Study guide: Plant Succession and Disturbance

Course Outline

  1. Disturbance and Ecosystem Responses
  2. Succession Types and Trajectories
  3. Theories of Pioneer Succession
  4. Egler’s Succession Models
  5. Niches and Species Interactions
  6. Strategies Based on Traits and Resources
  7. Probabilistic Succession Models
  8. Transitory States and Climax
  9. Biological Legacies in Succession
  10. Integrated Succession After Fire

1. Disturbance and Ecosystem Responses

Key Concepts & Definitions

  • Disturbance: A discrete event over time that partially or totally destroys biomass and is often intense.
  • Resistance: How an ecosystem withstands a disturbance.
  • Resilience: How an ecosystem recovers after a disturbance.

Essential Points

📌 Disturbance is a discrete event, whereas stress is a continuous constraint that limits biomass production.

  • Disturbances can negatively affect biodiversity by regulating abundance and diversity, including through effects on phytophages, and can affect ecosystem processes. - White & Pickett, 1985

  • Disturbances can positively affect biodiversity by creating habitat and resource heterogeneity that enables species establishment and movement. - Connell, 1978

2. Succession Types and Trajectories

Key Concepts & Definitions

  • Succession: The colonization of a site by organisms after a disturbance, followed by a change in the biocenosis over time.
  • Primary plant succession: Vegetation dynamics on a bare, sterile substrate, or lithosol, after disturbance and continuing until the climax.
  • Secondary plant succession: The reconstitution of vegetation after disturbance on existing soil with an existing seed bank, continuing until the climax.

★ Must-know

📌 Autogenic succession is driven by organisms themselves without external influence after the initial disturbance, whereas allogenic succession is driven by repeated external disturbances during succession.

📌 Progressive succession involves increasing biomass, notably in autogenic succession, whereas regressive succession involves loss of biomass and soil, notably under allogenic impacts. - Lepart and Escarré, 1983

  • Clements (1916) described succession as progressing from a pioneer state through an intermediary state toward a final stable climax state.

Further detail

  • In dune formation, the succession gradient is spatially equivalent to a temporal gradient, as illustrated by Cowles (1899).

  • Primary succession occurs in:

    • dune systems
    • salt muds
    • glacier-retreat moraines
    • lake edges filled with sediment or peat bogs
    • anthropogenic quarries or mines
  • After Krakatau’s 1883 volcanic eruption, recolonization records show 26 plant species after 3 years, 115 plant species and 265 animal species after 25 years, and 271 plant species and 600 animal species after 50 years.

  • Secondary succession occurs in:

    • burned areas
    • abandoned crops
    • sites affected by hurricanes
    • sites affected by clearing
    • sites affected by grazing
    • sites affected by mowing
  • Recolonization of an abandoned crop can be a progressive autogenic succession, with natural vegetation producing successive biocenoses of increasing diversity and biomass toward a climax.

  • Tree cutting can increase runoff and surface flow, reduce vegetation, and promote soil salinization in Australian bocage. - Walker & Reddell, 2007

  • Repeated intense fires can shift repeated Eucalyptus forests toward Acacia forests, producing a transition to another climax.

  • Cyclic succession in peat bogs involves organic-matter accumulation and water accumulation in 50 cm hummocks, followed by vegetation senescence.

Memory Hook

Primary succession begins on bare substrate; secondary succession begins on existing soil.

3. Theories of Pioneer Succession

Key Concepts & Definitions

  • Paraclimax: Bardat, 1993 - A maquis, scrubland or heath whose evolution is artificially blocked, potentially by regressive succession, and may include species introduced by humans.

★ Must-know

📌 Monoclimax theory proposes one community type determined by climate, whereas polyclimax theory allows several community types depending on soil, topography and other factors.

  • A main criticism of pioneer succession theories is their determinism and assumption of predictability. - Connell & Slatyer, 1977

Further detail

  • Theories of pioneer plant succession include Clements (1916), Cowles (1901, 1911) and Gleason (1917, 1927), and Egler (1954).

