Study guide: Transitions and Ecological Solidarity

Course Outline

  1. Environmental Inequality and Coastal Risk
  2. Soil Protection and Land Take
  3. Urban Climate and Heat Islands
  4. Urban Heat Adaptation Strategies
  5. Ecological Solidarity in French Law
  6. Ecological Solidarity and Water Governance
  7. Framing and Imagining Transitions
  8. Transition Dynamics and Constraints
  9. Contemporary Infrastructure Transitions
  10. Just Urban and Energy Transitions
  11. Digital Urban Transitions

Key Dates

  1. 1964River basins were created as a basis for territorial and financial solidarity among public river-basin agencies.
  2. 2000s onwardUrban infrastructure became increasingly financialized.
  3. 2016ecological solidarity became a legal principle in France
  4. 2021enforcement of the no net land take objective (ZAN) began

1. Environmental Inequality and Coastal Risk

Key Concepts & Definitions

  • Environmental inequality: dictionnary of climate change - Environmental inequality comprises inequalities in human populations’ relationships with their environment, including exposure to risks, access to resources and amenities, environmental impacts, ability to protect the environment through public policy, and ability to benefit from such policies; V. Deldrève’s 2022 Dictionary of Climate Change gives this definition.

★ Must-know

📌 Climate mitigation seeks to limit climate change, whereas adaptation responds to its effects; urgent adaptation spending is described as less effective when mitigation has failed.

Further detail

  • The Signal, a building in Soulac-sur-Mer constructed in the 1970s, became threatened by coastal erosion and its residents were evacuated, with owners suffering financial losses, illustrating the need to prepare for sea-level rise and coastal damage.

📌 French urban law allows construction only beyond 100 metres from the coast, although buildings permitted before the law may stand closer.

  • A public solidarity fund may compensate people affected by major risks, and a small amount from house purchases or insurance is paid into the fund.

Memory Hook

Coastal erosion → property loss → public compensation

2. Soil Protection and Land Take

★ Must-know

  • Soil is largely absent from international and European environmental legislation, with no direct international convention addressing soil issues and state sovereignty acting as an obstacle.

  • The Roadmap for a Resource-Efficient Europe sets a milestone that EU policies account for their direct and indirect land-use impacts in the EU and elsewhere by 2020, and gives an average of 800 km² per year for new land take between 2000 and 2020 as the rate needed to halt net land-area growth by 2050.

Further detail

  • Soil is presented as a resource with ecological functions and benefits for human populations, extending to a depth of about 6 metres.

  • The European Parliament and Council adopted a directive on soil monitoring and resilience in November after about twenty years of work, although the notes report that soil health was left out.

  • Sustainable Development Goal 15.3 calls for restoring degraded land and soil, and the IPBES report is cited in connection with zero net land degradation.

  • Land change contributes to biodiversity erosion because buildings and fields separated across the landscape create fractures in biodiversity.

  • French urban law increasingly addressed urban sprawl from 2000, initially with a modest success and a focus on agricultural land; from 2010, it increasingly connected land take with environmental issues such as ecological corridors and flood risks.

Memory Hook

Soil is ecologically essential but often overlooked by environmental law

3. Urban Climate and Heat Islands

Key Concepts & Definitions

  • Heat: Thermal energy transferred because of a temperature difference between a system and its surroundings.
  • Work: Energy transferred due to macroscopic forces exerted on or by a system.
  • Climate: The statistics of weather over long periods, such as at least 30 years.

★ Must-know

  • Heat is transferred in three ways:

    • conduction
    • convection
    • radiation
  • Typical greenhouse gases include:

    • H₂O
    • CO₂
    • methane
    • N₂O
    • CFCs

Further detail

📐 Formula - Urban climate is expressed as Urban Climate=Local Climate+Urban Effect\text{Urban Climate} = \text{Local Climate} + \text{Urban Effect}.

📐 Formula - At thermodynamic equilibrium, energy entering a system equals energy leaving it: energy in=energy out\text{energy in} = \text{energy out}.

4. Urban Heat Adaptation Strategies

Key Concepts & Definitions

  • Urban heat island: An urban heat island is a localized heating phenomenon in cities, with urban temperatures typically about 3°C higher than rural temperatures.

★ Must-know

  • Urban heat islands are strengthened by:
    • radiative trapping between buildings
    • limited evapotranspiration
    • obstructed wind
    • anthropogenic heat

Further detail

  • During the 2026 heat waves, the urban-rural temperature difference was reported as 5°C to 7°C.

  • Urban air temperature can decrease at night while built-up areas remain warmer than natural public areas because buildings retain and release heat.

Memory Hook

More heat → more air conditioning → stronger urban heat island

5. Ecological Solidarity in French Law

Key Concepts & Definitions

  • Ecological solidarity: The principle that territories depend on one another because they share a natural environment and ecosystems depend on interactions among their components.

