Study guide: Freedom, Morality and Determinism

Course Outline

  1. Freedom and Its Paradox
  2. Indifference and Human Choice
  3. Descartes on Free Will
  4. Gratuitous Action and Reason
  5. Deliberation, Regret, and Freedom
  6. Spinoza’s Determinism
  7. Determinism, Fatalism, and Oedipus's Fate
  8. La fatalité dans les récits
  9. La liberté selon Kant
  10. Schlick’s Spectrum of Constraint
  11. Merleau-Ponty Beyond Dualism
  12. Bourdieu on Social Determinism
  13. Sartre’s Existential Freedom
  14. Sartrean Bad Faith, Roles, Projects, and Actualized Possibilities
  15. Four Accounts of Freedom

1. Freedom and Its Paradox

Key Concepts & Definitions

  • External freedom: the absence of external constraint, expressed by the idea that one is free to do what one wants

★ Must-know

📌 Freedom from external constraint does not necessarily free a person from subjection to their own desires.

Further detail

  • The primitive sense of freedom, from Latin liber, describes a person who is neither enslaved nor imprisoned.

Memory Hook

External constraint may disappear while inner desire remains.

2. Indifference and Human Choice

Key Concepts & Definitions

  • Freedom of indifference: the ability to choose without a decisive reason when alternatives appear equally good or equally bad and no necessity determines the choice

★ Must-know

📌 The animal follows what attracts or repels it through instinct, while the human can reflect, doubt, compare, and choose.

Further detail

  • In the example of Buridan’s ass, the animal remains motionless when faced with perfectly balanced reasons, whereas a human can determine themselves.

3. Descartes on Free Will

Key Concepts & Definitions

  • Cartesian free will: Descartes - human freedom comes from a will able to affirm, deny, or suspend judgment

★ Must-know

📌 For Descartes, freedom of indifference is the weakest degree of freedom because it arises from ignorance and hesitation, whereas true freedom is a will guided by reason.

Further detail

📌 For Descartes, error occurs when the will affirms something beyond what the understanding clearly comprehends.

  • Cartesian freedom involves (Descartes):
    • doubting methodically
    • suspending judgment
    • mastering passions
    • acting with knowledge

Memory Hook

Clear understanding guides the will → greater freedom.

4. Gratuitous Action and Reason

Key Concepts & Definitions

  • Act gratuitous: an act entirely without an end or reason, such as pushing a stranger from a train

★ Must-know

📌 Leibniz’s principle of sufficient reason holds that every genuine human action has a reason, excluding an act wholly without motives. - Principes de la nature et de la grâce fondés en raison

Further detail

  • In Stanley Kubrick’s Orange Mécanique (1971), Alex and his gang commit extreme violence for pleasure, without seeking profit or acting from necessity.

  • The film depicts: the gratuitous assault of a writer and his wife, violence against a homeless man, destruction at the Korova Milkbar, a gang rape as an act of domination

Memory Hook

A supposedly motiveless act opposes Leibniz’s sufficient reason.

5. Deliberation, Regret, and Freedom

Essential Points

📌 Condillac argues that deliberation is a consequence of ignorance rather than proof of freedom, because an omniscient person would never deliberate.

  • Bergson argues that regret after an action gives us an intimate awareness that we could have acted otherwise.

Memory Hook

Condillac links deliberation to ignorance; Bergson links regret to freedom.

6. Spinoza’s Determinism

Key Concepts & Definitions

  • Liberté apparente: B. Spinoza, Lettre au très savant G. H. Schuller, 1667 - Consiste à être conscient de ses désirs tout en ignorant les causes qui les déterminent.

★ Must-know

📌 For Spinoza, true freedom is not free decree but free necessity: understanding and accepting the causes that shape us.

📌 Spinoza argues that people believe themselves free because they are conscious of their desires but ignorant of the causes determining them. - Lettre à Schuller

  • Dans sa lettre à G. H. Schuller, Spinoza explique que tout objet singulier est déterminé à exister et à agir selon une loi précise par une cause extérieure. - B. Spinoza, Lettre au très savant G. H. Schuller, 1667

Further detail

📌 Pour Spinoza, la contrainte d’un objet vient de sa détermination par des causes extérieures, tandis que la nécessité désigne le fait qu’il agit conformément à ces causes. - B. Spinoza, Lettre au très savant G. H. Schuller, 1667

  • For Spinoza, human actions follow the same causal laws of nature as the movement of a stone, and humans have no privileged status in nature.

  • Spinoza illustre la liberté apparente par une pierre consciente de son effort, qui croit poursuivre son mouvement parce qu’elle le désire. - B. Spinoza, Lettre au très savant G. H. Schuller, 1667

Memory Hook

A stone says “I choose to fall” while unaware of the cause pushing it.

7. Determinism, Fatalism, and Oedipus's Fate

Key Concepts & Definitions

  • Déterminisme: Affirme que tout événement est nécessairement déterminé par des causes antérieures et que les mêmes causes produisent le même effet.
  • Fatalisme: Affirme que les événements sont fixés d’avance par le destin, la providence, la nature ou le sort, et que rien ne peut changer leur cours.

