Study guide: Insanity Defense and Criminal Capacity

Course Outline

  1. Criminal Responsibility and Legal Terms
  2. Origins of the McNaughton Rules
  3. Insanity Defense and McNaughton Tests
  4. Mental Disease and Modern Debates
  5. Neuroscience and Psychopathy
  6. Halimi Case and Delirium
  7. Intoxication and Incapacity Readings

★ Must-know

  • Psychologists and psychiatrists may provide expert evidence in criminal trials about an accused person's mental capacity.

📌 A criminal act requires both actus reus, the act, and mens rea, the intention or state of mind.

Further detail

  • The legal vocabulary includes trial, accused or defendant, plaintiff, expert witness, insanity plea, lawyer or barrister, appeal, prosecution, burden of proof, balance of probabilities, mens rea, and actus reus.

Memory Hook

Actus reus is the act; mens rea is the guilty mind.

2. Origins of the McNaughton Rules

★ Must-know

  • In 1843, the House of Lords in Great Britain issued the ruling in R v. McNaughton, which became known as the McNaughton Rules.

Further detail

  • McNaughton shot and murdered Edward Drummond, believing Drummond was Prime Minister Robert Peel.

3. Insanity Defense and McNaughton Tests

Key Concepts & Definitions

  • Disease of the Mind: A disease of the mind is a condition that may cause a defect of reason relevant to the insanity defense; examples given include hypoglycaemia, an epileptic episode, and sleepwalking.

★ Must-know

📌 The McNaughton Rules presume every person sane and sufficiently reasonable to be responsible for their crimes.

📌 To establish an insanity defense under the McNaughton Rules, the accused must prove that, at the time of the act, a defect of reason or disease of the mind prevented them from knowing the nature and quality of the act or, if they knew it, that it was wrong.

Further detail

📌 Under the nature-and-quality test, the accused does not know what they are physically doing, and the test has no moral component.

  • Examples of not knowing the nature and quality of an act include cutting a man's throat while believing he is a loaf of bread and chopping off a man's head to see him look for it when he wakes up.

📌 A temporary delusion can support an insanity defense if the accused is proved to have lacked mens rea, with the court assessing the facts according to what the accused believed to be real.

📌 For the wrongfulness test, the accused must lack the capacity to know that the act was legally wrong, morally wrong, or both.

Memory Hook

Test reason first, the act’s nature next, then knowledge of wrongfulness.

4. Mental Disease and Modern Debates

★ Must-know

📌 Voluntary intoxication is excluded from the conditions qualifying for the insanity defense, and conditions characterized primarily by antisocial behavior, such as kleptomania, pyromania, and pedophilia, are also identified as excluded.

Further detail

  • The article “The Insanity Defense, An intersection of morality, public policy, and science” was written by Donald Schouten M.D., J.D. and published on August 16, 2012 in Psychology Today.

  • A modern debate asks how advances in neuroscience and genetics will affect the insanity defense.

5. Neuroscience and Psychopathy

Key Concepts & Definitions

  • Psychopathy: Psychopathy is described as an extreme form of personality disturbance with no established effective treatment, and as not supporting an insanity defense.

Essential Points

  • There is growing evidence for genetic transmission of numerous psychiatric conditions, including personality disorders and physiological abnormalities.

  • Neuroscience discoveries indicate fundamental anatomical and physiological differences between the brains of psychopaths and non-psychopaths, including non-psychopathic criminals.

  • There is evidence that psychopathic traits may be inherited.

Memory Hook

Brain differences and inherited traits are evidence; they do not establish an insanity defense.

6. Halimi Case and Delirium

★ Must-know

  • On April 14, 2021, the French Cour de cassation ruled that Kobili Traoré could not be held criminally responsible for Sarah Halimi’s murder because a state of delirium, described as bouffée délirante, had abolished his discernment at the time of the killing.

Further detail

  • Sarah Halimi, a 65-year-old Jewish doctor, was killed by her neighbor Kobili Traoré, who broke into her apartment, beat her, and pushed her out of a window.

  • Traoré had consumed high amounts of cannabis before the killing and claimed that he was possessed by a demon and did not know what he was doing.

  • Traoré was judged not responsible because of a temporary state of psychosis.

  • The decision in the Halimi case was condemned by many, including Emmanuel Macron.

Memory Hook

Delirium at the time of the killing → criminal incapacity under the 2020 ruling.

7. Intoxication and Incapacity Readings

Essential Points

  • The assigned readings are: the “Charles” case study, summaries of old British Common Law judgments, a summary of a recent Supreme Court of Canada case from 2023

Test yourself

Take a 11-question practice quiz on Insanity Defense and Criminal Capacity, with every answer explained.

1. In a criminal trial, the evidence establishes that a defendant performed the prohibited act, but does not establish the required intention or state of mind. Which element has not been established?

2. A court needs expert evidence about whether an accused person had the mental capacity relevant to a criminal trial. Which professionals may provide that evidence?

Take the quiz →

Study with flashcards

Memorize the key concepts of Insanity Defense and Criminal Capacity with 10 flashcards.

What may psychologists and psychiatrists provide evidence about in criminal trials?

An accused person’s mental capacity.

What two elements must a criminal act involve?

Actus reus and mens rea.

In which year did the House of Lords issue the ruling in R v. McNaughton?

1843.

See the flashcards →

Related classes

Make your own study guides

Upload your class notes and Revizly writes a study guide, a quiz and flashcards in about a minute.

Study guide maker