What characterizes magical thought, and how does reason relate to it?
It is archaic, spontaneous, and naturally occurring; reason opposes it rather than arising from it.
Which thinker is associated with the formula “enchantment of the world”?
Max Weber.
What does “enchantment of the world” mean in Max Weber’s formula?
The sacred taking possession of as much as possible of human actions and beliefs.
How does magical thought unify a group and regulate its boundaries?
Through strong emotions, inclusion of members, rejection of outsiders, and submission to claimants of the sacred.
What is Reason intended to free human beings from?
The domination of magical thought, socially and intellectually.
What guides Reason’s pursuit of knowledge and action?
Method, values, and ideals, without supernatural forces or excessive emotion.
What sequence does Reason use to develop and apply systems?
It develops mental experiments, tests them against reality, then applies them in practice.
What does transcendence mean in intellectual life?
It is a movement beyond oneself that need not be divine.
How do philosophers and Sophists differ in their view of progress toward truth?
Philosophers pursue truth or an ideal, while Sophists deny such progress is possible.
What distinguishes philosophers and scientists from Sophists in their approach to meaning?
Philosophers and scientists seek meaning beyond mere description, while Sophists reduce discourse to subjectivity, private interests, or rhetoric and disregard its content.
What did Enlightenment thinkers believe humanity could do to the world and its condition?
Understand the world and improve its own condition.
What attitude toward human potential characterized the Enlightenment?
Immense optimism and unprecedented faith.
How did Enlightenment thinkers use rational thought in the eighteenth century?
To explain, predict, and develop systems based on observation, experimentation, and mathematical reasoning.
What hope did the successes of mechanics inspire among Enlightenment thinkers?
They could surpass scholastic rhetoric and free minds and peoples from old regimes opposed to freedom of thought.
What themes did Enlightenment thinkers place at the center of their theoretical programs?
The state, power, and ethics.
What makes founding just states difficult, according to Enlightenment thinkers?
Powers defend their privileges.
What must accompany knowledge for it to generate action, according to Enlightenment thinkers?
An ethical framework.
What did Enlightenment philosophers develop alongside ethical approaches to knowledge?
Their own moral theories.
According to Kant’s 1784 essay *What Is Enlightenment?*, what are the Enlightenment’s defining movement and source of responsibility?
Humanity’s emergence from self-incurred tutelage.
Which work and year did Kant give for his definition of the Enlightenment?
*What Is Enlightenment?*, 1784.
According to Kant, what is the state of tutelage?
The inability to use one’s understanding without another’s guidance.
Which work and year contains Kant’s definition of the state of tutelage?
*What Is Enlightenment?*, 1784.
What is Kant’s motto of the Enlightenment, and what does it urge people to do?
“Sapere aude!”—have the courage to use your own understanding.
What happened to reason and Enlightenment ideals during the French Revolution?
They rapidly deteriorated, notably as reason was instrumentalized in the Cult of Reason.
What universal human phenomenon do anthropologists identify as a shared foundation?
Magical thought.
How do anthropologists characterize the Enlightenment in Western civilization?
As a particular moment in Western civilization.
Which thinkers are known as the “philosophers of suspicion”?
Marx, Nietzsche and Freud.
What makes science a remaining bastion of Platonic, Cartesian, and Kantian reason?
Its method, claim to universality, and ambition to establish truth.
What human capacity does science express confidence in?
The capacity to transcend the human condition.
Which social practices are included in magical thought?
Vendettas, scapegoating, ritualization of social life, and escalation.
How does magical thought connect entities and events across the world?
Through holism and ancestor worship.
What kinds of beings does magical thought populate the world with?
Animated entities, including forces of good and evil.
Which beliefs about destiny and causality belong to magical thought’s preconcepts?
Fatalism, predetermined destiny, and unrestrained causality mixing valid knowledge with superstition.
Where and when did Reason arise, according to surviving texts?
On the Mediterranean shores, a little less than a millennium before the Common Era.
What command expresses Reason’s response to supernatural fear?
“Do not be afraid.”
Which conflict does Thucydides’ early rational work recount?
The conflict between Sparta and Athens.
Who described reason as “letting our hypotheses die in our place”?
Karl Popper.
What must accompany the use of reason to guard against error?
Limits, doubt about possible error, and reflexive evaluation of one’s approach.
What does transcendence enable humans to do beyond everyday contingencies?
Think in abstract concepts and plan projects.
What did Thales, the Presocratics, Plato, and Aristotle seek to conceptualize rationally?
The Cosmos, the City and its institutions, and humanity’s place in them.
What do philosophers from Plato to Kant aim their dialectical systems toward?
A postulated but unknown truth or ideals such as the Beautiful, the Just, and the Good.
Which author criticized Sophists for teaching argument without seeking truth?
Platon.
What risks follow from neglecting humanity’s persistent need for transcendence?
A return to magical thought, collective fears, and hatred.
What future did Enlightenment thinkers envision through renewed freedom and energy?
Better states and economic systems, and a future better than the present.
Which political question was central to Enlightenment thinkers?
Political legitimacy.
Which work is associated with Adam Smith’s views on market freedom and moral conduct?
*The Theory of Moral Sentiments*.
What qualities should accompany market freedom, according to Adam Smith?
Integrity and honesty.
According to Kant, what makes a person responsible for their state of tutelage?
A lack of resolve and courage to use their understanding without guidance.
Which work and year contains Kant’s account of responsibility for tutelage?
*What Is Enlightenment?*, 1784.
Which author argued for freeing people from arbitrary authority in 1784?
Kant, in *Answering the Question: What Is Enlightenment?*
Which tradition does Rousseau represent in the Romantic glorification of the noble savage?
A tradition that glorifies the noble savage and regards nature and life in harmony with it as essentially good.
Which thinker is named as an influence on the Romantic glorification of the noble savage?
Jean-Jacques Rousseau.
What semantic confusions emerged in the twentieth century around reason?
Rationality with rationalism, reason with rationalization, and reason with calculation.
Which thinker is named in the critique of the Cartesian subject?
Jeremy Bentham.
Who sometimes undermines the foundations of science?
Scientists invoking tolerance, diversity of opinion, and respect for each person.
Answer 22 questions on Reason Against Magical Thought.
1. Which description best distinguishes magical thought from reason?
2. In Max Weber’s associated formula, what does the “enchantment of the world” mean?
Go over the full study guide for Reason Against Magical Thought.
Read the study guide →Upload your class notes and Revizly writes your flashcards in about a minute.
Flashcard maker