  • Different climates can lead to a similar community, while the same climate can support different communities on contrasting substrates such as sandstone and serpentine. - Kimmins

Memory Hook

Monoclimax: one climate-determined community; polyclimax: several communities shaped by local conditions.

4. Egler’s Succession Models

★ Must-know

📌 In Egler’s (1954) relay floristics model, new species replace those initially present, whereas in initial floristic composition no new species arrive and species are progressively lost.

Further detail

  • Many habitats and species follow a mixture of relay floristics and initial floristic composition, depending on the study scale and vegetation type. - Copenheaver, 2008

  • For Douglas to occur in the climax in the initial-floristic-composition example, it must already be present initially.

Memory Hook

Relay floristics replaces early species; initial floristic composition retains species established at the start.

5. Niches and Species Interactions

Key Concepts & Definitions

  • Niche: A niche is an n-dimensional hypervolume of environmental conditions and resources within which a species can survive and reproduce.

★ Must-know

  • The fundamental physiological niche differs from the occupied ecological niche, which can be modified by biotic interactions. - Hutchison, 1954

  • Competition and predation are negative interactions that can restrict the occupied niche, whereas facilitation can improve habitat directly or provide indirect refuge from predation. - Bruno et al., 2003

  • Connell and Slatyer’s (1977) facilitation model proposes that early species modify the environment so later species can establish, while the early species eventually die. - Connell & Slatyer

  • In facilitation, early species decrease recruitment of other early species and increase recruitment of later species.

  • In inhibition, early species decrease recruitment of both early and late species, and new invasion becomes possible when resident species are damaged or killed and space is freed.

  • In tolerance, recruitment of early species decreases while recruitment of late species is unaffected, allowing late species to grow despite early species.

  • Connell and Slatyer (1977) proposed facilitation, inhibition, and tolerance as three models of plant succession. - Connell & Slatyer

Further detail

📌 In Connell and Slatyer’s (1977) tolerance model, all species able to survive as adults can establish, recruitment of early species decreases, and late species recruitment is unaffected. - Connell & Slatyer

📌 In Connell and Slatyer’s (1977) inhibition model, early species reduce recruitment of both early and late species, and new invasion or mature growth becomes possible when resident species are damaged or killed and space opens. - Connell & Slatyer

  • Nurse plants can directly facilitate other plants in arid and semi-arid environments, including at Salar de Uyuni in Bolivia, and in alpine lawns in France.

  • In the grazing example, 100% of plants without nurse protection were grazed and 44% died.

  • Nurse-plant protection can occur through: repulsion, shelter by the nurse, shelter by dilution in the community of origin

  • Primary successions in sessile organisms can involve at least one of the facilitation, inhibition, or tolerance models, as discussed by Dean and Hurd (1980), Bergeron (2000), and Mullineaux et al. (2003). - Dean & Hurd, 1980; Bergeron, 2000; Mullineaux et al., 2003

  • The intermediate disturbance hypothesis is attributed to Grime (1973) and Connell (1978), and is linked to coexistence through a competition–colonization trade-off. - Grime, 1973; Connell , 1978

Memory Hook

Negative interactions restrict the occupied niche; positive interactions can expand it.

6. Strategies Based on Traits and Resources

Key Concepts & Definitions

  • Functional traits: Morphological, physiological, or phenological features that influence performance.
  • Functional type: Group of plants that respond approximately similarly to environmental factors, such as disturbance, and affect ecosystems approximately similarly.

★ Must-know

📌 Strategies interpret how a plant optimizes its fitness, whereas functional groups describe how plants respond to and affect the environment.

  • The r/K strategy model is attributed to MacArthur and Wilson (1967): r-strategists are associated with disturbance, while K-strategists are associated with stabilized resources and increased competition. - Mac Arthur & Wilson

  • The CSR strategies, attributed to Grime (1977), distinguish competitive (C), stress-tolerant (S), and ruderal (R) strategies.

Further detail

📌 In the resource-ratio hypothesis attributed to Tilman (1982), plants are distinguished by allocation toward aboveground competition for light, belowground competition for nutrients, or reproduction.

