Study guide: American Federalism

Course Outline

  1. Federalism and Constitutional Balance
  2. Constitutional Powers and State Relations
  3. Federalism Through Historical Models
  4. Grants and Devolution
  5. Intergovernmental Cooperation and Conflict
  6. Competition and Policy Innovation
  7. Federalism’s Benefits and Costs

1. Federalism and Constitutional Balance

Key Concepts & Definitions

  • Federalism: The constitutional division of power between national and state governments, with both levels possessing independent authority and responsibilities.

★ Must-know

  • The Framers created federalism to balance a strong national government, state autonomy, and protection against tyranny.

Further detail

  • Federalism allows the national government to handle broad issues while states address regional and local needs.

  • National government power has generally increased throughout U.S. history, and the Supreme Court has played a major role in defining federal-state relationships.

Memory Hook

National strength balances state autonomy.

2. Constitutional Powers and State Relations

Key Concepts & Definitions

  • Enumerated Powers: Powers specifically granted to the national government in the Constitution, mainly in Article I, Section 8.
  • Implied Powers: Not directly stated in the Constitution but inferred from it through the Necessary and Proper Clause, also called the Elastic Clause.
  • Reserved Powers: Powers reserved for state governments and protected by the 10th Amendment.
  • Concurrent Powers: Powers shared by the national and state governments, including taxation, borrowing money, creating courts, and law enforcement responsibilities.
  • Commerce Clause: Found in Article I, Section 8, gives Congress power to regulate interstate and foreign commerce.
  • Police Powers: State authority to protect public health, safety, and welfare.

★ Must-know

📌 The Supremacy Clause establishes the Constitution and federal laws as the supreme law of the land, so federal law overrides conflicting state law.

Further detail

  • Major enumerated powers include:

    • coining money
    • declaring war
    • regulating interstate commerce
    • taxation
    • maintaining military forces
  • The creation of a national bank is an example of an implied power.

  • In McCulloch v. Maryland (1819), the Supreme Court strengthened implied powers and confirmed the constitutionality of a national bank.

  • Reserved powers include:

    • conducting elections
    • establishing education systems
    • regulating marriage
    • providing local law enforcement
  • The Full Faith and Credit Clause requires states to recognize other states’ legal acts and court decisions, including marriage licenses, court rulings, and contracts.

  • The Extradition Clause requires states to return fugitives charged with crimes to the state where the crime was committed.

  • The Privileges and Immunities Clause prohibits states from discriminating against citizens from other states.

  • In Gibbons v. Ogden (1824), the Supreme Court expanded federal authority over interstate commerce and recognized broad congressional authority over economic activity crossing state lines.

  • The Commerce Clause has been used to justify federal regulation of:

    • labor laws
    • civil rights legislation
    • environmental regulations
    • transportation and communication industries

3. Federalism Through Historical Models

Key Concepts & Definitions

  • Dual Federalism: A model emphasizing strict separation between national and state powers, with the national government mainly limited to enumerated powers and states retaining broad authority over local affairs.
  • Cooperative Federalism: A model in which federal and state governments work together on shared responsibilities, with their roles blending rather than remaining separate.
  • New Federalism: A political movement seeking to return greater power and authority to states, associated especially with Presidents Nixon and Reagan.

Essential Points

  • Dual federalism, often called layer cake federalism, was dominant from the founding era through the late 1800s.

  • Under dual federalism, states were viewed as primary protectors of citizens’ daily needs and liberties, while the national government focused more on foreign affairs, trade, and defense.

  • Cooperative federalism expanded heavily during Franklin D. Roosevelt’s New Deal, when states helped administer federal economic relief programs responding to the Great Depression.

  • Cooperative federalism continued during the Civil Rights Movement and Lyndon Johnson’s Great Society programs, which expanded social welfare and anti-poverty programs.

  • New Federalism seeks to: reduce federal government influence, increase state flexibility in policy implementation, decrease federal regulations and mandates

  • Major wars and national crises, including the Civil War, Great Depression, Civil Rights Movement, and COVID-19 pandemic, have strengthened federal authority.

  • The Commerce Clause and Necessary and Proper Clause are frequently used to justify federal authority expanding into broader areas of economic and social life.

Memory Hook

Picture a layer cake with distinct layers turning into a marble cake with blended responsibilities.

