What is external freedom?
The absence of external constraint.
What idea expresses external freedom?
Being free to do what one wants.
What may remain despite freedom from external constraint?
Subjection to one's own desires.
What is freedom of indifference?
The ability to choose without a decisive reason when alternatives seem equally good or bad and no necessity determines the choice.
How does instinct guide an animal’s choices?
It guides the animal toward what attracts it or away from what repels it.
Which capacities allow humans to choose beyond instinct?
Humans can reflect, doubt, and compare.
What can humans do after reflecting, doubting, and comparing?
Choose.
According to Descartes, what enables human freedom?
The will’s ability to affirm, deny, or suspend judgment.
Which philosopher defined human freedom through the will’s choices?
Descartes.
According to Descartes, what makes freedom of indifference the weakest degree of freedom?
It arises from ignorance and hesitation.
According to Descartes, what guides true freedom?
Reason.
Which work states Leibniz’s principle of sufficient reason?
*Principes de la nature et de la grâce fondés en raison*.
What does Leibniz’s principle of sufficient reason require of genuine human actions?
Each must have a reason, excluding actions wholly without motives.
What does Condillac say deliberation reveals about human knowledge?
It results from ignorance, not freedom.
Which philosopher argues that an omniscient person would never deliberate?
Condillac.
What does Bergson say regret after an action makes us aware of?
That we could have acted otherwise.
According to Spinoza, why do people believe themselves free?
They know their desires but are ignorant of the causes determining them.
According to Spinoza, what constitutes true freedom?
Understanding and accepting the causes that shape us.
In which work and year did Spinoza explain how external causes determine singular objects?
B. Spinoza, Lettre au très savant G. H. Schuller, 1667.
What is apparent freedom according to Spinoza?
Being conscious of one’s desires while ignorant of the causes determining them.
What does determinism say determines every event?
Prior causes necessarily determine every event.
What does determinism say happens when the same causes recur?
They produce the same effect.
What does fatalism say fixes events in advance?
Destiny, providence, nature, or chance fixes them in advance.
How does determinism explain events?
Through necessary causes.
What sequence of events leads Oedipus from prophecy to exile?
Prophecy, abandonment, discovery of his origins, Laius’s accidental murder, marriage to Jocasta, revelation, and exile.
How does Oedipus fulfill his fate despite trying to avoid the prophecy?
He kills his father and marries his mother.
What does autonomy mean for Kant?
Determining oneself through reason and giving oneself one’s own law.
Which philosopher distinguishes degrees of constraint expressed by language?
Moritz Schlick.
Which five constraint degrees does Schlick distinguish?
No constraint, weak constraint, probable constraint, strong constraint, and logical or physical necessity.
Which two views of human beings does Merleau-Ponty reject?
The human as a mere physical thing and as a disembodied spirit.
Which philosopher rejects reducing humans to physical things or detached spirits?
Merleau-Ponty.
What is intentionality in Merleau-Ponty’s account?
Consciousness is anchored in and directed toward the world without being reducible to it.
Which philosopher defines intentionality as consciousness anchored in and directed toward the world?
Merleau-Ponty.
According to Bourdieu, how can knowledge of social mechanisms support control over them?
It can help determine the conditions and means for acting to control them.
Which work and year contain Bourdieu’s account of knowledge helping control social mechanisms?
*Leçon sur la leçon*, 1982.
According to Sartre, what is the human being initially?
Nothing, with no predefined nature.
According to Sartre, how does a person become what they are?
Through actions directed toward the future.
Which thinker describes people as condemned to be free and wholly responsible?
Sartre.
Which work and year contain Sartre’s argument that existence precedes essence?
*L'existentialisme est un humanisme* (1946).
Which work and year contain Sartre’s café-worker example of exaggeratedly precise gestures?
Sartre, L'être et le néant, 1943.
What does Sartrean bad faith involve regarding freedom and one’s role?
Fleeing one’s freedom by pretending to be determined by one’s role, character, or circumstances.
Which work and year state that a person is their project insofar as they realize it?
Sartre, L'être et le néant, 1943.
How does Descartes define freedom in the freedom synthesis?
Willing with knowledge.
How does Kant define freedom in the freedom synthesis?
Autonomy and acting according to the moral law.
What does Sartre link being condemned to be free with in the freedom synthesis?
Responsibility for one's choices.
