Study guide: EU Competences and Institutions

Course Outline

  1. European Integration and the Pursuit of Peace
  2. The EU as an International Organisation
  3. Treaty Control and Revision
  4. Popular Consent and Treaty Revision
  5. The Union’s Legal and Political Nature
  6. EU Enlargement, Accession Procedures and Criteria
  7. Protecting Values After Accession
  8. Withdrawal, Brexit and Constitutional Crises
  9. European Integration and State Status
  10. Sincere Cooperation and External Association Agreements
  11. Sincere Cooperation, Indirect Administration and Judicial Protection
  12. Autonomy and Institutional Cooperation
  13. Member State Participation Rights
  14. Institutional Balance and Council Voting Crises
  15. EU Budget and Own Resources
  16. Differentiated Integration
  17. EU Acts and Legislative Procedure
  18. Conditions and Types of Direct Effect
  19. Primacy of EU Law
  20. French Courts, Constitutional Limits and EU Primacy
  21. Review of Directive Implementation
  22. Conferral and Categories of Competence
  23. Subsidiarity and National Parliamentary Oversight
  24. The Principle of Proportionality
  25. EU Institutions and Commission Organisation
  26. Commission Powers, Initiative and Accountability
  27. Council Organisation and Powers

Key Dates

  1. 9 May 1950The Schuman speech set out an approach to overcoming national antagonisms through the Community method.
  2. 21 April 1970the Council adopted the own-resources decision, ending exclusive financing of the Community budget through direct Member State contributions and establishing financial autonomy for the European Communities.
  3. 1973in Commission v. Italy, Case 39/72, the Court of Justice held that a Member State cannot apply a Community regulation incompletely or selectively because it opposes the measure or considers it contrary to its national interests
  4. 1974the German Federal Constitutional Court held that it would apply European Community law only while that law provided fundamental-rights protection equivalent to the German Constitution
  5. 1979the Court of Justice recognised mutual recognition in the context of the internal market and the free movement of goods
  6. November 2016the UK Supreme Court in Miller 1 held that the Government needed parliamentary authorisation before triggering Article 50 TEU
  7. 2019the UK Supreme Court in Miller 2 held that the Government’s prorogation of Parliament was unlawful and of no effect because it prevented Parliament from performing its constitutional functions at a crucial point in the Brexit process
  8. 2019Scotland, after voting overwhelmingly to remain in the European Union in the 2016 referendum, sought a self-determination referendum that Boris Johnson declined
  9. 2020The United Kingdom withdrew from the European Union under the Article 50 procedure, following ratification by the UK and the EU

1. European Integration and the Pursuit of Peace

★ Must-know

  • European Union law helps explain the political and legal issues of European integration, understood as organising peace and promoting economic, social and environmental progress among Member States and people in Europe.

  • The course uses historical, institutional and normative approaches to study European integration: peace as the EU’s primary mission, the institutionalisation of supranationality, and normative power and its relation to supranationality.

Further detail

  • The course presents Brexit, democratic and liberal-democratic crises, economic and social crisis, migration, health, the war in Ukraine and environmental crisis as issues that reveal challenges or limits of European integration.

  • After the Second World War, states established international organisations as frameworks for collective action and preventive diplomacy.

  • The Council of Europe system was intended to rebuild Europe’s moral and democratic order, including through the Treaty of London of May 1949, conventions concluded under its auspices and the European Convention on Human Rights.

  • The European Court of Human Rights contributes to shaping a democratic standard in Europe through the European Convention on Human Rights.

  • The EEC is presented as the cornerstone of progressive economic and social integration.

Memory Hook

National antagonisms and war → efforts to build lasting peace through integration.

2. The EU as an International Organisation

Key Concepts & Definitions

  • International organisation: An international organisation is a subject of international law established by states to organise relations and undertake common action.

★ Must-know

  • Article 47 TEU expressly gives the European Union legal personality.

Further detail

📌 The EU’s legal personality was formalised by the Treaty of Lisbon, whereas before Lisbon its international legal personality was described as informal despite its ability to act internationally.

  • The Treaty of Maastricht introduced the EU in 1992.

  • Article 34 of the European Convention on Human Rights allows individuals claiming to be victims of a Convention violation to apply to the European Court of Human Rights.

  • Article 218 TFEU provides for the EU’s capacity to conclude international agreements.

  • Article 263 TFEU allows a legal person to bring proceedings against an EU act under specified conditions.

Memory Hook

States possess sovereignty; the EU has legal personality and only the competences conferred on it.

3. Treaty Control and Revision

Key Concepts & Definitions

  • Principle of conferral: The principle of conferral means that the EU may act only within competences conferred on it by the Member States.
  • Ultra vires review: Ultra vires review is a court’s examination of whether a public, administrative or supranational authority has acted within its legally conferred competence.

★ Must-know

📌 International organisations are created by states through treaties agreed by the states that become parties to them.

  • Under Article 5 TEU, competences not conferred on the EU by the Member States remain with the Member States.

📌 Article 48 TEU governs treaty revision, and Member States retain decisive roles throughout the revision process.

Further detail

  • The EEC was established by the Treaty of Rome of 1957.

📌 The course distinguishes transfer of competence, which gives the EU authority to act within the conferred field, from delegation, in which an organisation acts temporarily on behalf of the authority that delegated it.

  • Article 218(11) TFEU allows the Court of Justice to give an opinion on whether a proposed international agreement is compatible with EU primary law; an incompatible agreement cannot enter into force.

  • In the Honeywell case in 2010, the German Federal Constitutional Court declared an EU act incompatible with the German Constitution because it considered that the act exceeded EU competence.

📌 The ordinary revision procedure is distinct from the simplified revision procedure, which cannot revise provisions of the TEU and is limited to the TFEU.

📌 The simplified revisione can authorise the Council to act by qualified majority in an area where the treaties otherwise require unanimity, but it does not apply to decisions with military or defence implications.

  • A qualified majority in the Council requires at least 55%55\% of Council members representing at least 65%65\% of the EU population.

Key Concepts & Definitions

  • Implied powers: Implied powers are competences not expressly stated in the Treaties but logically linked to an express competence and necessary for achieving the Union’s objectives.

★ Must-know

  • The EU is founded on representative democracy under Article 10 TEU, and the course states that there is no single European people.

