★ Must-know
Further detail
Magical thought’s social practices include:
Magical thought fills the world with animated entities, such as forces of good and evil, and connects everything with everything through holism and ancestor worship.
Magical thought’s preconcepts include: fatalism and predetermined destiny, sacredness attributed to Nature and holders of power, animism, totemism, unrestrained causality mixing valid knowledge and superstition, belief in hidden powers such as voodoo and mana, anthropomorphic beings such as deities and spirits, the supernatural or social efficacy of sacrifices
Magical thought enchants the world; reason opposes that enchantment.
★ Must-know
Reason pursues knowledge and action without supernatural forces or the excessive weight of powerful emotions, but with method, values, and ideals.
Reason develops systems as mental experiments, tests them against reality, and then applies them in practice; the systems may prove true, false, or approximate.
Further detail
📌 Reason is used rationally only through the conscious exercise of a precise method; using its conclusions outside that method or turning them into dogmas is a return to the irrational.
Reason arose somewhere on the shores of the Mediterranean a little less than a millennium before the Common Era, as far as surviving texts attest.
Reason seeks to empty the world of enchantment by eliminating supernatural entities and the behaviors accompanying them; its command is “Do not be afraid.”
Karl Popper describes reason as “letting our hypotheses die in our place.”
Reason’s systems can provide a coherent account of the world and produce conceptual or material tools that extend human capacities beyond physical strength alone.
Using reason requires: limits on how far one can go, doubt about possible error, reflexivity that evaluates one’s approach as it proceeds
Thucydides’ History of the Peloponnesian War is presented as an early rational work that recounts the conflict between Sparta and Athens without deities, supernatural forces, or predetermined destiny.
★ Must-know
📌 Philosophers and Sophists both leave magical thought behind, but philosophers seek progression toward truth or an ideal while Sophists deny that such progression is possible.
📌 Philosophers and scientists seek meaning beyond mere description, whereas the Sophist reduces discourse to subjectivity, private interests, or rhetoric and is indifferent to its content.
Further detail
Without transcendence, humans cannot think in abstract concepts or plan projects and remain caught in everyday contingencies, powerful emotions, superstitions, and collective culture without a contradictory or potentially liberating tool.
Thales, the Presocratics, Plato, and Aristotle pursued the rational conceptualization of the Cosmos, the City and its institutions, and humanity’s place in them.
Philosophers, from Plato to Kant, construct dialectical systems aimed at a postulated but unknown truth or hoped-for ideals such as the Beautiful, the Just, and the Good.
Plato criticizes Sophists for teaching argument and counterargument without seeking truth and for treating rhetorical force as sufficient to persuade regardless of a speech’s content. - Platon
Neglecting the persistent human need to pursue some form of transcendence risks a return to magical thought, collective fears, and hatred; magical thought is described as humanity’s natural state and therefore difficult or impossible to eliminate permanently.
The philosopher seeks truth; the Sophist seeks persuasive speech without regard to truth.
★ Must-know
Au XVIIIe siècle, les penseurs des Lumières voient dans la pensée rationnelle un moyen d’expliquer, de prédire et de développer des systèmes fondés sur l’observation, l’expérimentation et l’élaboration mathématique.
Les succès de la mécanique nourrissent l’espoir de dépasser la rhétorique scholastique et de libérer les esprits et les peuples des anciens régimes jugés incompatibles avec la liberté de pensée.
Further detail
La mécanique ouvre une voie de libération intellectuelle et politique.
★ Must-know
Les penseurs des Lumières placent l’État, le pouvoir et l’éthique au cœur de leurs programmes théoriques, tout en reconnaissant la difficulté de fonder des États justes face aux pouvoirs attachés à leurs privilèges.
Pour les penseurs des Lumières, toute connaissance doit être accompagnée d’une éthique pour engendrer une action, et les philosophes élaborent aussi leur propre théorie morale.
Further detail
La légitimité politique constitue une question centrale pour les penseurs des Lumières.
Adam Smith ne défend pas seulement la « main invisible » : il juge que la liberté du marché doit s’accompagner de droiture et d’honnêteté. - La Théorie des Sentiments Moraux
★ Must-know
Further detail
Selon Kant, on est responsable de son état de tutelle lorsque sa cause est le manque de résolution et de courage d’utiliser son entendement sans la conduite d’un autre, et non une insuffisance de l’entendement. - Réponse à la question : Qu’est-ce que les Lumières ?, 1784
Kant cherche à libérer l’être humain des autorités qui imposent l’arbitraire de leur pouvoir. - Réponse à la question : Qu’est-ce que les Lumières ?, 1784
★ Must-know
Le statut de la raison et les idéaux des Lumières se détériorent rapidement, notamment lorsque la raison est instrumentalisée dans le Culte de la Raison pendant la Révolution.
Les anthropologues mettent en évidence le caractère ubiquitaire de la pensée magique comme fond commun et seul véritable universel humain, ce qui conduit à considérer les Lumières comme un moment particulier de la civilisation occidentale.
Les motivations cachées comprennent (Marx, Nietzsche et Freud):
Further detail
📌 Au XXe siècle, des glissements sémantiques conduisent à confondre rationalité et rationalisme, raison et rationalisation, ainsi que raison et calcul.
Les Romantiques, dans une tradition remontant notamment à Jean-Jacques Rousseau, glorifient le bon sauvage et présentent la Nature et la vie en harmonie avec elle comme essentiellement bonnes, réaffirmant ainsi une Nature sacrée.
Des penseurs, de Jeremy Bentham à Claude Lévi-Strauss, attaquent le Sujet cartésien en affirmant qu’il n’existe pas et que Descartes l’a inventé.
Culte de la Raison, romantisme, anthropologie, soupçon, confusions modernes.
★ Must-know
Further detail
Take a 22-question practice quiz on Reason Against Magical Thought, with every answer explained.
1. Which description best distinguishes magical thought from reason?
2. In Max Weber’s associated formula, what does the “enchantment of the world” mean?
Memorize the key concepts of Reason Against Magical Thought with 55 flashcards.
What characterizes magical thought, and how does reason relate to it?
It is archaic, spontaneous, and naturally occurring; reason opposes it rather than arising from it.
Which thinker is associated with the formula “enchantment of the world”?
Max Weber.
What does “enchantment of the world” mean in Max Weber’s formula?
The sacred taking possession of as much as possible of human actions and beliefs.
Upload your class notes and Revizly writes a study guide, a quiz and flashcards in about a minute.
Study guide maker