associated with the position a group member holds and the tasks the member is expected to fulfil.

Essential Points

  • Group positions may be formal and specialised or informal, and a position is linked to its title.

  • Examples of group positions include:

    • chairperson
    • secretary
    • timekeeper
    • scribe
    • treasurer
    • committee member
  • A secretary’s position requires accurately recording the minutes at every meeting, and the secretary’s role includes being organised and thorough.

Memory Hook

A position is the part and rights; a role is the behaviour expected in that position.

9. Leadership Emergence and Traits

Key Concepts & Definitions

  • Group task role: Focuses members on achieving the group’s task or goal through a structured approach to decision-making, progress summaries, updates, and attention to time and deadlines.
  • Group maintenance role: Supports cohesion, good relationships, member satisfaction, and productivity by reflecting on group behaviour and resolving conflict quickly.
  • Individual role: Prioritises a member’s own needs and interests over the group’s, often obstructing its common goal and creating conflict; it is dysfunctional and counter-productive.
  • Leadership: Zeuschner, 2003 - Any behaviour that influences a group.
  • Personality traits: Habitual patterns of thought, behaviour, and emotion that remain relatively stable across time and situations, although individuals can learn to adapt or control them.
  • Interactionist approach: Considers both personality and skills in relation to the circumstances and needs of the group.

★ Must-know

  • The four group-member roles are:

    • group task
    • group maintenance
    • individual
    • leadership
  • Factors contributing to an individual becoming a leader are:

    • personality traits (internal)
    • the situation (external)
    • the interactionist approach (both)

Further detail

  • Understanding their roles can make group members more effective, roles emerge as members perform tasks, and fulfilling the roles helps the group achieve its common goal.

  • Group task role members may minimise conflict, for example by asking members to vote, because they view conflict as wasting time and disrupting task completion.

  • Leader traits named in the material include:

    • initiative
    • perseverance
    • problem-solving
    • motivating others
    • self-confidence
  • Situational leadership arises when a person has the competence or skills needed to solve a problem or meet the group’s needs, and that person may no longer be needed as leader once the problem is solved or goal achieved.

10. Autocratic and Democratic Leadership

Key Concepts & Definitions

  • Autocratic leadership: Gives the leader authority to direct group decisions and task completion, with little input or discussion from members.
  • Democratic leadership: Encourages all group members to participate in decision-making and consults them about proposed actions and decisions.

★ Must-know

  • Democratic leadership is valued because it:

    • satisfies members through participation
    • fully uses group resources
    • encourages creativity
  • A laissez-faire leader takes no initiative or gives the group a specific direction, allows it to develop independently even through mistakes, and does not take a hands-on role in decisions, although members may consult the leader.

Further detail

📌 Laissez-faire leadership can be effective when group members are competent, with the necessary skills and experience, and self-motivated.

  • Leadership style influences the quality and quantity of group work and the group’s communication patterns.

  • Autocratic leaders typically: issue commands, set group policies, make decisions for the group, reward or punish performance, focus on tasks, hold firm views about how goals should be achieved

  • Autocratic leadership can be effective when: members lack experience or knowledge and the leader is an expert, a decision is needed quickly in a crisis, high output is needed in a short time

  • Autocratic leadership can cause dissatisfaction and frustration when members are skilled or knowledgeable enough to decide for themselves, and discouraging creative input can prevent members from working to their full potential.

  • Democratic leaders provide guidance while allowing members to use initiative, determine their direction, develop their own goals and procedures, and make decisions with reinforcement or alternative suggestions from the leader.

  • Democratic leadership is effective when there is enough time for discussion and members provide good input; it is less effective when input is not relevant or differences in status, education, experience, or skills make members hesitant to participate.

  • Democratic leadership encourages good member input, but participation may be limited when members differ in status, education, experience, or skills.

  • Laissez-faire leadership may reduce productivity, especially when output matters, because some members need hands-on leadership and may not adapt to this style.

Memory Hook

Autocratic leaders decide; democratic leaders consult and encourage participation.

11. Working Climate and Group Success

Key Concepts & Definitions

  • Group climate: The relatively enduring tone and quality of group interaction experienced similarly by group members.

★ Must-know

📌 A supportive and safe climate listens to and respects individuals and treats them fairly, consistently, and objectively, whereas a defensive and hostile climate undermines, patronises, ridicules, judges, or manipulates them.

  • Successful groups require: no more than 12 members, a positive working climate, trust, support, honesty, and openness among members, commitment to group goals

  • Effective group listening attends to both what is said and how it is said, including non-verbal communication, and requires empathy.

  • A defensive climate can: hinder accurate communication, distort messages and cause misunderstanding or conflict, make members withdrawn and guarded, encourage inaccurate judgments, discourage participation and questions, create a cycle of defensive behaviour

Further detail

  • Working-climate language may be objective and unbiased, such as stating that working hours are from 8:00 until 16:00, or biased and subjective, such as claiming that everyone leaves early or staff are never available to help.

  • Good listening helps members understand one another, build relationships, solve problems, cooperate, and feel understood, motivated, and valued, while poor listening can cause frustration, misunderstanding, confusion, conflict, relationship breakdown, and reduced productivity.

Memory Hook

Defensive climate → distorted messages → misunderstanding and conflict.

12. Small Group Communication Networks

Key Concepts & Definitions

  • Communication network: A pattern created by the way individuals communicate within a group.

★ Must-know

📌 A centralised network depends on a central person for intra-group communication, whereas a decentralised network allows communication to take place freely.

  • Centralised networks suit repetitive or simple tasks, such as running a meeting or planning a group project, but can overload the central person and enable gatekeeping that blocks or withholds information.

  • In the Wheel network, all members communicate through a central person rather than directly with one another; it allows urgent matters to be discussed when time is limited and ensures output, but requires strong leadership and cooperative members.