📌 Under Articles 48 and 49 TEU, treaty revision and accession require the consent of the Member States’ peoples through the applicable national procedures.

📌 Under Article 48(6) TEU, a bridge-clause decision cannot apply to decisions with military implications or decisions in the area of defence.

  • 🔄 The procedure proceeds as follows:
    1. The initiative is notified to national Parliaments.
    2. A national Parliament may oppose it within six months of notification.
    3. If any Parliament opposes it, the decision cannot be adopted.
    4. If there is no opposition, the European Council may adopt the decision.

📌 Article 352 TFEU allows the Council to adopt appropriate measures when Union action is necessary to achieve Treaty objectives but the Treaties have not provided the necessary powers; it cannot be used to add a new policy area.

  • Unanimous ratification of a Treaty does not ensure a unanimous referendum result, since a referendum divides voters into opposing sides and can create political-legitimacy difficulties.

📌 The TEU and TFEU are formally treaties rather than a Constitution, although the Court of Justice has described the Treaties as the Union’s constitutional charter.

Further detail

  • Treaty ratification requires unanimous consent across the Member States; rejection by one state may lead to renegotiation or prevent the treaty from taking effect.

  • The Maastricht Treaty was rejected in a Danish referendum in June 1992, after which a renegotiated arrangement was put to a second referendum and approved.

  • The French and Dutch rejections of the proposed EU Constitutional Treaty led to its abandonment.

  • Protocols may grant a Member State specific exceptions or rights, but their adoption still requires the consent of all Member States.

  • In the 1971 AETR judgment, the Court of Justice recognised a parallel between written and unwritten competences, including the Union’s ability to act externally in connection with an express transport competence.

  • The Court of Justice regularly characterises the Treaties as the Union’s constitutional charter, including in the cited 1986 and 2009 decisions.

Memory Hook

Bridge clauses change how the Council votes; implied powers fill a necessary competence gap.

Key Concepts & Definitions

  • Confederation: A confederation is an association created by treaty between sovereign States, whose common bodies generally decide unanimously and whose decisions are addressed to States rather than directly to individuals.

★ Must-know

📌 The Union is an international organisation because it was created by treaties, but it is not a traditional intergovernmental organisation because individuals are also subjects of its law and its legal order has primacy and direct effect.

  • The Court of Justice initially described the Community as a “new legal order of international law” and later emphasised that Member States had limited sovereign rights in widening fields and that Community law had primacy and direct effect. - Court of Justice of the Communities

📌 A State is classically defined by a territory, a population and a sovereign authority, while the Union does not possess all three elements in the same way as a State.

  • Union citizenship, introduced by the Maastricht Treaty and set out in Article 20 TFEU, belongs to nationals of Member States, complements national citizenship and does not replace it.

📌 Under Article 5(2) TEU, the Union may act only within the competences conferred on it, while Member States cannot decide matters in the last resort where the Treaties have conferred competence on the Union.

  • The Union’s features distinguishing it from a confederation include:

    • An autonomous legal order
    • Direct effect
    • Primacy
    • Qualified-majority decision-making
    • Union citizenship
    • A directly elected Parliament
  • The Union combines confederal features, especially in the common foreign and security policy, with federal features in its legal system and common policies, so it does not fit neatly into either category.

  • The European Parliament represents citizens rather than only States and acts as a co-legislator.

  • The Union retains these confederal features:

    • The States remain masters of the Treaties, and treaty revision requires unanimity and ratification by all States
    • The Union has only the competences conferred on it by the States
    • Withdrawal is possible under Article 50 TEU
    • The CFSP remains largely intergovernmental, with decisions taken unanimously
    • The European Council and the Council are intergovernmental institutions

Further detail

  • After Maastricht, the Union comprised the Communities and policies under Titles V and VI TEU, but the Treaties did not expressly establish a legal personality specific to the Union, while the Communities had their own legal personality.

  • The Treaty of Lisbon merged the Union and the Community, clarifying the Union’s legal structure.

  • The integration process has four dimensions:

    • Normative integration
    • Substantive integration
    • Institutional integration
    • Collaborative integration
  • The Treaties’ territorial scope covers the territories of Member States with qualifications under Article 52 TEU, while the notion of Union territory remains tied to national definitions and the Schengen area includes non-EU Norway and Iceland.

  • The German Federal Constitutional Court described the Community as an association of States (Staatenverbund) in its judgment of 12 October 1993 and said in its judgment of 30 June 2009 that the Union has a federal form but largely intergovernmental decision-making and institutional composition.

  • Since the 1970 decision, the Union has had own resources and no longer depends solely on contributions from Member States.

Memory Hook

The Union borrows federal features but retains intergovernmental and confederal ones.

6. EU Enlargement, Accession Procedures and Criteria

Key Concepts & Definitions

  • Enlargement: The process of admitting new Member States into the European Union.
  • Absorption capacity: Its ability to integrate new Member States while maintaining the effective functioning of its institutions and policies.
  • EU acquis: The body of existing EU law, rules and obligations that a candidate State must progressively adopt.

★ Must-know

📌 Under Article 49 TEU, any European State that respects the Article 2 TEU values and is committed to promoting them may apply to join the Union.

  • The Copenhagen criteria cover:

    • Stable institutions guaranteeing democracy, the rule of law, human rights and minority protection
    • A viable market economy able to cope with competitive pressure
    • The capacity to fulfil membership obligations and implement the EU acquis
  • Accession under Article 49 TEU proceeds from application to candidate status, possible opening of negotiations, negotiation of admission conditions and treaty adjustments, unanimous Council approval after Commission consultation and European Parliament consent, conclusion of an Accession Treaty, and ratification by all contracting States.

Further detail

  • Enlargement is a political process shaped by political opportunity and is lengthy and complex.

  • Spain and Portugal joined the EEC in 1986 after their transitions to democracy, having been unable to join while governed by authoritarian regimes.

  • The fall of the Berlin Wall opened the way for Central and Eastern European countries to join, and the major 2004 enlargement included several of these States.

📌 Austria, Sweden and Finland participated in the European Economic Area before joining the EU in 1995, while Norway remains in the EEA without being an EU member and Switzerland participates in the internal market through bilateral agreements rather than EEA membership.

