Study guide: British Constitutional Monarchy Lecture 1

Course Outline

  1. Constitutional Monarchy, Parliament, and the Sovereign
  2. Medieval Kings and Magna Carta
  3. Tudor Royal Power
  4. Tudor Legacy and Stuart Conflict
  5. Parliament’s Victory, Restoration, and Declining Monarchical Power
  6. Sources and Character of the Constitution
  7. Prorogation Crisis and the Ceremonial Monarchy
  8. Parliamentary Sovereignty and Elections
  9. The House of Lords and Its Limits
  10. Political Parties in Parliament
  11. Government Control of Parliament and Parliamentary Lawmaking
  12. Government Formation, Majorities, and Prime Ministerial Leadership
  13. Cabinet, Ministers and Civil Service
  14. Common Law, Legal Systems, and Legal Professions
  15. Judges, Parliament, and Constitutional Change
  16. Devolution and National Autonomy
  17. Brexit and the Union’s Future
  18. The Case for a Written Constitution

Key Dates

Key dates to know

If you only remember a few dates, remember these, since they mark the major turning points:

  • 1066: Norman Conquest, which transformed English society and language.
  • 1215: Magna Carta, the first text to limit the king's power, and the origin of the rule of law.
  • 1534: Act of Supremacy, Henry VIII becomes head of the Church of England.
  • 1642-1651: English Civil Wars, between Royalists and Parliamentarians.
  • 1649: Execution of Charles I, a defining moment in Parliament's victory.
  • 1688-1689: Glorious Revolution and Bill of Rights, the most important date in the course. It establishes parliamentary sovereignty.
  • 1701: Act of Settlement, which regulates the succession by law.
  • 1707: Act of Union, creation of the United Kingdom.
  • 1911: Parliament Act, the House of Lords loses its power to block legislation.
  • 2019: Prorogation crisis, when the Supreme Court intervened over a constitutional convention.

Useful context

  • 1455-1487: Wars of the Roses
  • 1603: Union of the Crowns, under James I (start of the Stuart dynasty)
  • 1660: Restoration of the monarchy
  • 1685-1688: Reign of James II
  • 1997: Tony Blair's victory
  • 2013: Succession to the Crown Act
  1. 1066William the Conqueror defeated King Harold at the Battle of Hastings and took control of most of England and Wales.
  2. 1215Rebellious barons forced King John to sign the Magna Carta, a peace treaty between the king and the barons.
  3. 1455 to 1487The War of the Roses, a civil war between two rival factions, lasted, and Henry Tudor’s victory led to his becoming Henry VII.
  4. 1534Henry VIII passed the Act of Supremacy, making himself head of the Church of England and replacing the Pope’s authority; Protestantism replaced Catholicism.
  5. 1603Elizabeth I died without an heir, ending the Tudor dynasty.
  6. 201168% voted to retain first-past-the-post rather than adopt the alternative vote system
  7. December 2019Boris Johnson called a snap election to resolve the Brexit crisis and seek a stronger majority for the Brexit deal, and the Conservatives won a landslide
  8. 4 July 2024The last general election was held.
  9. 4 July 2024The general election was held after Rishi Sunak had to call it by December 2024
  10. 2 November 2024Kemi Badenoch became Conservative Party leader after the party lost its majority

1. Constitutional Monarchy, Parliament, and the Sovereign

Key Concepts & Definitions

  • Constitutional monarchy: A system in which the head of state is a monarch whose power is shared with a constitutionally organised government.
  • Royal prerogative: A special right that allows the monarch to make certain decisions without Parliament’s approval.

★ Must-know

  • The British Parliament consists of the House of Commons, the lower chamber, and the House of Lords, the upper chamber.

  • The leader of the party that wins a majority of seats in Parliament becomes Prime Minister, and the monarch formally appoints the Prime Minister.

  • The monarch is head of state, while the Prime Minister is head of government.

  • The monarch is formally head of the armed forces, but the government makes important decisions about the army and the monarch’s military role is symbolic.

📌 Royal assent is the sovereign’s approval of a bill passed by Parliament, turning it into law; in practice, assent is a formality and the monarch always assents.

Further detail

  • Other European constitutional monarchies named are:

    • Spain
    • the Netherlands
    • Denmark
    • Belgium
    • Luxembourg
  • In 2024, Rishi Sunak, the Conservative candidate, faced Keir Starmer, the Labour candidate, in the general election; Starmer won with a large majority.

  • The monarch opens and prorogues Parliament, and each parliamentary session lasts one year.

