Evaluating Sources with CRAAP Practice Quiz (6 questions)

All questions and answers

1. A student is comparing two sources about how ocean acidification affects oysters. Both address the topic, but which source is more directly relevant to a question about the effect of seawater pH on oyster reproduction?

Source A, which directly examines seawater pH and oyster reproduction
Source B, which discusses ocean acidification’s effects on oysters generally
Source A, because it provides more experimental detail
Source B, which explains the issue for a public audience

Source A, which directly examines seawater pH and oyster reproduction

Explanation

Relevance depends on how closely a source addresses the specific question, and Source A directly investigates the relationship between seawater pH and oyster reproduction. General coverage of oyster impacts or experimental detail alone does not identify the most directly relevant focus.

2. For an authority comparison of two sources about ocean acidification and oysters, which source has the stronger credentials based on its authorship and publication venue?

Source B, written by a journalist and published by an environmental organisation
Source A, because its topic concerns oyster reproduction
Source A, written by scientific researchers and published in a peer-reviewed journal
Source B, published by an organisation focused on environmental issues

Source A, written by scientific researchers and published in a peer-reviewed journal

Explanation

Source A’s scientific researchers and peer-reviewed journal provide the stronger authority credentials. An environmental organisation’s relevance to the subject or a source’s topic does not make it a peer-reviewed scientific publication.

3. A researcher must choose the stronger scientific source between two accounts of ocean acidification’s effects on oysters. Source A includes peer-reviewed research, detailed experimental methods, and measurable results; Source B has less direct experimental evidence. Which should the researcher select?

Source B, for its interviews and discussion of real-world effects
Source B, for its explanations aimed at readers outside scientific research
Source A, for its peer-reviewed research and measurable experimental evidence
Source A, because its publication date is more recent

Source A, for its peer-reviewed research and measurable experimental evidence

Explanation

Peer review, detailed methods, and measurable results make Source A stronger for scientific evidence than Source B’s less direct evidence. Public accessibility, interviews, or publication date do not replace those evidential strengths.

4. A student is evaluating two sources with the CRAAP approach to decide which is stronger. Which procedure best supports a reasoned comparison?

Assess every CRAAP aspect for one source, then judge the other by its overall impression
Assess each CRAAP aspect for both sources, then compare their strengths
Select the more persuasive source, then discuss criteria that support the choice
Assess authority for both sources, then select the more credentialed author

Assess each CRAAP aspect for both sources, then compare their strengths

Explanation

A CRAAP evaluation should address each aspect for both sources and use that comparison to determine which is stronger. Focusing on one criterion or evaluating the sources unevenly does not provide the required comparative basis.

5. In the CRAAP framework for evaluating sources, what does the “Purpose” criterion examine?

The source’s publication date and how recently its information was produced
The strength of the evidence, including methods and measured results
The author’s expertise and the credibility of the publication venue
The source’s aim, such as communicating research or persuading readers to take action

The source’s aim, such as communicating research or persuading readers to take action

Explanation

Purpose concerns what a source is trying to accomplish; here, one source communicates research while the other also encourages action. Currency is a plausible alternative, but it evaluates recency rather than the source’s aim.

6. What type of evidence does Source B provide that helps readers understand ocean acidification’s real-world impacts?

Controlled measurements linking seawater pH to oyster reproduction
Peer-reviewed experimental results accompanied by detailed methods
Public-facing explanations and interviews about its effects
A graph reporting measured changes in oyster reproduction

Public-facing explanations and interviews about its effects

Explanation

Source B uses explanations and interviews to help convey the real-world impacts of ocean acidification. Source A, rather than Source B, provides direct experimental measurements and detailed methods.

Study with flashcards

Lock in the answers with 4 flashcards on Evaluating Sources with CRAAP.

What relationship does Source A directly examine about oysters?

The relationship between seawater pH and oyster reproduction.

Why is Source A stronger than Source B in scientific evidence?

It provides peer-reviewed research, detailed experimental methods, and measurable results.

Which source is more recent, and when was it published?

Source A, published in 2017.

See the flashcards →

Read the study guide

Go over the full study guide for Evaluating Sources with CRAAP.

Read the study guide →

Related classes

Make your own practice quizzes

Upload your class notes and Revizly writes a practice quiz with explained answers in about a minute.

Quiz maker