  • Article 2 TEU identifies these Union values:

    • Respect for human dignity
    • Freedom
    • Democracy
    • Equality
    • The rule of law
    • Respect for human rights
  • The Copenhagen criteria were established by the European Council in 1993, and the European Council in Madrid added an administrative criterion in 1995 requiring candidate countries to adapt their administrative structures for effective application of EU law.

  • Under Article 49(2) TEU, admission conditions and the necessary Treaty adjustments are agreed between the Member States and applicant State, and the agreement must be ratified by all contracting States under their respective constitutional requirements.

Memory Hook

Application → candidacy → negotiation → treaty → ratification

7. Protecting Values After Accession

Key Concepts & Definitions

  • Acquis communautaire: The body of legal rights and obligations linking the Member States, which an applicant country must respect and be able to implement.

★ Must-know

📌 Under Article 7 TEU, after the European Council unanimously finds a serious and persistent breach of Article 2 values, the Council may suspend certain rights deriving from the Treaties, potentially including the Member State’s voting rights.

  • During screening, the Commission examines chapter by chapter whether the applicant country meets the conditions under the accession criteria and reports on the procedure to the Council of Ministers.

Further detail

📌 Suspension of a Member State’s rights does not temporarily exclude it from the Union, and the State must continue to comply with all obligations arising from Union law.

📌 Article 7 sanctions target the State responsible for the breach rather than private individuals, so the Council must consider the consequences of suspension measures for those individuals.

  • The 2020 reform of accession negotiations aimed to streamline the process, which had previously proceeded chapter by chapter.

📌 The reversibility principle allows accession negotiations to be stopped; Turkey remained a candidate country after its negotiations stopped.

  • Turkey applied for EEC membership in 1987, was recognised as a candidate in 1999, and began negotiations in 2005, which later stopped.

  • A prior association agreement can facilitate or advance accession negotiations; Greece had such an agreement since 1961, applied in 1975, and joined the European Union in 1981.

Memory Hook

A serious and persistent breach of Article 2 values → possible suspension of Treaty rights

8. Withdrawal, Brexit and Constitutional Crises

★ Must-know

📌 Under Article 50(1) TEU, any Member State may decide to withdraw from the European Union in accordance with its own constitutional requirements.

  • 🔄 The withdrawal procedure proceeds as follows:
    1. The withdrawing state notifies the European Council of its intention.
    2. The European Council provides guidelines.
    3. The Union negotiates a withdrawal agreement with the state, taking account of the framework for their future

📌 The withdrawal agreement is negotiated under Article 218(3) TFEU, concluded on behalf of the Union by the Council acting by qualified majority, and requires the consent of the European Parliament.

Further detail

📌 Under Article 50(4) TEU, the withdrawing state’s representative does not participate in European Council or Council discussions or decisions concerning its withdrawal.

📌 The Article 50 withdrawal agreement is an agreement between the Union and the withdrawing state, not a treaty between that state and the other Member States.

  • The Treaty of Lisbon introduced the explicit withdrawal procedure after the political debate surrounding the failed Constitutional Treaty, signed in 2004.

  • The withdrawal agreement provided for a transition period during which EU law continued to apply in the United Kingdom.

  • The EU and the United Kingdom concluded an interim arrangement on the transfer of personal data in December 2020, and in June 2021 the European Commission adopted adequacy decisions permitting personal data transfers to the United Kingdom under EU data-protection law.

  • The 1998 Good Friday Agreement helped stabilise the border between Northern Ireland and the Republic of Ireland after a period of violent conflict.

  • The UK Internal Market Bill introduced by Boris Johnson’s Government contained provisions that could breach international law and parts of the Withdrawal Agreement, particularly the Northern Ireland Protocol.

Memory Hook

Parliamentary sovereignty, not governmental sovereignty

9. European Integration and State Status

Key Concepts & Definitions

  • European integration: The process through which Member States choose to organise and exercise some aspects of their sovereignty collectively.

Essential Points

  • Pierre Pescatore used the expression “European integration law” to identify the principles that characterise the distinctive nature of EU law.

📌 A state’s relationship with the European Union may take different forms, including membership, applicant or candidate status, partnership, or association.

10. Sincere Cooperation and External Association Agreements

★ Must-know

  • Under Article 4(3) TEU, the Union and the Member States must assist each other, in full mutual respect, in carrying out tasks arising from the Treaties.

  • Member States must take all measures necessary to ensure the effective implementation and respect of EU law, and their obligation is one of result.

  • EU law does not operate on reciprocity: each Member State must apply EU law even if another Member State fails to do so.

  • Canada already participates in the EU common commercial policy through the AECG under Article 207 TFEU and following, so describing it as the first associate country is ambiguous.

Further detail

  • A Member State that unilaterally sets aside EU obligations on the basis of its national interest undermines equality between Member States and the foundations of the Community legal order.

📌 Article 8 TEU provides for the Union to develop a special relationship with neighbouring countries, based on Union values and close, peaceful cooperation.

📌 Under Article 8(2) TEU, the Union may conclude specific agreements with neighbouring countries that include reciprocal rights and obligations, joint activities, and periodic consultation on implementation.

  • The EU has concluded association arrangements with former colonial territories, including the Cotonou Agreement.

  • EFTA association arrangements organise trade and relations between the EU, its institutions and partner countries; Austria was an EFTA member before joining the EU.

  • Article 238 of the Treaty of Rome provided for the possibility of becoming an associate of the European Economic Community.

  • Morocco has had one of the oldest EU partnerships and was long regarded as almost a Member State or a special associate partner.

Memory Hook

Selective compliance → unequal treatment → damage to the foundations of the EU legal order

11. Sincere Cooperation, Indirect Administration and Judicial Protection

Key Concepts & Definitions

  • Sincere cooperation: Sincere cooperation is an autonomous principle recognised by the Court of Justice, which any Member State can invoke.
  • Indirect administration: Indirect administration is the arrangement under which Member States are primarily responsible for implementing EU law, while Union institutions and agencies may support that implementation.

★ Must-know

📌 Under Article 4(3) TEU, the Union and Member States must assist one another, in full mutual respect, in carrying out Treaty tasks.

📌 The negative aspect of sincere cooperation requires Member States to refrain from measures that could jeopardise Union objectives or contradict EU law.

  • The obligation applies to these authorities:
    • national
    • local
    • judicial
    • political
    • executive

📌 Article 19(1) TEU requires Member States to provide sufficient remedies to ensure effective legal protection in fields covered by Union law.