  • At the State Opening of Parliament, the monarch reads a speech explaining which laws the government plans to enact in the coming year.

  • The monarch is immune from prosecution, justice is rendered in the monarch’s name, and courts are run in the monarch’s name.

  • 🔄 Almost all judges are appointed through these steps:

    1. The Judicial Appointments Commission selects from a list of candidates.
    2. The government approves the selection.
    3. The monarch automatically appoints the judge.
  • Criminal cases are initiated by the Crown Prosecution Service on behalf of the Crown.

Memory Hook

Royal power appears across three branches, but is largely symbolic in practice.

2. Medieval Kings and Magna Carta

★ Must-know

  • The Magna Carta required the king to: respect the freedom of the church, avoid excessive taxation of feudal lords, prohibit arbitrary detention of freemen, provide trial by jury, accept a council of 25 barons to ensure compliance

  • The Magna Carta limited the king’s arbitrary power and established the principle that the king is subject to the law, marking the beginning of the rule of law.

Further detail

  • The Norman Conquest replaced the Anglo-Saxons with Normans as the ruling class, influenced the English language through French words, and was the last time England was conquered.

  • The Magna Carta contributed to the development of a consultative body for the king and to the beginnings of protection from arbitrary detention, jury trial and due process, although these rights took a long time to extend to everyone.

  • The Magna Carta’s legacy is linked to the American Constitution (1789), the American Bill of Rights (1791) and the Universal Declaration of Human Rights (1948).

Memory Hook

John’s abuses → baronial rebellion → limits on royal power.

3. Tudor Royal Power

Essential Points

  • Henry VII reduced dependence on nobles by:

    • ending the feudal system
    • developing a royal army
    • banning private armies for noble families
    • reducing royal spending
    • creating a special court to try traitors
  • Henry VIII’s break with the Pope followed the refusal to annul his marriage to Catherine, which he sought to end so he could marry Anne Boleyn and have a male heir; the Church’s wealth and the Protestant Reformation sweeping Europe were also causes.

  • Henry VIII established the Privy Council, a cabinet-style council to help him govern, and used Acts of Parliament to take over Church property and place himself at the head of the Church.

  • Edward VI pursued church reform and killed many Catholics; Mary I restored Catholicism and killed many Protestants; Elizabeth I restored Anglicanism and persecuted Catholics.

  • The Tudor monarchs used Parliament to regulate religion, giving their decisions greater weight.

4. Tudor Legacy and Stuart Conflict

★ Must-know

📌 The Tudors strengthened royal power by making the monarch head of both Church and state and using Parliament to increase control over subjects, while religious divisions and Parliament's growing appetite for power eventually contributed to civil war.

📌 Anglicanism was moderate Protestantism that retained features such as bishops, whereas Scottish Presbyterianism was radical Protestantism opposed to any hierarchy.

  • In January 1642, Charles I entered Parliament with soldiers to arrest five Puritan MPs accused of treason; after they had fled and the Speaker refused to reveal their whereabouts, Charles left London and declared war on Parliament.

  • The English Civil Wars of 1642–1651 pitted Royalists against Parliament, whose New Model Army, led by Oliver Cromwell, defeated the Royalists and captured the king.

  • In 1649, radical parliamentarians tried and executed Charles I for treason.

Further detail

  • James VI of Scotland succeeded Elizabeth I as James I of England, beginning the Stuart dynasty, and his proposed political union of England and Scotland was blocked by Parliament.

  • James I held an absolutist view of monarchy, claiming that a king was divinely anointed and contracted with God rather than with Parliament.

  • Puritans and other non-conformists faced such difficulty that some left for the New World as the Pilgrim Fathers, described as ancestors of US settlers.

  • Charles I ruled without Parliament from 1629 to 1640, a period called the « 11 years' tyranny ».

  • After Charles I tried to impose the Church of England model on Scotland, a Scottish rebellion and invasion forced him to seek money from Parliament, increasing Parliament's power.

Memory Hook

Tudor royal power rises, but religious division and Parliament's ambitions grow

5. Parliament’s Victory, Restoration, and Declining Monarchical Power

Key Concepts & Definitions

  • Constitutional conventions: Unwritten rules of government that are not contained in Acts of Parliament and are described as the « morality of the constitution ».

★ Must-know

  • The Commonwealth lasted from 1649 to 1660 and governed England as a republic.

  • The Restoration lasted from 1660 to 1689, beginning when Parliament invited Charles II to resume the throne with a stronger position for Parliament than before.