  • The Circle network gives everyone an equal say, while the Circle with a leader adds order to discussion and decision-making and allows members to communicate with both the leader and one another.

Further detail

  • In a centralised network, the central person has high morale and power, does much of the work, and is most satisfied, while other members usually have low morale and may be dissatisfied.

  • In the Y-pattern, a central person makes decisions on other people's behalf without encouraging their input.

  • The Circle with a leader is commonly used by:

    • people at the same hierarchical level
    • discussion groups working on projects
    • brainstorming groups
  • Decentralised networks suit smaller groups, but their unstructured nature can make them ineffective for productivity.

Memory Hook

Centralised communication passes through a hub; decentralised communication flows among members.

13. Small Group Benefits and Challenges

★ Must-know

📌 Conventional problem-solving uses a logical sequence of steps to solve a problem, whereas creative problem-solving starts with an identified problem and focuses on finding solutions.

  • Small groups increase workforce and productivity by subdividing work and responsibilities, and increase brainpower through shared ideas and perspectives that support problem-solving and decision-making.

  • Small groups can make decisions and solve problems more slowly because more people must be consulted, and some members may be uncooperative, making the group ineffective and divided.

  • Task groups or work teams focus on: accomplishing a goal or project, finding the best problem-solving strategy, developing a strategy to implement a specific plan

  • Conventional problem-solving proceeds by defining the problem, establishing acceptable solution criteria, identifying possible solutions, evaluating each solution against the criteria, and choosing the solution that meets the criteria or is the best fit.

Further detail

  • Group members may feel accepted and valued for their contributions, and the group may become more unified because members understand that the outcome results from everyone's contribution.

  • Small groups may: produce more talk than action, form cliques, become too large to remain effective, suffer from members shifting responsibilities to others

  • Within organisations, task groups or work teams are formed.

  • A shortage of computers is given as a possible cause of human-resources staff missing monthly deadlines; possible solutions include borrowing five spare computers from accounts or buying two computers as a short-term solution.

Memory Hook

Shared effort adds brainpower and workforce, but also takes time and coordination.

14. Creative Problem-Solving Techniques

★ Must-know

  • Creative problem-solving is used after the problem has been identified and focuses on finding solutions rather than identifying the problem or establishing criteria.

  • Brainstorming generates many ideas without evaluating them during idea generation, records all ideas, ends when no further ideas are offered, and then evaluates the suggestions to choose the best solution.

  • In the nominal group technique, members first generate and write down solutions individually without seeing others’ ideas, then return to the group and share their ideas.

Further detail

  • Brainstorming avoids evaluating ideas during generation because evaluation can slow the process, limit the number of ideas, and discourage members whose ideas are rejected.

  • The nominal group technique is preferred to brainstorming because members may evaluate ideas during brainstorming, claim to have others’ ideas, or feel intimidated by higher-status members such as a manager.

Memory Hook

Brainstorming shares ideas together; nominal groups generate ideas apart before sharing.

15. Conformity and Groupthink

Key Concepts & Definitions

  • Conformity: Following a group’s accepted behaviour or beliefs rather than going against what the group does or thinks.
  • Groupthink: Janis, 1972 - A negative group phenomenon in which high cohesion or conformity pressure leads to a lack of critical evaluation of proposed ideas or courses of action.

★ Must-know

  • Groupthink is associated with limited consideration of alternatives, reluctance to review decisions, little discussion of rejected options, and selective acceptance of information consistent with group beliefs.

Further detail

  • Internal conformity pressures include members’ personality traits and self-regulation; internalized norms can produce guilt or shame when violated and encourage corrective behaviour. - Ellis & Fisher, 1994

  • External conformity pressures include: group policies and probation periods, leaders’ praise or punishment, rewards or punishments tied to the whole group’s performance

  • Appropriate and ethical conformity pressure can strengthen cohesion, satisfaction with membership, relationships, task performance, and the group’s external image and reputation. - Hargie, 2011

  • Factors that can lead to groupthink include: (Ellis & Fisher, 1994): high social cohesion that discourages criticism, high task cohesion that creates a sense of invincibility, internal pressure to defer to leaders or the majority, impending rewards or punishments, time pressure, an aggressive leader

  • Conflict can help a group succeed when it prevents groupthink.

  • Groups can reduce groupthink by distributing decision-making responsibilities, recording contributions, encouraging minority opinions, collecting ideas before discussion, questioning major decisions and playing devil’s advocate, seeking outside review, and allowing a reflection period before implementation. - Hargie, 2011

Memory Hook

Excessive conformity and cohesion → uncritical agreement (groupthink).

Synthesis Tables

Four Types of Group Norms

TypeGoverns
InteractionCommunication approach
Procedure-orientedOperational rules and rituals
StatusHierarchy and power dynamics
AchievementPerformance and productivity standards

Test yourself

Take a 49-question practice quiz on Small Group Roles and Leadership, with every answer explained.

1. A community group disbands after completing the purpose for which it was formed. What phase does this represent?

2. During a brainstorming session, a facilitator records every suggestion and asks members to withhold judgments until ideas stop flowing. What should the group do next?

Take the quiz →

Study with flashcards

Memorize the key concepts of Small Group Roles and Leadership with 88 flashcards.

How does Zeuschner define small group communication?

Face-to-face interaction among 3–12 individuals working toward a common goal.

Which source is credited with the small group communication definition?

Zeuschner, 2003.

What elements enable a small group to achieve a specific purpose?

Few members, intragroup interaction, a common goal, and shared organising rules.

See the flashcards →

Related classes

Make your own study guides

Upload your class notes and Revizly writes a study guide, a quiz and flashcards in about a minute.

Study guide maker