Further detail

📌 The positive aspect of sincere cooperation requires Member States to take appropriate general or particular measures to fulfil Treaty obligations and obligations arising from Union acts.

  • In Deutsche Milchkontor, the Court held that Member States are responsible for implementing EU rules within their territories and may use national substantive and procedural rules only if those rules do not undermine EU-law effectiveness.

  • Member States must carry out the controls necessary to ensure that the conditions for granting EU aid are properly met.

📌 Article 47 of the Charter of Fundamental Rights guarantees the right to an effective remedy and effective judicial protection, including a court that is independent and impartial.

  • Since the Charter became legally binding with the Treaty of Lisbon, effective judicial protection has been protected at the level of EU primary law.

  • National courts are the ordinary courts for applying EU law.

Memory Hook

Picture national authorities as the EU law’s front line, with national judges guarding effective remedies.

12. Autonomy and Institutional Cooperation

★ Must-know

📌 Article 4(2) TEU requires the Union to respect Member States’ national identities, their fundamental political and constitutional structures, regional and local self-government, essential State functions and national security.

📌 Member States may retain diverse institutional arrangements, but national identity cannot justify failure to comply with EU obligations.

Further detail

  • In Case C-430/21 RS (2022), the Court of Justice interpreted the requirements concerning national judicial systems in the light of EU values.

  • Article 7 TEU provides a political procedure for responding when a Member State poses a clear risk of seriously breaching, or breaches, EU values.

  • The principle of sincere cooperation also applies between EU institutions under Article 13 TEU and supports the uniform and effective application of EU law.

📌 Member States remain free to choose their national means and procedures for implementing EU law, subject to institutional identity and the uniform and effective application of EU law.

  • In Czech Republic v European Commission, Case C-808/21 (2024), the Court rejected national identity as a justification for refusing EU citizens the right to stand for certain local elections in the Czech Republic.

  • Article 267 TFEU provides for preliminary rulings by the Court of Justice of the European Union.

  • Article 240 TFEU provides for COREPER, a committee of Member States’ Permanent Representatives that prepares the Council’s work and may adopt procedural decisions where the Council’s Rules of Procedure provide.

  • The European Council sets the Union’s general political directions and priorities under Article 15 TEU, while the Commission normally has the right of legislative initiative under Article 17(2) TEU.

  • The Council of the EU and the European Parliament exercise the Union’s legislative function together under Articles 14 and 16 TEU; Parliament represents citizens and the Council represents Member States.

  • The Treaties provide for administrative cooperation under Article 6 TFEU, enhanced cooperation under Article 20 TEU, interparliamentary cooperation under Article 12 TEU, diplomatic cooperation under the second paragraph of Article 35 TEU, defence cooperation under Article 42 TEU and cooperation in the area of freedom, security and justice under Title V of Part Three TFEU, including judicial and police cooperation under Article 67(3) TFEU.

Memory Hook

National diversity is permitted; using it to evade EU obligations is not.

13. Member State Participation Rights

★ Must-know

  • Membership gives Member States rights as well as duties, including representation in the Union’s institutions and participation in appointing Commission members.

  • Qualified-majority voting in the Council helps make collective decisions possible when unanimity among Member States would be difficult or could block action.

📌 Article 4 TEU guarantees equality of Member States before EU law, understood as the equal application of EU law and the same rights for people within each Member State’s jurisdiction.

Further detail

📌 Member States have equal rights to participate in the Council and European Council, but those rights must be understood in light of the objective of EU integration.

  • Under the classical one-state-one-vote approach, equal Member State voting rights would require unanimity and give each State a veto.

  • Fiscal matters and security and defence are examples of areas in which decisions are to be taken unanimously.

Memory Hook

Member States have equal participation rights, balanced against the Union’s integration objectives.

14. Institutional Balance and Council Voting Crises

Key Concepts & Definitions

  • Institutional balance: The principle that each EU institution must act within the limits of the powers conferred on it by the Treaties and respect the competences of the other institutions.

★ Must-know

  • The European Parliament represents EU citizens through elected representatives and participates with the Council in adopting regulations and directives.

  • Under Article 16 TEU, ministers from each Member State sit in the Council, where they debate and vote on EU legislation; the Council is one of the Union’s legislative chambers.

  • The Commission is composed of 27 independent members chosen for their competence and European commitment, proposes regulations and directives, and monitors Member State compliance with EU law.

  • The Empty Chair Crisis began in 1965 when France, under Charles de Gaulle, refused to participate in Council meetings, paralysing the institutions for six months.

📌 The crisis reflected a conflict between de Gaulle’s intergovernmental vision, which limited the Commission’s role, and proposals to strengthen the Commission and the European Assembly’s democratic legitimacy and powers.

📌 The 1966 Luxembourg Compromise established an informal practice under which, when a Member State claimed very important interests were at stake in a decision normally taken by qualified majority, Council members would seek an acceptable solution while respecting mutual and Community interests.

  • Under the double-majority system described for the Treaty of Lisbon, a Council decision requires support from 55% of Member States representing 65% of the EU population.

Further detail

  • The institutional balance became especially important when powers were recognised for the European Parliament, and the course links the principle to the Court of Justice’s Meroni affair of 1958.

  • Under Article 15 TEU, the European Council sets directions for EU legislation but has no legislative competence.

  • The Court of Justice gives the final ruling in disputes, can review the validity of Union acts, and safeguards the uniform application of EU law.

  • The European Parliament was an assembly in 1957 and initially had fewer competences; the European Council became a formal institution with the Treaty of Lisbon.

  • France opposed the Commission’s proposal to introduce qualified-majority voting in the Council, fearing that it could be outvoted and that the Community would become more supranational.

  • The Commission’s proposal also concerned a common agricultural policy and new Community resources intended to support financial autonomy.

📌 The French delegation’s interpretation of the Luxembourg Compromise was that discussion must continue until unanimous agreement is reached when very important interests are at stake.

  • In practice, the Luxembourg Compromise encouraged Council decisions to be adopted by consensus, meaning that no member opposed the decision even if every member had not obtained everything it wanted.