  • In 1688, the birth of James II's son raised the prospect of a Catholic dynasty, so Parliament invited William of Orange and his wife Mary, James's daughter, to take the throne; William invaded and James fled after losing support.

  • The Glorious Revolution brought William and Mary to the throne without bloodshed, and they agreed to a Declaration of Rights before their coronation in February 1689; it became the Bill of Rights.

📌 The Bill of Rights requires Parliament's consent for changes to law proposed by the monarch and reserves the raising of taxes to Parliament.

  • The Bill of Rights is a fundamental constitutional text that establishes parliamentary sovereignty, makes the monarch, government, and courts subject to Parliament's laws, and marks Parliament's final victory over the monarchy.

  • The Act of Settlement 1701 placed succession beyond the monarchs' and nobility's control by naming Sophia, Electress of Hanover, and her Protestant descendants as heirs and disqualifying heirs who became Catholic or married a Catholic.

📌 The monarch no longer chooses how to exercise royal prerogative powers: conventions determine some, such as royal assent, while others, such as prorogation, are exercised on the advice of a government that must command a parliamentary majority.

Further detail

  • During the Commonwealth, the House of Lords was abolished and a Council of State, initially presided over by John Bradshaw, replaced the monarch; Cromwell later became Lord Protector in 1653.

  • Divisions between radicals seeking further reform and conservatives seeking the monarchy's return led Cromwell to maintain order; his son Richard could not, and Charles II was invited back.

  • Under Charles II, Parliament legislated on religion in favour of Anglicans and discriminated against non-Anglicans.

  • James II attempted to suspend laws restricting religious freedom, dissolved Parliament in 1685 after it opposed him, and issued the Declaration of Indulgence in 1687 to remove penalties on non-Anglicans.

  • The Bill of Rights protects MPs from prosecution for what they say in Parliament, forbids excessive bail and punishments, and requires regular parliamentary sessions and free elections.

  • The Bill of Rights inspired the American Declaration of Independence and other constitutions and advanced the principles that heads of state are subject to law, rights are inalienable, and people may rebel and replace a head of state who denies those rights.

📌 Since the Succession to the Crown Act 2013, marrying a Catholic no longer disqualifies an heir from succession.

6. Sources and Character of the Constitution

Key Concepts & Definitions

  • Constitution: A document that lays down fundamental principles of government, assigns powers to state branches, and sets limits through checks between branches, human rights, and international obligations.
  • Uncodified constitution: Not contained in a single document approved by the people but accumulated over time.

★ Must-know

📌 Unlike the American and French constitutions, the British Constitution was not established after a crisis or war but developed incrementally, although major changes occurred during crises such as the 17th century.

📌 Parliamentary sovereignty means Parliament's law is supreme: no court can strike down or veto an Act of Parliament.

Further detail

  • The American Constitution has seven articles and 27 amendments, followed the Revolutionary War, and was ratified in 1788.

  • The French Constitution has 89 articles, has been amended 25 times, and was ratified by referendum in 1958 after the Fourth Republic proved too unstable to deal with the war in Algeria.

  • Constitutional statutes include:

    • Act of Settlement 1701
    • Act of Union 1707
    • Parliament Act 1911
  • The UK constitution includes European and international law, including the European Convention on Human Rights ratified by the UK in 1951, the Non-Proliferation Treaty of 1968, and retained EU law created by the EU (Withdrawal) Act 2018 for legal continuity after the transition period and subsequently revoked or kept as assimilated law.

  • Common law contributes to the UK constitution through court decisions that determine the limits of government powers.

  • Other constitutional sources include conventions, royal prerogatives, and works of authority such as A.V. Dicey's The Law of the Constitution; the 2012 Cabinet Manual attempted to write conventions down.

7. Prorogation Crisis and the Ceremonial Monarchy

★ Must-know

  • In 2019, the government asked Queen Elizabeth II to prorogue Parliament for five weeks while it lacked support for its Brexit deal, leaving Parliament unable to sit until the 31 October 2019 Brexit deadline.

  • The Supreme Court ruled the prorogation unlawful and Parliament was recalled.

  • The Brexit referendum brought major constitutional change through a simple referendum: 52% voted for Brexit, 30% of the electorate did not vote, and 62% voted against in Scotland.

  • The monarch is head of state and is increasingly apolitical, never voting and serving as a consensual figure in a ceremonial monarchy that unites the UK through royal events and pageantry.

  • The Crown lost the political struggle, leaving power organized around Parliament's supremacy and constitutionally organized.