How does Spinoza connect understanding necessity with freedom in the freedom synthesis?
Greater understanding of necessity brings greater freedom.
What does the primitive sense of freedom, from Latin liber, describe?
A person who is neither enslaved nor imprisoned.
What does Buridan’s ass do when reasons are perfectly balanced?
It remains motionless.
What can a human do when faced with perfectly balanced reasons, unlike Buridan’s ass?
Determine themselves.
According to Descartes, when does error occur?
When the will affirms what the understanding does not clearly comprehend.
Which philosopher explained error as the will exceeding clear understanding?
Descartes.
What does Cartesian freedom involve doing with passions?
Mastering them.
What is an act gratuitous?
An act entirely without an end or reason.
Which work depicts Alex and his gang committing violence for pleasure without profit or necessity?
Stanley Kubrick’s *Orange Mécanique* (1971).
Which acts of violence does *Orange Mécanique* depict?
An assault on a writer and his wife, violence against a homeless man, destruction at the Korova Milkbar, and a gang rape as domination.
According to Spinoza, what causal laws govern human actions?
The same causal laws of nature that govern a stone’s movement.
According to Spinoza, what determines an object under constraint?
External causes.
Which work contains Spinoza’s example of a stone conscious of its effort?
B. Spinoza, Lettre au très savant G. H. Schuller, 1667.
What kinds of causes can form the causal chain underlying determinism?
Physical, biological, psychological, and social causes.
Where does the vizier flee after meeting Death in Baghdad?
Samarkand.
What do the Fates weave, and can anyone change what is written?
They weave birth, life, and death, and no one can change what is written.
What does Atropos do to the thread of life?
She cuts it, ending life.
What do the Pre-Cogs see in Minority Report?
They see the future.
What crime is John Anderton accused of in Minority Report?
A crime he has not yet committed.
Which work and year present M’s actions as shaped by character, past, and environment?
Fritz Lang’s M le Maudit, 1931.
In which year was Immanuel Kant born?
1724.
What was Immanuel Kant’s profession and intellectual role?
He was a German philosopher, a major Enlightenment figure, and a professor of logic and metaphysics.
How does Kant say each person must be treated?
As valuable in themselves, never merely as a means.
In which work does Kant link freedom and morality as mutual conditions?
*Foundations of the Metaphysics of Morals*.
What does Kant’s categorical imperative require?
Act only on a maxim that you can will to become a universal law.
What does “It is raining today” assert about necessity or obligation?
Neither necessity nor obligation.
What does “Cats sleep at night” express without claiming an invariable law?
An observed regularity.
What kind of generalization can “This plant needs light” express?
A revisable empirical generalization.
What does “You must obey the law” express?
A practical or moral obligation.
What capacities combine in Merleau-Ponty’s account of the human condition?
Social and bodily embeddedness with the capacity to represent shaping causes.
Which philosopher describes humans as socially and bodily embedded yet able to represent shaping causes?
Merleau-Ponty.
What example does Bourdieu give of cultural capital reproducing itself?
Cultural capital accrues to cultural capital, contributing to the school elimination of children least endowed with it.
Which work and year present Bourdieu’s example of cultural capital’s social reproduction?
*Leçon sur la leçon*, 1982.
What political effect can awareness of social mechanisms help produce?
It can help create the political conditions for social change.
According to Bourdieu, what sustains symbolic violence?
Dominated people accept their relation to the dominant as natural because they lack other tools to understand it.
According to Sartre, what is bad faith?
Evasion of freedom by claiming determinism excuses one’s faults.
In Sartre’s account, what must people invent to interpret signs?
What it means to be human.
Which work and year state that a person can perform, but cannot simply be, a social role?
Sartre, L'être et le néant, 1943.
Which work and year connect a café worker’s duties and rights to abstract possibilities?
Sartre, L'être et le néant, 1943.
Which work and year describe the café worker’s choice to rise early or risk dismissal?
Sartre, L'être et le néant, 1943.
Answer 30 questions on Freedom, Morality and Determinism.
1. Which statements characterize the basic senses of freedom?
2. A person can act without external restrictions but still feel compelled by a powerful personal desire. Which statements best capture this tension?
Go over the full study guide for Freedom, Morality and Determinism.
Read the study guide →Upload your class notes and Revizly writes your flashcards in about a minute.
Flashcard maker