Memory Hook

France rejects qualified majority → Council paralysis → Luxembourg compromise

15. EU Budget and Own Resources

★ Must-know

  • The initial own resources included:

    • customs duties
    • agricultural levies
    • a resource based on VAT
  • The own-resources system gave the Community a degree of financial autonomy, but its resources remained insufficient and Member States continued to make national contributions.

Further detail

  • A resource based on Member States’ Gross National Income was subsequently developed to supplement the Community’s own resources.

📌 The European Coal and Steel Community had its own resources under the Treaty of Paris, while the European Economic Community initially relied on national contributions allocated at the discretion of national parliaments.

  • Member States may compare their contributions with the expenditure allocated to them, creating political disputes over which states contribute more than they receive.

  • The course identifies Margaret Thatcher’s demand for a budgetary correction with the expression “I want my money back.”

📌 Only a national parliament can approve new taxes, which makes granting an international organisation the power to create and collect taxes a question of sovereignty.

Memory Hook

Own resources give the Community autonomy; national contributions preserve Member State influence

16. Differentiated Integration

★ Must-know

📌 EU law distinguishes derogation or opt-out protocols from enhanced cooperation as two mechanisms for accommodating differences among Member States while pursuing integration.

  • Derogation protocols are provisions with the same legal value as the Treaties, unanimously accepted by all Member States, that create exceptions to general membership obligations for one or more states.

📌 A net-budget calculation compares a Member State’s contribution to EU revenue with EU expenditure allocated to that state, but it excludes benefits such as EU citizenship rights and cross-border mobility.

  • The EU’s 2021–2027 multiannual financial framework listed customs duties, VAT-based contributions and direct Member State contributions based on gross national income as its main resources.

Further detail

  • The UK, Germany, Denmark, the Netherlands and Sweden were identified as states that considered themselves net contributors because they gave more to the EU budget than they received.

  • In 2021, Denmark, Germany, the Netherlands and Sweden benefited from budgetary correction mechanisms that returned money to them.

  • A December 2020 own-resources decision introduced a contribution based on non-recycled plastic packaging waste, which began as a new EU resource in 2021.

  • The EU’s budgetary autonomy remains constrained by reliance on GNI-based contributions and financial compensation mechanisms.

  • A carbon border adjustment mechanism was proposed as a possible future EU resource, charging imports associated with carbon emissions to make them less price-competitive.

  • During the Covid crisis, the EU introduced an exceptional possibility for the Commission to borrow 750 billion euros in 2018 prices on the market.

Memory Hook

Opt-outs exempt particular states; enhanced cooperation lets willing states integrate further

17. EU Acts and Legislative Procedure

★ Must-know

  • Article 288 TFEU identifies these EU acts:
    • Regulations
    • Directives
    • Decisions
    • Recommendations
    • Opinions

📌 A regulation has general application, is binding in its entirety and is directly applicable in every Member State.

📌 A directive binds each Member State addressed as to the result to be achieved but leaves national authorities the choice of form and methods.

  • 🔄 The ordinary legislative procedure proceeds through these stages:
    1. The Commission proposes a law to the Council and Parliament.
    2. The Council and Parliament examine and may amend the proposal through up to three readings.
    3. They adopt the act if they agree on the same text; otherwise, no law is adopted.

Further detail

📌 A decision is binding in its entirety, and a decision specifying its addressees is binding only on those addressees.

  • Recommendations and opinions have no binding force, while atypical acts such as common positions and joint actions are used in the common foreign and security policy, where legislative acts cannot be adopted under Article 24 TEU.

  • In the Council, national-expert committees prepare legislative texts, and many acts are adopted by consensus after discussion in those committees.

18. Conditions and Types of Direct Effect

★ Must-know

  • A provision can have direct effect when it is sufficiently clear, unconditional because its application requires no subsequent discretionary measure, and precise.

  • Articles 51(1) and 52(5) of the Charter distinguish rights, which must be respected, from principles, which must be observed and do not themselves give rise to immediate rights to positive action.

  • Vertical direct effect allows an individual to invoke EU law against a state, while horizontal direct effect allows an individual to invoke EU law against another individual.

Further detail

  • Articles 101 and 102 TFEU and rights in the Charter of Fundamental Rights are identified as provisions with direct effect.

  • Regulations have both vertical and horizontal direct effect, and decisions have direct effect for their addressees when the obligation is unconditional, clear and precise.

  • Treaty competition rules, including Articles 101 and 102 TFEU, and provisions on establishment, services and workers’ free movement are identified as having both vertical and horizontal direct effect.

  • Article 30 TFEU prohibits Member States from introducing new customs duties in intra-Community trade, and Article 34 TFEU prohibits new quantitative restrictions on trade.

19. Primacy of EU Law

★ Must-know

  • The Court of Justice established the primacy of EU law through its case law; the principle was not enshrined in the treaties.

  • In Costa v ENEL, decided on 15 July 1964, the Court of Justice established the primacy of Community law over conflicting national legislation.

  • The Court’s primacy doctrine applies to all EU acts and gives EU law precedence over all domestic legal provisions, including constitutional rules.

  • The Court of Justice’s maximalist view requires every Member State authority—legislature, administration, and courts—to respect EU law regardless of the nature or rank of the national act.

📌 Under Simmenthal (ECJ, 9 March 1978, Case 107/77), incompatible new national legislative acts cannot reduce the effect of Community rules.

📌 National courts must set aside any national provision contrary to EU law, whether adopted before or after the EU rule, and interpret national provisions consistently with EU law.

Further detail

  • Costa v ENEL described the EEC Treaty as creating its own legal system, integrated into Member States’ legal systems from the treaty’s entry into force and binding on their courts.

  • The Court reasoned that Member States limited their sovereign rights by transferring powers to a Community with its own institutions, personality, legal capacity and international representation, creating law that binds both states and their nationals.

  • In International Handelsgesellschaft, Case 11/70, on 17 December 1970, the Court held that the validity or effect of an EU regulation could not be affected by incompatibility with national constitutional rules, including constitutional rights.

  • The Court’s reasoning treats primacy as necessary to preserve the autonomous character and uniform application of EU law, because allowing national provisions to override it could undermine the Community’s legal basis.

  • In Les Verts v. EP (1986), the Court of Justice described the Treaties as the European Community’s basic constitutional charter. - ECJ

📌 Since Francovich (Case 6/90, 19 November 1991), a Member State may be liable for a breach of primacy resulting from a law.