Further detail

  • Brexit created an unprecedented constitutional situation without clear rules, including uncertainty over prorogation.

  • Whether Britain needs a written or codified constitution remains an open question that would require a constitutional convention, and not everyone supports it.

  • The monarchy remains vulnerable to crises, but no alternative has ever gathered enough support.

8. Parliamentary Sovereignty and Elections

★ Must-know

📌 Parliamentary sovereignty means that Parliament can make and unmake laws, and courts cannot disapply an Act of Parliament.

  • The constituencies are distributed as follows:

    • 543 in England
    • 57 in Scotland
    • 32 in Wales
    • 18 in Northern Ireland
  • Under first-past-the-post, each voter chooses one candidate at a polling station, and the candidate with the most votes wins without needing 50% of the vote.

📌 General elections are held every five years, usually on a Thursday and often in May or June; the monarch formally dissolves Parliament on the Prime Minister’s advice, and the Prime Minister chooses the date but must call an election once five years have elapsed.

Further detail

  • The British constitution is uncodified, flexible, drawn from several sources, and subordinate to the legislature.

  • The House of Commons is the elected lower chamber, while the House of Lords is the upper chamber, composed mainly of appointed peers.

  • The right to vote belongs to registered British citizens, qualifying Commonwealth citizens, and citizens of the Republic of Ireland who reside in the UK; people with legal incapacity and Lords peers are disqualified.

  • Women over 30 gained the vote in 1918, while men could vote from age 21; in 1928 women gained the vote from age 21.

  • The voting age has been 18 since 1969, and a plan proposes lowering it to 16 at the next general election.

  • First-past-the-post is criticized for weak proportionality, low vote shares for some MPs, underrepresentation of small parties, and governments usually winning a seat majority without a popular majority; no government has had a popular majority since the Second World War.

  • In the 2015 election, the Conservatives won 50.9% of seats with 36.9% of votes, while UKIP won one seat with 12.6% of votes.

  • First-past-the-post is considered easy to understand and conducive to stable single-party governments and strong majorities, and its supporters argue that it prevents radical parties from entering Parliament.

Memory Hook

Parliament makes and unmakes laws; courts cannot disapply them

9. The House of Lords and Its Limits

★ Must-know

  • As of August 2025, the House of Lords comprises 26 Lords Spiritual, who are Church of England bishops and archbishops, and Lords Temporal, including 92 hereditary peers and 718 life peers.

  • The 1999 reform reduced the total number of peers from 1,330 to 669 and hereditary peers from about 750 to 92, making life peers the majority and establishing the House of Lords Appointments Commission.

  • Party-appointed life peers are working peers who generally vote along party lines, whereas HLAC-appointed life peers are people's peers, or crossbenchers, who do not vote along party lines.

  • The House of Commons dominates the House of Lords because it is elected and the Lords' power to block legislation is limited.

  • The Parliament Act 1911 removed the Lords' power to block money bills and limited its ability to block other legislation to two years; a bill passed three times by the Commons could not be blocked.

Further detail

  • Before 1958, almost all Lords members were hereditary peers whose seats passed from father to son.

  • The Life Peerage Act 1958 established life peerages, which provide a seat for life that cannot be passed on.

  • The King's Speech in July 2024 announced legislation to abolish all hereditary peers, which is before Parliament.

  • The House of Lords is criticized as unelected and out of touch, and reform attempts have not yet succeeded; the Conservatives are its largest group, with 270 seats.

  • In 1909, the Lords rejected the Commons' People's Budget, which raised taxes on the wealthiest, violating the convention against blocking budgets; after the Liberals won a snap election, the Lords gave in.

📌 The Parliament Act 1949 reduced the Lords' blocking power to one year, and that power has been used only four times since 1949.

📌 Under the Salisbury Convention, the House of Lords does not block a bill implementing an electoral promise, such as the EU Referendum Act 2015.

10. Political Parties in Parliament

★ Must-know

  • The Labour Party is progressive and centre-left; it moved right under Tony Blair's New Labour, and Keir Starmer, described as more left-wing than Blair, led Labour to a 2024 landslide and became Prime Minister with 398 MPs.

  • The Scottish National Party's main aim is Scottish independence; it is broadly left-wing, opposed Brexit, and saw support for independence grow after Brexit, but its independence goal was rejected in the 2014 referendum.

Further detail

  • The Conservative Party, or Tories, is centre-right and contains a broad range of views on social policy, taxation, and whether Brexit should be rejected, hard, or soft.