★ Must-know

📌 Le déterminisme explique les événements par des causes nécessaires sans exclure l’action ni la responsabilité, tandis que le fatalisme affirme que toute action est vaine et nie la responsabilité.

  • Malgré ses efforts pour éviter la prophétie, Œdipe accomplit son destin en tuant son père et en épousant sa mère.

  • L’histoire d’Œdipe suit la chaîne de la prophétie, de son abandon, de sa découverte de ses origines, du meurtre involontaire de Laïos, de son mariage avec Jocaste, de la révélation, puis de son exil.

Further detail

  • Les causes de la chaîne causale peuvent être:
    • physiques
    • biologiques
    • psychologiques
    • sociales

Memory Hook

Le déterminisme explique les effets par des causes et laisse place à l’action ; le fatalisme tient le cours des choses pour immuable.

8. La fatalité dans les récits

Essential Points

  • Dans le récit du vizir de Bagdad, le vizir fuit à Samarkand après avoir rencontré la Mort à Bagdad, où celle-ci l’attendait précisément le soir même.

  • Les Parques tissent la naissance, la vie et la mort, et nul ne peut changer ce qui est écrit.

  • Clotho file le fil de la vie, Lachésis le mesure et Atropos le coupe, mettant fin à la vie.

  • Dans Minority Report, John Anderton est accusé d’un crime qu’il n’a pas encore commis, et ses tentatives pour changer son destin semblent le ramener à la prédiction.

  • Dans M le Maudit, M se croit incapable d’agir autrement et justifie ses crimes comme inévitables, tandis que la société, l’ignorance et les circonstances le maintiennent dans ce cercle fatal. - Fritz Lang, 1931

  • Dans Minority Report, les Pré-cogs voient l’avenir et la police arrête un individu avant qu’il ne commette un crime annoncé comme certain.

  • Dans M le Maudit de Fritz Lang, les actes de M sont présentés comme les conséquences de son caractère, de son passé et de son environnement plutôt que comme des choix libres.

9. La liberté selon Kant

Key Concepts & Definitions

  • Autonomie: Immanuel Kant - La capacité de se déterminer soi-même selon la raison et de se donner sa propre loi.
  • Autonomy: Giving oneself the law and being the subject of one’s actions rather than merely an object of desires or circumstances.
  • Categorical imperative: The universal moral principle: “Act only according to a maxim that you can at the same time will to become a universal law.”
  • Human dignity: That every human being must be treated as an end in themselves, never merely as a means.
  • State and law: A just state and universal law must guarantee freedom and make the free coexistence of individuals possible.

★ Must-know

  • Pour Kant, la liberté ne consiste ni à faire tout ce que l’on veut ni à être dépourvu de contraintes, mais à se donner sa loi et à agir par devoir selon la raison plutôt que par simple inclination. - Immanuel Kant, Critique de la raison pratique

  • Kant distinguishes inner freedom, which consists in giving oneself the law, from outer freedom, which consists in not being constrained by others.

  • For Kant, only a good will acting from duty is truly free, so freedom is linked to obedience to the moral law rather than satisfaction of desires.

Further detail

📌 Political freedom is necessary for Kant, but it must remain in the service of moral freedom.

📌 For Kant, individual freedom requires a legal framework and respect for the freedom of others.

  • Kant naît en 1724 à Königsberg et meurt en 1804. - Immanuel Kant

  • Kant est un philosophe allemand, une figure majeure des Lumières et professeur de logique et de métaphysique. - Immanuel Kant

  • Pour Kant, chaque personne a une valeur en soi et ne doit pas être traitée comme un simple moyen. - Immanuel Kant

  • In the Foundations of the Metaphysics of Morals, Kant states that freedom is the condition of morality and morality is the condition of freedom. - Fondements de la métaphysique des mœurs

Memory Hook

Agir par devoir selon la raison, plutôt que suivre une simple inclination.

10. Schlick’s Spectrum of Constraint

★ Must-know

  • Schlick’s spectrum has five degrees:

    • No constraint
    • Weak constraint through correlation or regularity
    • Probable constraint through an empirical law
    • Strong constraint through an imperative or rule
    • Logical or physical necessity
  • Moritz Schlick distinguishes degrees of constraint expressed by language, ranging from a simple statement of fact to logical or physical necessity.

Further detail

  • A simple factual statement, such as “It is raining today,” describes a state of affairs without asserting necessity or obligation.

  • A weak constraint expresses an observed regularity, such as “Cats sleep at night,” but does not claim an invariable law.

  • A probable constraint refers to a revisable empirical generalization, such as “This plant needs light,” which can be verified or falsified.

  • A strong constraint expresses a practical or moral obligation, such as “You must obey the law.”

11. Merleau-Ponty Beyond Dualism

Key Concepts & Definitions

  • Intentionality: Merleau-Ponty - The condition in which consciousness is anchored in the world and directed toward it without being reducible to it.