📌 Under Compagnie Alitalia (Conseil d’État, 3 February 1989), the administration must repeal administrative acts that are contrary to a directive.

Memory Hook

If Member States could override EU law, its uniformity and effectiveness—and potentially its existence—would be jeopardized.

20. French Courts, Constitutional Limits and EU Primacy

Key Concepts & Definitions

  • Constitutional identity: The core of values, principles, and fundamental structures specific to a State that cannot be erased or compromised, even by EU law.

★ Must-know

📌 French courts eventually accepted the primacy of treaties over statutes but did not accept EU law’s primacy over the Constitution.

  • In the IVG decision of 15 January 1975, the Conseil constitutionnel held that Article 61 empowers it to review statutes for constitutionality, not treaty compatibility under Article 55.

  • In Nicolo (Conseil d’État, 1989), the Conseil d’État accepted treaty primacy over statutes and ended the distinction between statutes adopted before and after treaties.

📌 Article 54 of the 1958 Constitution provides that if the Constitutional Council finds an international undertaking contains a clause contrary to the Constitution, ratification or approval requires a prior constitutional amendment.

  • In Sarran (Conseil d’État, 30 October 1998) and Fraisse (Cour de cassation), the courts held that Article 55 does not give international or EU treaties precedence over the Constitution.

Further detail

  • In its 1 March 1968 Syndicat général de fabricants de semoule decision, the Conseil d’État refused to set aside a later statute that conflicted with a treaty, invoking separation of powers.

  • In Jacques Vabres (Cour de cassation, 1975), ordinary courts accepted the power to review whether a statute complies with a treaty, relying on Article 55 of the Constitution.

  • The Conseil d’État recognized primacy over regulations in Boisdet (24 September 1990), over directives in Société Rothmans and Philip Morris (28 February 1992), and over general principles of Community law in SNIP (3 December 2001), after rejecting it in Paulin (28 July 2000).

  • In its 1992 review of the Maastricht Treaty under Article 54, the Constitutional Council found incompatibilities concerning EU citizenship and monetary union, and the Constitution was amended before ratification.

Memory Hook

Semoules resists, Vabres accepts, Nicolo aligns

21. Review of Directive Implementation

Key Concepts & Definitions

  • Mutual recognition: Requires Member States to treat the legislation of other Member States as providing protection equivalent to their own national safeguards.

★ Must-know

📌 In its June 2004 decision on the law on confidence in the digital economy, the Conseil constitutionnel treated directive transposition as a constitutional requirement under Article 88-1 and declined to review the transposing law, absent an express constitutional provision barring transposition.

  • Under Arcelor (Conseil d’État, 8 February 2007), when reviewing a decree transposing a directive, the court first checks whether EU law protects an equivalent principle; if so, it refers the issue to the CJEU, and if not, it reviews the decree itself against the constitutional principle.

📌 In La Quadrature du Net, the Conseil d’État stated that review of a decree transposing a directive must respect Article 88-1 of the Constitution, Article 4(3) TEU and the principles established by the Court of Justice, while resorting to the Constitution if EU law provides insufficient protection.

  • In Associação Sindical dos Juízes Portugueses (2018) and Aranyosi (2016), the Court of Justice treated mutual trust as a condition for the normal functioning of EU law.

Further detail

📌 In La Quadrature du Net / French Data Network (Conseil d’État, 21 April 2021), the court required correct transposition and respect for EU law while treating the Constitution as the supreme norm of the domestic order.

📌 Under La Quadrature du Net / French Data Network, where a constitutional requirement is invoked, the Conseil d’État checks whether EU law protects the relevant objective; if EU protection is absent or insufficient, it reviews the act against that constitutional requirement while interpreting the transposition obligation.

  • In Arcelor, the Conseil d’État reviewed a decree transposing a directive linked to the Kyoto Protocol by first examining the requirements of EU law.

📌 Article 1 of the German Basic Law requires all public authority to respect fundamental rights at all times.

📌 A national court cannot decide alone to refuse to apply an EU act, a position also associated with Commission v Italy.

Memory Hook

Check an EU equivalent first; refer to the CJEU if one exists, otherwise review nationally

22. Conferral and Categories of Competence

Key Concepts & Definitions

  • Principle of conferral: Limits EU action to competences granted to the Union by the treaties.

★ Must-know

📌 In an exclusive competence area, only the Union may legislate and adopt binding acts unless it empowers Member States or they implement Union acts.

📌 In a shared competence area, the Union and Member States may adopt binding acts, but Member States exercise their competence only to the extent that the Union has not exercised it or has ceased exercising it.

Further detail

  • The Treaty of Lisbon enshrined the distinction between exclusive, shared and supporting competences, which was not part of the original Treaty of Rome distinction.

📌 In supporting competence areas, the Union may support, coordinate or supplement Member State action, but its acts may not harmonise national laws or regulations or supersede Member State competence.

  • The treaties provide for EU coordination of Member States’ economic and employment policies and for EU competence to define and implement the common foreign and security policy, including the progressive framing of a common defence policy.

📌 In research, technological development and space, EU action does not prevent Member States from exercising their own competence or programmes.

📌 In development cooperation and humanitarian aid, EU action does not prevent Member States from exercising their own competence.

Memory Hook

Exclusive competence leaves Member States no independent legislative role; shared competence allows both levels to act.

23. Subsidiarity and National Parliamentary Oversight

Key Concepts & Definitions

  • Principle of subsidiarity: Allows EU action in non-exclusive competence areas only when Member States cannot sufficiently achieve the proposed action’s objectives and those objectives can be better achieved at Union level because of the action’s scale or effects.

★ Must-know

📌 National parliaments may send a reasoned opinion to the Commission within 8 weeks if they consider that a draft legislative act in a non-exclusive competence area breaches subsidiarity.

📌 Under Article 88-6 of the French Constitution, the National Assembly and Senate may issue an opinion on whether a draft EU legislative act complies with subsidiarity and address it to the presidents of the relevant assembly, the European Parliament and the Council.

  • Under Article 88-6 of the French Constitution, each chamber may send a reasoned opinion on a draft EU legislative act’s compliance with subsidiarity to the presidents of the relevant assembly, the European Parliament and the Council, and may bring an action before the CJEU alleging breach of subsidiarity.