  • In 2022, Boris Johnson resigned after Partygate, Liz Truss succeeded him and was removed after six weeks following catastrophic economic policy, and Rishi Sunak became Prime Minister.

  • The Liberal Democrats are centrist, support social justice with minimum state intervention, and were the only clearly anti-Brexit mainstream party, promising to reverse Brexit in 2019; their leader is Ed Davey and they have 72 seats.

  • Reform UK is a right-wing populist party led by Nigel Farage; formerly called the Brexit Party, it advocated a no-deal Brexit and was renamed in January 2021.

  • The Green Party of England and Wales combines environmentalism with left-wing economic policy.

  • Led by John Swinney, the SNP lost 38 seats in the 2024 election and was left with nine seats amid corruption scandals.

  • Plaid Cymru is the Welsh party whose main aim is Welsh autonomy; led by Rhun ap Iorwerth, it has four seats.

  • The Democratic Unionist Party seeks to keep Northern Ireland in the UK, is very socially conservative, and had five seats in 2024; its leader is Gavin Robinson.

  • Sinn Féin supports reunification with the Republic of Ireland and is left-wing and socially progressive; led by Mary Lou McDonald, it refuses to take its Westminster seats because it does not recognize British rule.

11. Government Control of Parliament and Parliamentary Lawmaking

★ Must-know

📌 The government controls much of Parliament because it usually leads the Commons majority party, cabinet members are mostly MPs, and the Lords cannot block legislation; this creates less separation of powers than in the US or France.

  • The whip system sends MPs daily voting instructions, with a three-line whip applying the strongest pressure; whips enforce party discipline, and rebels may be suspended or resign and struggle to be elected without party support.

  • Under Standing Order 14, government business has precedence; Parliament sits about 155 days, of which the government controls about 120, and the Leader of the House of Commons sets the weekly timetable.

  • Government departments draft most legislation because individual MPs lack the necessary legal and technical expertise, and government bills usually pass without major amendments.

  • In each chamber, a bill passes through these stages:

    • first reading
    • second reading
    • committee stage
    • report stage and third reading
    • consideration in the other house

📌 A public bill is introduced by a minister and supported by the government, often to deliver its manifesto, whereas a private member’s bill is introduced by an MP outside the government.

  • In parliamentary ping-pong, an amended bill returns to its originating chamber; exchanges continue until agreement and royal assent, while failure to compromise kills the bill, though the government may reintroduce it the next year and the Lords cannot block it a second time.

  • Parliament has three roles:

    • scrutinising legislation
    • holding the government to account
    • holding debates

Further detail

  • To deter Channel crossings, Sunak's Rwanda policy sought to transfer asylum seekers to Rwanda; after courts found Rwanda insufficiently safe under the UK's international obligations, Sunak introduced and passed a law declaring Rwanda safe despite public and Lords opposition.

📌 Collective cabinet responsibility requires ministers to vote with the government, while whips encourage backbenchers to follow; strong party discipline helps the government rarely lose votes, since it must deliver its manifesto promises to voters.

📌 Private members' bills proposed by backbenchers or opposition MPs receive very little parliamentary time and are easy for the government to block.

  • Government departments draft most legislation because they have legal and technical expertise individual MPs lack, and such legislation usually passes without major amendments.

  • The 2016 Turing law episode saw the government block a private member’s bill seeking pardons for living and dead men convicted of illegal same-sex relations, then pass its own public bill granting pardons only to the dead.

  • At second reading, the main chamber discusses a bill’s general principles and makes no amendments; at committee stage, about 20 MPs examine details, question the minister and may propose amendments.

  • The Lords is a revising chamber that scrutinises bills and draws attention to measures it considers unfair or against the public interest; almost no public bill fails in the Commons, though amendments may be made, including in the Lords.

  • MPs question ministers orally or in writing, mainly in writing, to press for action, seek information and require ministers to defend decisions; Prime Minister’s Questions takes place every Wednesday for 30 minutes.

12. Government Formation, Majorities, and Prime Ministerial Leadership

★ Must-know

  • 🔄 Government formation proceeds as follows:
    1. A party wins a majority at a general election.
    2. Its leader goes to Buckingham Palace.
    3. The King appoints the leader Prime Minister.
    4. The Prime Minister nominates the government.

📌 A coalition government has two or more parties governing together, with Cabinet seats and a joint programme requiring compromise, whereas a minority government lacks an overall majority and depends on another party’s support on important matters.