★ Must-know

  • Urban heat adaptation measures include:

    • solar shading
    • ventilation and air supply
    • ceiling fans
    • evaporative cooling
    • external thermal insulation
    • thermal mass
  • More heat can lead to more air-conditioning use, which strengthens the urban heat island; air-source air conditioning should therefore be avoided as much as possible, and exhaust systems installed if cooling is necessary.

  • Mathevet et al. (2012) distinguish solidarity of fact, the shared destiny of humans, society, and their environment, from solidarity of action, the recognition by residents, users, and visitors that they belong to the living community and wish to live alongside other living beings.

  • The French Environmental Code calls for taking into account, in public decisions with a significant impact on the environment of affected areas, interactions among ecosystems, living organisms, and natural or developed environments.

Further detail

  • Indoor heat depends on:
    • the roof
    • windows
    • ventilation
    • walls
    • the floor
    • thermal bridges
  • Increasing urban albedo by using reflective surfaces can help reflect light and heat, and reflective roofs allow heat to leave.

  • Urban greening can use green façades, roofs, and streets, but its irrigation needs and maintenance costs must be considered.

  • Rainwater management measures include:

    • infiltration wells
    • floodable gardens
    • green roofs
    • infiltration trenches
    • ditches or swales
    • rainwater harvesting
    • permeable pavement
    • rain gardens
    • permeable surfaces
    • floodable squares
  • Creating shade is identified as the first priority for urban heat management, and grass is described as the best urban material.

  • The French national park model includes a core area and an adjacent membership area (aire d’adhésion) that extends ecological protection more lightly and encourages dialogue with neighboring territories.

Memory Hook

Solidarity of fact describes shared ecological destiny; solidarity of action expresses a will to live together

6. Ecological Solidarity and Water Governance

★ Must-know

  • Water law widely treats water as the common heritage of the nation.

Further detail

  • Ecological solidarity is presented as a debt linking people to future generations, whose lives may otherwise be treated as not counting.

  • Under a solidarity contract among flatmates in France, if one flatmate does not pay, the others must pay.

  • Water governance has developed through territorial solidarity and solidarity among water users.

  • Water governance includes fiscal and economic solidarity among users and solidarity between upstream and downstream areas.

Memory Hook

Solidarity of fact describes shared destiny; solidarity of action expresses a will to live together.

7. Framing and Imagining Transitions

Key Concepts & Definitions

  • Transition: A systematic change in how systems operate, involving changes in the fundamental structures and operating logics of infrastructure, politics, institutions, and social life.
  • Leapfrogging: The prospect of jumping over assumed stages in a development trajectory, regarded as an opportunity for certain regions or types of society.

★ Must-know

📌 Transitions can be studied both as material processes of change that can be empirically documented and as discourses that construct narratives around crisis or urgency.

Further detail

  • The term transition helps order time and human experience by constructing eras and stories about what has happened and what may happen next.

  • Alternative framings include the Capitalocene, emphasizing capitalism, and the Plantationcene, emphasizing racialized plantation systems and colonial extraction.

  • South Africa has more renewable energy on its electricity grid than ever before, while a just energy transition also comprises policies, experts, arguments, and debates that may be distant from material realities.

  • The term leapfrogging is criticized for implying that the Global South can be saved by skipping development stages without specifying which stages are being skipped.

Memory Hook

A transition is both material change and a discourse that narrates change.

8. Transition Dynamics and Constraints

Key Concepts & Definitions

  • Lock-in: How existing infrastructure, institutions, technologies, and investments make a shift to alternative pathways difficult even when superior alternatives exist.
  • Speculation: An attempt to discern risk and uncertainty in relation to possible futures.

★ Must-know

  • Large technological systems create: sunk costs, technical dependencies, regulatory commitments or legally binding obligations, user habits or cultural norms

📌 Risk can be measured and assessed if appropriate data are available, whereas uncertainty cannot be quantified and remains in the realm of imagination. - Sjol, 2022

  • Transitions are:
    • non-linear
    • socio-technical
    • additive rather than substitutive
    • highly contested, with winners and losers
    • interconnected and planetary in nature
    • material as well as discursive

Further detail

  • Transitions have often failed to produce more just social and economic outcomes.

  • Transition expertise includes: prediction and modelling, interventions to manage the direction of change, financing packages, social and economic justice expertise, legal expertise to support new regimes

Memory Hook

Built systems create sunk costs and dependencies → alternatives become harder to adopt.

9. Contemporary Infrastructure Transitions

Key Concepts & Definitions

  • Governance decentralization: A shift of power and financial control from nation-states to subnational authorities.

★ Must-know

  • Demographic transitions include declining populations and fertility rates with aging populations in the Global North, climate-, conflict-, and hardship-related migration shifts, and urbanization in the Global South with growing young urban populations and informalized work.