4. Grants and Devolution

Key Concepts & Definitions

  • Fiscal Federalism: The use of federal funding to influence policies and actions of state and local governments.
  • Categorical Grants: Federal grants designated for specific purposes, with strict rules and regulations attached to the funding.
  • Block Grants: Federal grants providing broader funding with fewer restrictions, allowing states greater flexibility in spending decisions.
  • Devolution: The transfer of powers and responsibilities from the national government to state governments.

Essential Points

  • Federal grants are a major source of state funding, and states are often dependent on federal money for large public programs.

  • Examples of categorical grant purposes include:

    • highway construction
    • Medicaid
    • school lunch programs
  • Community development programs and public health services are examples of block grant purposes.

  • Welfare reform during the 1990s gave states greater control over administration of social service programs.

📌 Supporters of devolution favor local control and flexibility, while critics warn it can create inequality between states and uneven services.

Memory Hook

Categorical grants constrain spending; block grants leave states more room.

5. Intergovernmental Cooperation and Conflict

Key Concepts & Definitions

  • Intergovernmental Cooperation: Occurs when federal, state, and local governments work together through shared funding and policy implementation.
  • Mandates: Federal requirements imposed on states.
  • Preemption: Occurs when the federal government overrides state or local laws that conflict with national law, based on the Supremacy Clause.

★ Must-know

📌 Funded mandates provide federal money for required actions, whereas unfunded mandates require state action without sufficient federal funding and are often criticized by states as costly burdens.

Further detail

  • Intergovernmental cooperation is important in:

    • disaster response
    • public health
    • transportation
    • education
  • Preemption commonly arises in:

    • immigration
    • environmental regulation
    • civil rights

Memory Hook

Funded mandates bring money; unfunded mandates impose costs.

6. Competition and Policy Innovation

Key Concepts & Definitions

  • Laboratories of Democracy: States functioning as testing grounds for new policies and programs, with successful policies sometimes adopted nationally.

★ Must-know

  • States compete for businesses, jobs, residents, and economic investment through differences in tax rates, business regulations, education quality, and public services.

  • Political polarization increases conflict between state and national governments, as states pursue different policies on immigration, voting laws, gun control, and abortion.

Further detail

  • States have served as testing grounds for marijuana legalization, health care reforms, and environmental regulations.

Memory Hook

States act as laboratories, testing policies before others adopt them.

7. Federalism’s Benefits and Costs

★ Must-know

  • Federalism encourages political participation through local elections, state legislatures, and national offices.

  • State and local governments are often more responsive to regional concerns and can tailor policies to local preferences and conditions.

  • Differences in state wealth and resources can produce unequal education, health care, and public services.

Further detail

  • Dividing authority among levels of government limits the ability of any one level to dominate and helps protect against tyranny.

  • States can experiment with policies, and successful ideas may spread to other states.

  • Marijuana laws can differ between states and the federal government, creating confusion and inconsistency.

  • Shared authority can delay policy responses during emergencies or national crises.

  • Multiple government levels performing similar functions can create duplication, increased bureaucracy, and administrative costs.

Memory Hook

Local flexibility enables innovation, while divided authority can produce inequality and delay.

Synthesis Tables

Federalism Models

ModelGovernment relationshipMain emphasis
Dual federalismDistinct responsibilitiesSeparation of national and state powers
Cooperative federalismBlended responsibilitiesJoint work on shared concerns
New FederalismPower shifted toward statesState flexibility and reduced federal influence

Test yourself

Take a 23-question practice quiz on American Federalism, with every answer explained.

1. A constitution gives national and state governments separate responsibilities and independent authority. What system does this establish?

2. Why did the Framers design a federal system with both a strong national government and state autonomy?

Take the quiz →

Study with flashcards

Memorize the key concepts of American Federalism with 49 flashcards.

What is federalism?

The constitutional division of power between national and state governments, each with independent authority and responsibilities.

What three goals did the Framers seek to balance through federalism?

A strong national government, state autonomy, and protection against tyranny.

What powers does the Constitution specifically grant the national government?

Enumerated powers.

See the flashcards →

Related classes

Make your own study guides

Upload your class notes and Revizly writes a study guide, a quiz and flashcards in about a minute.

Study guide maker