  • The Prime Minister:

    • appoints the government
    • oversees government policy
    • represents the UK internationally
    • makes important appointments
  • A Prime Minister’s success depends on:

    • the parliamentary majority
    • competence and ability to lead the party
    • events

Further detail

  • When George I became king in 1714, he gave Robert Walpole the reins of government because Walpole could command a parliamentary majority; Walpole was First Lord of the Treasury, a position the Prime Minister still holds.

  • The 2010 coalition joined the Conservatives and Liberal Democrats, while the 2017 Conservative minority government secured DUP support on confidence motions, the budget and Brexit legislation in exchange for £1 billion in Northern Ireland funding.

  • The Prime Minister chooses Cabinet members, chairs meetings, sets priorities and can reshuffle the Cabinet.

  • Margaret Thatcher’s initially small majority limited what she could pass, but her popularity rose after the Falklands War and a larger majority enabled more radical changes despite popular opposition.

  • Theresa May lost her majority in the 2017 snap election, governed with DUP support, faced Tory MPs blocking her Brexit deal and ministerial resignations, and resigned before Boris Johnson succeeded her.

  • 🔄 The events leading to Truss’s resignation were:

    1. Her mini-budget proposed radical tax cuts.
    2. Markets reacted with concern.
    3. Interest rates and the cost of living rose.
    4. Her popularity and party support fell.
    5. Ministers resigned.
    6. She resigned after six weeks.
  • Truss took office after Johnson was forced out following scandals he tried to cover up, most notably Partygate, involving parties during Covid lockdown, which destroyed his popularity and prompted ministerial resignations.

Memory Hook

A larger majority gives a Prime Minister more room to implement policy.

13. Cabinet, Ministers and Civil Service

Key Concepts & Definitions

  • His Majesty's Loyal Opposition: The shadow cabinet formed after a defeat by members of the second-largest party.

★ Must-know

  • The Cabinet consists of 23 of the most important ministers, including secretaries of state who head government departments, and meets every Wednesday to discuss policy objectives, taxation and government spending under the Prime Minister’s control.

  • Ministers and the Civil Service prepare public bills, ministers seek Cabinet support to put them on the parliamentary agenda, and departments may also make technical legislation when Parliament delegates powers to ministers.

📌 Under the ministerial code, ministers must account for their departments, give Parliament accurate and truthful information, be as open as possible and offer their resignation if they knowingly mislead Parliament.

  • Outside a general election, party members choose a new leader who automatically becomes prime minister because the party still holds a Commons majority, so voters do not vote; this occurred with Burnham in July 2026.

Further detail

  • Ministers must be MPs, unlike in France and the US, and rely on Civil Service experts for legal and policy expertise in running departments.

  • After a committee concluded that Boris Johnson had misled Parliament about Partygate, he resigned as an MP and protested that it was a “witch-hunt.”

  • After a general-election defeat, a government is replaced; Gordon Brown was succeeded by David Cameron in 2010, and Rishi Sunak by Keir Starmer in 2024.

  • Before an election, MPs backed by influential cabinet members can pressure a prime minister to resign based on electoral calculations, as occurred with Johnson and Truss.

  • The leader of the opposition receives a salary, and shadow secretaries of state propose alternative policies and are expected to be ready to govern if their party wins.

  • The opposition receives priority during Prime Minister's Questions and ministerial questions.

Key Concepts & Definitions

  • Barrister: A lawyer who represents people in court, including as prosecutor or defence counsel, and specialises in areas of law and advocacy.
  • Solicitor: Deals with clients, chooses barristers and negotiates their fees, prepares briefs, and supports clients during hearings.

★ Must-know

  • Statutory law consists of Acts of Parliament, whereas common law consists of law established through court decisions known as precedents.

  • When a case's facts resemble an earlier case, judges follow its decision as a binding precedent unless it came from a lower court, promoting legal certainty.

  • Common-law systems combine statutes with binding court decisions, whereas civil-law systems codify all law in codes and do not treat precedents as binding.

  • In the common-law adversarial system, lawyers lead the case and the judge acts as a referee, while in the civil-law inquisitorial system judges play a larger role in investigation and questioning.

  • UK legal training divides lawyers into solicitors and barristers, whereas the United States has no divided legal profession.

Further detail

  • Before Parliament sat regularly in the nineteenth century, people seeking remedies unavailable through statute turned to royal courts, whose recorded decisions were later invoked in cases and formed common law.

  • Common law governs: contract law, tort law, succession law, some criminal law, including definitions of murder, manslaughter, and kidnapping

  • Common-law systems exist in the UK and about 80 countries it colonised or influenced, while civil law is the most common system, used in about 150 countries.