📌 The subsidiarity mechanism requires collective action by national parliaments at EU level; a single national parliament cannot act alone against the EU to claim a breach.

📌 Under the yellow-card procedure, reasoned opinions representing at least one third of the votes allocated to national parliaments require the Commission to review its proposal; the threshold is lower for draft legislation on justice, freedom and security.

Further detail

  • Subsidiarity developed in response to concerns that expanding EU competences could reduce Member State, regional and federal autonomy and leave national parliaments merely registering EU decisions.

  • Subsidiarity oversight can lead to action remaining at Member State level, being taken at EU level, or being divided between the EU and Member States without unnecessary interference with national action.

  • The Commission must explain why a proposed EU action cannot sufficiently achieve its objectives at national level and would be better achieved at EU level.

  • The Treaty of Lisbon strengthened subsidiarity monitoring by involving national parliaments and, to a lesser extent, the Committee of the Regions.

  • Under Article 88-4 of the French Constitution, each chamber has a European Affairs Committee, and the government must submit EU draft or proposed acts to the National Assembly and Senate as soon as it knows of them.

  • Each of the 27 national parliaments is allocated two votes, with France’s National Assembly and Senate each holding one vote.

📌 Under the orange-card procedure, if reasoned opinions represent a majority of national-parliament votes and the draft falls under the ordinary legislative procedure, the Commission must review its proposal and decide whether to maintain or withdraw it; if it maintains the proposal, it must justify its decision to the European Parliament and the Council.

📌 Under the red-card proceduree, the proposal is not considered further if a simple majority of European Parliament members or 55% of Council members find that it breaches subsidiarity.

  • In Case C-84/94 and Case C-233/94, the Court treated compliance with subsidiarity as a circumstance to be addressed in the statement of reasons required by Article 296 TFEU and recognised a wide margin of discretion for the EU institutions.

  • In Philip Morris, the Court assessed whether the EU legislature could consider that the objectives of the proposed measures would be better achieved at EU level and said review must consider the contested act’s wording, context and circumstances.

Memory Hook

If national action cannot sufficiently achieve an objective, EU action may be justified by its scale or effects.

24. The Principle of Proportionality

Key Concepts & Definitions

  • Principle of proportionality: Set out in Article 5(4) TEU, requires that the content and form of Union action do not exceed what is necessary to achieve the Treaties’ objectives.

★ Must-know

📌 Subsidiarity determines the level at which a competence should be exercised, whereas proportionality determines the type and extent of EU action, favouring the measure least restrictive for Member States.

📌 The principle of proportionality applies to all EU competences, and the Court may invalidate an act when its author committed a manifest error.

Further detail

  • In CJEU, 13 November 1990, Fedesa, C-331/88, the Court applied the manifest-error standard when reviewing proportionality.

  • Proportionality review examines: the measure’s necessity in relation to its objective, whether the measure goes beyond what is appropriate, whether the measure is the least restrictive for individuals or economic operators

  • In Valsabbia v Commission (154/78 and joined cases, 18 March 1980), the Court held that burdens on economic operators must not exceed what is necessary to achieve the objective, but need not be assessed against the specific situation of a particular group of operators.

Memory Hook

Subsidiarity chooses the level of action; proportionality limits its form and intensity.

25. EU Institutions and Commission Organisation

★ Must-know

  • Article 13 TEU establishes an EU institutional framework intended to promote Union values, advance its objectives, serve the interests of the Union, its citizens and Member States, and ensure consistency, effectiveness and continuity of its policies.

  • Only the seven institutions listed in Article 13 TEU are institutions in the strict sense; agencies, advisory committees and the European External Action Service are other bodies.

📌 Commissioners serve five-year terms, are selected for general competence and European commitment, and must be independent of national and private interests and neither seek nor take instructions from governments.

  • Under Article 17(7) TEU, the European Council proposes a Commission President candidate by qualified majority after taking account of European Parliament elections and consultations; Parliament elects the candidate by a majority of its component members, and a rejected candidate must be replaced by a new proposal within one month.

  • The Commission acts collegially under Article 17(6) TEU, and its deliberations are confidential.

Further detail

  • The Commission and Court of Justice defend the Union’s general interest, the Council and European Council represent Member State governments, and the Parliament represents citizens.

  • The Union’s institutional system is complete, comprising political, administrative and judicial institutions, and the Union can adopt secondary legislation after its creation by the Member States.

📌 Article 245 TFEU requires Commission members to avoid actions incompatible with their duties, bars other occupations during their term, and requires integrity and discretion during and after office; Member States must respect their independence and not seek to influence them.

  • Although Article 17(5) TEU provided for a Commission of two-thirds the number of Member States from 2014, that reduction was not applied and the Commission retained one commissioner per Member State, for a total of 27.

  • The Council, acting by common accord with the President-elect and on the basis of Member State suggestions, adopts the list of other commissioners; Parliament then consents to the College as a whole, and the European Council appoints it by qualified majority.

📌 Under Article 17(8) TEU and Article 234 TFEU, Parliament may force the Commission to resign through a motion of censure requiring two-thirds of votes cast and a majority of Parliament’s members; if adopted, the whole Commission resigns.

  • The Commission’s written procedure deems a proposal adopted if commissioners raise no objection or reservation by the deadline; empowerment delegates management powers or administrative acts to individuals subject to Court review; and delegation or sub-delegation allows directors-general to carry out management and implementation acts in the Commission’s name, also subject to CJEU review.

  • The Commission President sets internal organisation, appoints Vice-Presidents other than the High Representative, and ensures the effectiveness, coherence and collegiality of the Commission’s work.

  • After serving as Commission President from 2004 to 2014, José Manuel Barroso took a position with Goldman Sachs, prompting concern about integrity and discretion after office.

26. Commission Powers, Initiative and Accountability

★ Must-know

  • The High Representative conducts and carries out the Common Foreign and Security Policy as mandated by the Council, chairs the Foreign Affairs Council, and promotes consistency in the Union’s external action.

  • Under Article 17(2) TEU, legislative acts generally require a Commission proposal unless the Treaties provide otherwise, giving the Commission a quasi-monopoly on legislative initiative.

  • A citizens’ initiative under Article 11(4) TEU requires at least one million citizens from at least seven Member States to invite the Commission to submit a proposal; the Commission may accept or refuse but must give reasons.

