Insanity Defense and Criminal Capacity

From the study guide

Course Outline

  1. Criminal Responsibility and Legal Terms
  2. Origins of the McNaughton Rules
  3. Insanity Defense and McNaughton Tests
  4. Mental Disease and Modern Debates
  5. Neuroscience and Psychopathy
  6. Halimi Case and Delirium
  7. Intoxication and Incapacity Readings

★ Must-know

  • Psychologists and psychiatrists may provide expert evidence in criminal trials about an accused person's mental capacity.

📌 A criminal act requires both actus reus, the act, and mens rea, the intention or state of mind.

Further detail

  • The legal vocabulary includes trial, accused or defendant, plaintiff, expert witness, insanity plea, lawyer or barrister, appeal, prosecution, burden of proof, balance of probabilities, mens rea, and actus reus.

Memory Hook

Actus reus is the act; mens rea is the guilty mind.

2. Origins of the McNaughton Rules

★ Must-know

  • In 1843, the House of Lords in Great Britain issued the ruling in R v. McNaughton, which became known as the McNaughton Rules.

Further detail

  • McNaughton shot and murdered Edward Drummond, believing Drummond was Prime Minister Robert Peel.
Read the full study guide →

Practice quiz preview

1. In a criminal trial, the evidence establishes that a defendant performed the prohibited act, but does not establish the required intention or state of mind. Which element has not been established?

2. A court needs expert evidence about whether an accused person had the mental capacity relevant to a criminal trial. Which professionals may provide that evidence?

3. In which year did the House of Lords in Great Britain issue the ruling in R v. McNaughton that became known as the McNaughton Rules?

Take the quiz (11 questions) →

Flashcard preview

What may psychologists and psychiatrists provide evidence about in criminal trials?

An accused person’s mental capacity.

What two elements must a criminal act involve?

Actus reus and mens rea.

In which year did the House of Lords issue the ruling in R v. McNaughton?

1843.

Whom did McNaughton shoot and murder, believing him to be Robert Peel?

Edward Drummond.

What do the McNaughton Rules presume about every person?

Every person is sane and sufficiently reasonable to be responsible for their crimes.

What must an accused prove under the McNaughton Rules to establish insanity?

A defect of reason or disease of the mind prevented them from knowing the act’s nature and quality or, if they knew it, that it was wrong.

See all 10 flashcards →

Frequently asked questions

What does the Insanity Defense and Criminal Capacity study guide cover?

It covers the core concepts of Insanity Defense and Criminal Capacity, organized by topic with the key definitions, explanations and takeaways, so it's easier to learn and remember.

Read the full study guide →

How many questions are in the Insanity Defense and Criminal Capacity quiz?

The practice quiz has 11 multiple-choice questions, each with an explanation. Use it to check what you know and find your gaps.

Take the quiz (11 questions) →

How do I study Insanity Defense and Criminal Capacity with flashcards?

There are 10 flashcards on Insanity Defense and Criminal Capacity, with a question on the front and the answer on the back. Try to recall each answer before you flip, and let spaced repetition bring back the ones you miss.

See all 10 flashcards →

Related classes

Turn your own class notes into a study guide

Upload a PDF or paste your notes. Revizly writes a study guide, a practice quiz and flashcards in about a minute.