  • Global value chains shifted through imperial globalization (1500–1800), industrial globalization (1820–1980), and hyper-globalization (1980–2010).

Further detail

  • Subnational associations and power structures increasingly claim power and space, while cities gain influence globally and in international forums.

  • The global infrastructure finance landscape includes China’s rise and possible decline in spending, new bilateral players such as Turkey and Korea, and the falling significance of the World Bank.

  • Since 2010, value chains have experienced both calls for re-localization and continued hyper-disaggregation, driven by nationalization campaigns, COVID-19’s exposure of risks, and China’s changing role.

10. Just Urban and Energy Transitions

★ Must-know

  • The just-transition discourse began in the US labor movement in the 1970s and 1980s, arguing that workers in polluting or hazardous industries should not bear the economic costs of environmental protection.

  • The 17 Sustainable Development Goals contain an unspoken tension: more than half require expanded economic activity, food, or sanitation, while others depend on scaling back, including reducing greenhouse-gas emissions, responsible consumption, and restoring fish stocks.

📌 Climate mitigation reduces emissions, whereas adaptation prepares societies for climate impacts.

  • The countries required to mitigate climate change are not necessarily the same countries that must adapt to its impacts.

  • Renewable-energy innovation drove an 85% drop in photovoltaic electricity prices and a 70% drop in onshore wind prices between 2010 and 2020.

  • African cities face the imperative to:

    • expand access to energy
    • shift sources of energy
    • build appropriate governance systems

Further detail

  • Swilling describes the sustainability age (2015–2030) as a shared language for engaging contested futures.

  • Within the Sustainable Development Goals, Goal 7 reconciles the tension between growth and degrowth through the promise of affordable, reliable, sustainable, and modern energy for all.

  • Under the Paris Agreement adopted at COP21, nearly all countries submit Nationally Determined Contributions as part of climate commitments to energy transitions.

  • Digital technologies have enabled smart metering and mini-grids, while electric-vehicle and storage batteries make lithium important to energy-transition value chains.

  • Africa accounts for approximately 5% of global carbon-dioxide emissions, and South Africa accounts for approximately 30% of Africa’s emissions.

  • African cities aggregate growing energy demand and development challenges, making them key sites of the tension surrounding urban transitions.

11. Digital Urban Transitions

Key Concepts & Definitions

  • Digital transition: Fundamental socio-technical and processual change in how society is organized, based on digital technology and networks.
  • Digital platform: A socio-technical intermediary and business arrangement that aims to automate market exchanges and mediate social action.
  • Networks: Interconnections between objects and agents in a system.

★ Must-know

  • The socio-technical perspective treats social and technical worlds as mutually affecting and holds that technical processes are also social processes.

  • Digital transitions can create injustice through:

    • new forms of extraction
    • power concentration in big technology firms
    • bias in AI systems and platforms
    • persistent digital divides

Further detail

  • Key milestones in digital transition include microprocessors and personal computers around 1970, public access to the World Wide Web in 1991, Amazon Web Services and its Elastic Compute Cloud in 2006, and the rise of AI for prediction, automation, and machine learning around 2010.

  • Digitization is associated with:

    • optimization
    • efficiency
    • access to knowledge
    • transparency
    • agility
    • convenience
    • innovation or disruption
  • The twin-transition idea holds that digital technologies can help reduce emissions through smart grids, sensors that reduce water and energy waste, and AI that optimizes transport and logistics or reduces the need for them.

  • Urban data may concern mobility, health, finances, infrastructure conditions, and ecological conditions, and much collected data is not currently used.

  • Urban digital governance can:

    • modernize payments for revenue
    • provide access to government forms
    • document and track grievances
  • Cities can govern technology by taking positions on platforms such as Airbnb and by supporting or discouraging technology hubs.

  • Undersea internet cables are fragile and can be broken by ships’ anchors, making digital infrastructure vulnerable to sabotage, information interception, or disruption of access.

Test yourself

Take a 32-question practice quiz on Transitions and Ecological Solidarity, with every answer explained.

1. Which description best captures environmental inequality as defined by V. Deldrève?

2. A coastal town faces worsening erosion and flooding after years of rising emissions. Which policy pairing correctly distinguishes the two responses?

Take the quiz →

Study with flashcards

Memorize the key concepts of Transitions and Ecological Solidarity with 84 flashcards.

How does V. Deldrève’s 2022 Dictionary of Climate Change define environmental inequality?

It comprises inequalities in populations’ relationships with their environment.

Which source gives the definition of environmental inequality?

V. Deldrève’s 2022 Dictionary of Climate Change.

What does climate adaptation address, unlike climate mitigation?

The effects of climate change.

See the flashcards →

Related classes

Make your own study guides

Upload your class notes and Revizly writes a study guide, a quiz and flashcards in about a minute.

Study guide maker