★ Must-know

📌 Merleau-Ponty’s account rejects both the human being as a mere thing confined to physical space and the human being as a pure spirit detached from the physical world.

Further detail

  • The human condition combines social and bodily embeddedness with the capacity to represent the causes that shape it. - Merleau-Ponty

Memory Hook

Neither a thing trapped in space nor a pure spirit detached from the world.

12. Bourdieu on Social Determinism

Key Concepts & Definitions

  • Symbolic violence: Bourdieu, Leçon sur la leçon, 1982 - A form of constraint sustained when dominated people, lacking other tools to understand their relation to the dominant, accept that relation as natural.

★ Must-know

📌 For Bourdieu, knowledge of social mechanisms can help determine the conditions and means for acting to control those mechanisms. - Leçon sur la leçon, 1982

Further detail

  • Awareness of social mechanisms can help create the political conditions for social change, as emancipation movements demonstrate. - Bourdieu, Leçon sur la leçon, 1982

  • Bourdieu gives the social reproduction of cultural capital as an example: cultural capital accrues to cultural capital, contributing to the school elimination of children least endowed with it. - Leçon sur la leçon, 1982

Memory Hook

Knowledge of social mechanisms → conditions for changing their effects.

13. Sartre’s Existential Freedom

Key Concepts & Definitions

  • Bad faith: Sartre - The evasion of freedom through the comfortable claim that determinism excuses one’s faults.

★ Must-know

📌 For Sartre, people are responsible for what they do after being thrown into the world, even though they did not create themselves. - L'existentialisme est un humanisme, 1946

  • For Sartre and existentialism, the human being enters the world without a predefined nature and is initially nothing.

  • Sartre describes the human being as condemned to be free and wholly responsible because no deterministic, biological, or divine excuse is valid.

  • In L'existentialisme est un humanisme (1946), Sartre argues that because existence precedes essence, there is no fixed human nature that determines conduct.

  • For Sartre, the human being projects themself toward the future and becomes what they are through their actions.

Further detail

📌 Sartre rejects passion as an excuse for action: people remain responsible for their passions rather than being carried inevitably into acts by them. - L'existentialisme est un humanisme, 1946

  • For Sartre, people interpret signs for themselves and are continually required to invent what it means to be human. - L'existentialisme est un humanisme, 1946

Memory Hook

Existence → project and action → the essence one becomes.

14. Sartrean Bad Faith, Roles, Projects, and Actualized Possibilities

Key Concepts & Definitions

  • Bad faith: Fleeing one's freedom by pretending to be determined by one's role, character, or circumstances.

★ Must-know

📌 For Sartre, unrealized possibilities do not constitute a person's actual achievements; a person's figure is shaped by the life and actions they carry out. - L'être et le néant, 1943

  • In L'être et le néant (1943), Sartre says that a person is nothing other than their project and exists only insofar as they realize it.

  • In Sartre's café-worker example, exaggeratedly precise gestures and movements show the worker performing the role of a café worker. - L'être et le néant, 1943

Further detail

📌 A person can perform a social role but cannot be that role in the fixed, self-identical way an object is what it is. - Sartre, L'être et le néant, 1943

  • Sartre says a café worker's duties and rights refer to abstract possibilities associated with a legal subject, rather than making the worker identical to the role. - L'être et le néant, 1943

  • Sartre describes the café worker as free to get up at five each morning or stay in bed and risk being dismissed. - L'être et le néant, 1943

  • Sartre identifies Proust's genius with the totality of Proust's works and Racine's genius with the series of his tragedies. - L'être et le néant, 1943

  • Sartre says a person's dreams, hopes, and expectations define them negatively when they remain unfulfilled, rather than positively as realized actions. - L'être et le néant, 1943

Memory Hook

The café worker performs a role; he is not identical to that role.

15. Four Accounts of Freedom

Essential Points

📌 In the freedom synthesis, Descartes defines freedom as willing with knowledge, while Kant defines it as autonomy and acting according to the moral law.

📌 In the freedom synthesis, Sartre links being condemned to be free with responsibility for one's choices, while Spinoza links greater freedom to understanding necessity.

Synthesis Tables

Accounts of Freedom

ThinkerFreedom means
DescartesWilling with knowledge
KantAutonomy and acting according to the moral law
SartreBeing condemned to freedom and responsible for one's choices
SpinozaUnderstanding necessity

Test yourself

Take a 30-question practice quiz on Freedom, Morality and Determinism, with every answer explained.

1. Which statements characterize the basic senses of freedom?

2. A person can act without external restrictions but still feel compelled by a powerful personal desire. Which statements best capture this tension?

Take the quiz →

Study with flashcards

Memorize the key concepts of Freedom, Morality and Determinism with 85 flashcards.

What is external freedom?

The absence of external constraint.

What idea expresses external freedom?

Being free to do what one wants.

What may remain despite freedom from external constraint?

Subjection to one's own desires.

See the flashcards →

Related classes

Make your own study guides

Upload your class notes and Revizly writes a study guide, a quiz and flashcards in about a minute.

Study guide maker