  • The course links r/K and CSR strategies to ecosystem characteristics: juvenile ecosystems are associated with r or R strategies, early and abundant reproduction, rapid growth, short life expectancy, high productivity and renewal, and few species interactions; mature ecosystems are associated with S or K strategies, later and less frequent reproduction, longer life expectancy, more species, complex interactions, and specialized niches.

  • 🔄 The depicted forest succession proceeds as follows:

    1. An opening is colonized by expansive r species.
    2. The r species grow and become dominant.
    3. Conservative K species reach the canopy.
    4. The r species disappear as the forest matures.

📐 Formula - The morphological index is calculated as MI=a+b+c2MI = \frac{a+b+c}{2}, where a is height (1–10), b is width (1–5), and c is litter thickness (1–5).

  • Plant functional traits listed include height, specific leaf area, C/N, seed production and mass, root length, stem/root ratio, lateral expansion, leaf area, canopy structure, biomass, vegetative propagation, phenology, and leaf dry matter content.

Memory Hook

Ruderal plants exploit disturbance; competitive plants dominate stable, resource-rich conditions; stress-tolerant plants withstand stress.

7. Probabilistic Succession Models

Key Concepts & Definitions

  • Markovian chain: Model of the probability of replacement by the same species (p) or another species (q) from the frequency of juveniles at each stage.

Essential Points

  • The Markovian-chain example concerns vegetation regeneration on mined sites in Germany over 20 years.

8. Transitory States and Climax

★ Must-know

📌 Transitions between ecological states are gradual when disturbances are infrequent and abrupt when disturbances are frequent.

Further detail

  • The course identifies stable states and transitions between an initial state and a stable state as features of succession.

  • The discussion of transitory states and disturbance cites Westoby et al. (1989) and Phillips (2011). - Westoby et al 1989; Phillips 2011

9. Biological Legacies in Succession

★ Must-know

  • Biological legacies include:

    • survivors
    • structural legacies
    • biologically generated spatial patterns
  • A biological legacy is a surviving or biologically generated feature that influences ecological trajectories after disturbance.

Further detail

  • Franklin et al. (2000) are cited in connection with biological legacies.

  • A stream succession study compared three biological-legacy treatments with a control without legacy and examined effects on benthic succession.

  • The stream legacy treatments included effects that favored filter feeders and predators, reduced or excluded decomposers, filter feeders, and predators as colonizers, or had no effect.

  • The stream-succession example cites Ledger et al. (2006).

10. Integrated Succession After Fire

★ Must-know

  • Pulsford et al. (2014) examine post-fire succession in Australian Eucalyptus regnans forests and present three post-disturbance succession scenarios.

  • The scenarios connect these disturbance concepts: biological legacy, initial floristic composition and facilitation, competition and tolerance, transition states, habitat accommodation, plant traits

Further detail

  • The illustrated succession names these species:
    • flame robin
    • Pomaderris aspera
    • Olearia argophylla
    • Cassinia aculeata
    • myrtle beech (Nothofagus cunninghamii)

Synthesis Tables

Primary and Secondary Succession

FeaturePrimarySecondary
Starting substrateBare, sterile substrate (lithosol)Existing soil and seed bank
Typical settingsDunes, salt muds, morainesBurned areas, abandoned crops
Course endpointClimaxClimax

Test yourself

Take a 28-question practice quiz on Plant Succession and Disturbance, with every answer explained.

1. A brief, intense event partially destroys the biomass in a woodland. Which term best describes this event?

2. A plant community experiences a persistent shortage of water that limits biomass production, rather than a single destructive event. Which concept best describes this condition?

Take the quiz →

Study with flashcards

Memorize the key concepts of Plant Succession and Disturbance with 67 flashcards.

What is an ecological disturbance?

A discrete event that partially or totally destroys biomass and is often intense.

How does a disturbance differ from stress in its duration?

A disturbance is discrete, whereas stress is continuous.

Which source is associated with disturbances regulating abundance and diversity?

White & Pickett, 1985.

See the flashcards →

Related classes

Make your own study guides

Upload your class notes and Revizly writes a study guide, a quiz and flashcards in about a minute.

Study guide maker