  • In UK criminal trials, prosecutors and defence lawyers have the same qualifications, while in the described civil-law system prosecutors are magistrates trained at the École nationale de la magistrature and sit alongside judges.

  • England and Wales have about 15,000 barristers, whose work traditionally involves little client contact and is considered more prestigious.

  • Solicitors can increasingly represent clients in court and draw up documents such as wills and title deeds and handle conveyancing for house purchases or sales.

  • The divided profession offers barristers' advocacy and specialist expertise alongside solicitors' client services, but can mean paying twice, choosing a career early, and trusting both lawyers.

Memory Hook

Common law follows binding precedents; civil law applies codified rules.

15. Judges, Parliament, and Constitutional Change

★ Must-know

  • Most UK judges are former lawyers who first qualify as solicitors or barristers, unlike the French model described in which judges enter through a competitive examination and magistracy school.

  • When neither precedent nor statute applies, a UK judge may develop the law by creating a rule guided by moral or legal principles from scholarship or other cases, judicial deference to Parliament on serious social issues, the requirement for parliamentary authorisation of new public expenditure, and Parliament's wishes.

  • On social and economic issues, UK courts defer to Parliament, cannot strike down an Act of Parliament, and Parliament can overrule judge-made law by legislation.

  • Under the Human Rights Act, judges may issue a declaration of incompatibility when an Act of Parliament violates the European Convention on Human Rights, but the declaration does not invalidate the law and instead alerts Parliament.

  • The court ruled the five-week prorogation illegal because it prevented Parliament from carrying out an essential part of its work, and Parliament was recalled.

  • The UK is a composite state of England, Scotland, Wales, and Northern Ireland, with one flag and one head of state and government, while each nation has its own anthem, sports teams, language, and culture.

  • The 1603 Union of the Crowns followed Elizabeth's death without an heir, when her cousin James VI of Scotland became James I of England; Scotland retained its own Parliament, so this was a personal rather than political union.

  • In 1603, after Elizabeth died without an heir, her cousin James VI of Scotland became James I of England, creating a personal union while Scotland retained its own Parliament.

  • The 1707 Act of Union dissolved the Scottish Parliament and established the Kingdom of Great Britain, whose flag combined the crosses of St George and St Andrew.

  • After the 1707 union, Scotland was ruled from London but retained its Presbyterian Church and distinct hybrid English-continental legal system.

  • Protestant plantations placed English Anglican and, in northern Ireland, Scottish Presbyterian landowners on Catholic lands, making Protestants the majority in the north-east and contributing to centuries of religious conflict.

  • The 1801 Act of Union included Ireland in the UK, dissolved the Irish Parliament and added St Patrick’s cross to the Union flag, forming the Union Jack.

  • In 1916, British repression of the week-long Easter Rising turned opinion toward separatism; after winning a large majority in the 1918 general election, separatists refused to sit at Westminster and established the Dáil in Dublin.

  • The 1921 Anglo-Irish Treaty granted Irish independence while the six northern counties remained self-governing within the UK; Éire left the UK, adopted a constitution in 1937, and the UK became the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland.

Further detail

  • District judges sit in county, magistrates', and family courts; circuit judges sit in the Crown Court; and High Court judges sit in the High Court.

📌 Court of Appeal and UK Supreme Court judges must already have served as judges.

16. Devolution and National Autonomy

Key Concepts & Definitions

  • Devolution: The transfer of certain powers from central government to regional authorities within the state, also called internal self-determination.

★ Must-know

  • In the 1979 devolution referendums, Scotland recorded 51.9% support but only 32% of the electorate voted yes, below the required 40% threshold; Wales recorded only 20% support.

  • After Tony Blair promised referendums in 1997, Scotland voted 75% in favour of devolution and Wales by a very small majority, leading to legislatures in Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland.

  • Devolved matters include:

    • agriculture
    • education
    • health
    • policing
    • housing
  • On 18 September 2014, 55% voted against Scottish independence and 45% voted for it; one reason for the no vote was the stated difficulty of an independent Scotland joining the EU.

  • After 62% of Scots voted to remain in the EU, the Scottish government asked the UK Supreme Court whether it could hold another independence referendum without Westminster’s approval; on 23 November 2022, the Court ruled that it could not because the constitution is a reserved matter.

Further detail

  • The Scotland Act 1998 established a Scottish Parliament and executive in Edinburgh with wide powers, while the Wales Act 1998 established a Welsh assembly and executive with fewer devolved powers.