  • Under Articles 225 and 241 TFEU, the European Parliament may ask the Commission to submit a proposal and the Council may ask it to undertake studies or submit proposals; the Commission is not bound to comply but must give reasons for a refusal.

  • Member States are normally the first to implement EU law under Article 291 TFEU and the principle of sincere cooperation, while the Commission supervises their application under the control of the Court of Justice.

  • 🔄 The infringement procedure proceeds through: the Commission sends a formal notice, the State receives an opportunity to submit observations, the Commission issues a reasoned opinion, the Commission may refer the case to the CJEU if the State fails to comply within the set period

📌 Under Article 291(2) TFEU, the legislator may confer implementing powers on the Commission when uniform conditions are needed, while Article 290 TFEU allows the Commission to adopt delegated non-legislative acts supplementing or amending non-essential elements of a legislative act.

Further detail

  • Since 2009, the High Representative for Foreign Affairs and Security Policy has also been a Commission Vice-President; Kaja Kallas has held the post since December 2024.

📌 Under Article 18 TEU, the European Council appoints the High Representative by qualified majority with the agreement of the Commission President and may end the term by the same procedure; as a Commission member, the High Representative is also subject to Parliament’s vote of consent.

  • The High Representative coordinates external action in these areas:

    • common security
    • common commercial policy
    • cooperation with third countries
    • humanitarian aid
    • restrictive measures
  • The European External Action Service assists the High Representative, works with national diplomatic services, and includes officials from the Council Secretariat, the Commission and national services.

📌 Article 293 TFEU allows the Council to amend a Commission proposal only unanimously and allows the Commission to alter its proposal at any time.

  • In cases provided for by the Treaties, a group of Member States, the European Central Bank, or the Court of Justice may initiate the ordinary legislative procedure under Article 294(15) TFEU; the ECB also has initiative rights in monetary matters.

  • The Commission monitors Member States through: requests for information, the annual report on the application of EU law, the annual Rule of Law Report, accession screening, conditionality measures, infringement proceedings

📌 Under Regulation 2020/2092, if a rule-of-law breach affects the Union budget, the Commission may propose suspending a State’s access to funds after notifying it and allowing it to respond and propose corrective measures; the Council decides by qualified majority.

  • The Treaties give the Commission direct decision-making powers in fields including competition law and State aid, and it may impose fines, as illustrated by its decision concerning Microsoft’s bundling of software.

Memory Hook

A Member State’s failure to comply leads from dialogue to a reasoned opinion, then potentially to CJEU proceedings.

27. Council Organisation and Powers

★ Must-know

  • The Council is composed of one representative per Member State at ministerial level, empowered to commit that State’s government under Article 16 TEU; a vote cast by the representative commits the government, including when the representative is a minister of a constituent entity.

  • Under Article 16(1) TEU, the Council exercises legislative and budgetary functions jointly with the European Parliament and performs the policy-making and coordinating functions assigned to it by the Treaties.

📌 Since the Treaty of Lisbon, implementing powers are generally conferred on the Commission, but the legislator may confer them on the Council in specific and duly justified cases, including in the CFSP; other Treaty or secondary-law examples for the Council include agricultural prices, fishing quotas, competition and State aid, and economic and monetary policy.

Further detail

  • The Commission may be invited to Council sessions under the Council’s rules of procedure, but the Council may meet without it; the Commission’s participation lets it explain or defend proposals, respond to amendments, and modify proposals during the session.

  • Coreper coordinates the Council’s day-to-day work and prepares meetings of all Council configurations, while the European Council promotes overall coherence and receives reports from the Council Presidency on work since its previous meeting.

📌 Under Article 240 TFEU, the Council may adopt its rules of procedure by a majority of its members.

  • Under Article 16(9) TEU, the Council Presidency originally rotated among Member States for six months in alphabetical order, while the Council meeting in its Foreign Affairs configuration is chaired by the High Representative.

📌 The Council has no general right of legislative initiative, but it may ask the Commission by simple majority to undertake studies or submit proposals under Article 241 TFEU; the Commission must consider the request in good faith and report its follow-up and reasons.

  • In special legislative procedures, the Council may decide while the European Parliament is only consulted; in the CFSP, the Council decides within the objectives and general guidelines set by the European Council.

  • 🔄 The economic policy guidelines proceed through: the Council draws up draft guidelines by qualified majority, the European Council adopts a conclusion, the Council issues a recommendation

  • The Council also coordinates cooperation between Member States in the area of freedom, security and justice, including operational police cooperation, and employment policy coordination under Article 148 TFEU.

Memory Hook

The Commission normally implements EU law; the Council receives implementing powers only in specific, duly justified cases.

Synthesis Tables

Key EU Institutional Roles

InstitutionRepresents or safeguardsRole described
European ParliamentEU citizensParticipates with the Council in adopting legislation
CouncilMember State governmentsDebates and votes on EU legislation
European CouncilMember State leadersSets directions; does not legislate
CommissionGeneral EU interestProposes legislation and monitors compliance
Court of JusticeEU legal orderRules on disputes and reviews Union acts

French courts and primacy

Court or casePositionKey point
Conseil constitutionnel, IVG (1975)No treaty review under Article 61Constitutionality differs from treaty compatibility
Cour de cassation, Jacques Vabres (1975)Accepts treaty reviewArticle 55 permits ordinary courts to review statutes
Conseil d’État, Nicolo (1989)Accepts treaty primacyNo distinction by statute date
Conseil d’État, Sarran (1998)Rejects primacy over ConstitutionArticle 55 does not place treaties above the Constitution

Test yourself

Take a 94-question practice quiz on EU Competences and Institutions, with every answer explained.

1. Which description best captures European integration as a process that EU law helps explain?

2. What approach did the Schuman speech set out on 9 May 1950 to overcome national antagonisms?

Take the quiz →

Study with flashcards

Memorize the key concepts of EU Competences and Institutions with 92 flashcards.

What does European Union law help explain about integration?

Its political and legal issues.

Which approaches does the course use to study European integration?

Historical, institutional, and normative approaches.

What is an international organisation?

A subject of international law established by states to organise relations and undertake common action.

See the flashcards →

Related classes

Make your own study guides

Upload your class notes and Revizly writes a study guide, a quiz and flashcards in about a minute.

Study guide maker