📌 Westminster can overturn laws passed by devolved legislatures and can abolish those legislatures; the Northern Ireland Assembly established in 1998 has been suspended, not abolished.

  • The SNP took control of the Scottish executive in 2007 and won a landslide in 2011, after which it promised an independence referendum.

  • The Welsh independence movement has been weaker than Scotland’s because Wales has been part of the union longer and is more economically dependent on England.

17. Brexit and the Union’s Future

★ Must-know

  • The Northern Ireland Troubles lasted from 1968 to 1998 and pitted nationalists seeking to leave the UK and reunite with the Republic against unionists seeking to remain in the UK.

  • Bloody Sunday in January 1972, when the army killed 13 protesters, escalated the conflict and was followed by the suspension of the Northern Ireland Parliament and direct rule from London.

  • The 1998 Good Friday Agreement, brokered by the British and Irish governments, established a Northern Ireland Assembly and power-sharing and provided for free movement between north and south.

  • Brexit could create a land border between the UK and the EU on the island of Ireland, and a hard Brexit outside the single market could require customs checks between north and south.

  • Boris Johnson’s October 2019 deal used the Northern Ireland Protocol to keep Northern Ireland in the EU customs union and place checks between Great Britain and Northern Ireland, prompting DUP opposition to a de facto Irish Sea border.

Further detail

  • The armed groups included:

    • the republican IRA
    • the loyalist UDA
    • the loyalist UVF
  • About 30 years of sectarian violence during the Troubles left more than 3,500 people dead.

  • In the 2016 referendum, Northern Ireland voted 55% to remain in the EU, while the UK as a whole voted to leave.

  • A hard border could disrupt business and movement, revive memories of past conflict and tensions, and jeopardise the Good Friday Agreement.

  • The 2023 Windsor Framework relaxed checks under the Northern Ireland Protocol but did not convince unionists.

  • The DUP boycotted power-sharing at Stormont from February 2022 to January 2024, causing political deadlock.

  • The 2022 census found that Catholics outnumbered Protestants in Northern Ireland, and Sinn Féin won the 2022 Assembly election; unionists refused to work with the party from 2022 to 2024, and Michelle O’Neill became the first nationalist First Minister in February 2024.

Memory Hook

A border after Brexit risks reviving the Troubles and weakening the Good Friday Agreement.

18. The Case for a Written Constitution

★ Must-know

📌 The UK is a union state formed from four distinct nations, rather than a nation state formed around a single nation.

  • Brexit strained the UK constitution because it brought drastic, sudden change to a system that works through gradual change and created an unprecedented political crisis with no clear rules, as illustrated by the prorogation crisis.

  • Arguments for a written constitution include: clarity, modernisation, easier prevention of government abuse of power, stronger protection of human rights

  • Arguments for retaining the status quo include: the risk that a constitutional convention would be divisive, the flexibility of the current system, the democratic value of parliamentary sovereignty because it can adapt to the will of the people

Further detail

  • Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland have obtained greater autonomy, while the Republic of Ireland gained independence in 1921.

  • Brexit has placed the unity of the UK in greater danger than before.

  • Brexit has not yet led to a constitutional moment in the UK.

Memory Hook

Written rules promise clarity; the unwritten status quo preserves flexibility.

Synthesis Tables

Composition of the House of Lords

Peer typeAppointmentVoting tendency
Working peersPolitical party appointmentGenerally vote along party lines
People's peersHLAC appointmentCrossbenchers; do not vote along party lines

Devolution and Reserved Powers

Devolved to regionsReserved at Westminster
AgricultureConstitution
Education and healthTaxation
Policing and housingDefence and foreign affairs

Test yourself

Take a 67-question practice quiz on British Constitutional Monarchy Lecture 1, with every answer explained.

1. A country’s head of state is a monarch, and the monarch’s power is shared with a constitutionally organised government. What type of system is this?

2. A student is identifying the two chambers of the British Parliament and their positions. Which pairing is correct?

Take the quiz →

Study with flashcards

Memorize the key concepts of British Constitutional Monarchy Lecture 1 with 97 flashcards.

What is a constitutional monarchy?

A system where a monarch shares power with a constitutionally organised government.

Which two chambers make up the British Parliament?

The House of Commons and the House of Lords.

Who becomes Prime Minister after a party wins a parliamentary majority?

The leader of the winning party.

See the flashcards →

Related classes

Make your own study guides

Upload your class notes and Revizly writes a study guide, a quiz and flashcards in about a minute.

Study guide maker