What does European Union law help explain about integration?
Its political and legal issues.
Which approaches does the course use to study European integration?
Historical, institutional, and normative approaches.
What is an international organisation?
A subject of international law established by states to organise relations and undertake common action.
Which Treaty on European Union article expressly grants the EU legal personality?
Article 47.
How are international organisations created by states?
Through treaties agreed by the states that become parties.
What does the EU principle of conferral restrict?
The EU may act only within competences conferred by the Member States.
Under Article 5 TEU, who retains competences not conferred on the EU?
The Member States.
What democratic principle under Article 10 TEU underpins the EU?
Representative democracy.
Whose consent do Articles 48 and 49 TEU require for treaty revision and accession?
The consent of Member States’ peoples through applicable national procedures.
Why is the Union not a traditional intergovernmental organisation?
Individuals are subjects of its law, whose legal order has primacy and direct effect.
Which court initially called the Community a “new legal order of international law”?
The Court of Justice of the Communities.
What process does EU enlargement describe?
Admitting new Member States into the European Union.
What does the EU’s absorption capacity mean?
Its ability to integrate new Member States while maintaining effective institutional and policy functioning.
After an Article 7 TEU finding, what rights may the Council suspend?
Certain rights deriving from the Treaties, potentially including voting rights.
What must an applicant country respect and be able to implement under the acquis communautaire?
The body of legal rights and obligations linking the Member States.
Under Article 50(1) TEU, who may decide to withdraw from the European Union?
Any Member State.
Under Article 50(2) TEU, which institution does a withdrawing state notify?
The European Council.
Under Article 218(3) TFEU, how does the Council conclude the withdrawal agreement for the Union?
By qualified majority.
What is European integration?
The collective organisation and exercise of some aspects of Member States’ sovereignty.
What mutual duty does Article 4(3) TEU impose on the Union and Member States?
They must assist each other, in full mutual respect, in carrying out Treaty tasks.
What kind of obligation do Member States have to ensure EU law is effectively implemented and respected?
An obligation of result.
How does EU law apply when one Member State fails to comply?
Each Member State must apply EU law regardless of another Member State’s failure.
What kind of principle is sincere cooperation, and who can invoke it?
It is an autonomous principle recognised by the Court of Justice that any Member State can invoke.
What does the negative aspect of sincere cooperation require Member States to avoid?
Measures that could jeopardise Union objectives or contradict EU law.
What does Article 4(2) TEU require the Union to respect?
Member States’ national identities, fundamental political and constitutional structures, regional and local self-government, essential State functions, and national security.
What limit applies to Member States’ reliance on national identity under EU law?
National identity cannot justify failure to comply with EU obligations.
What rights accompany EU Member State membership?
Representation in Union institutions and participation in appointing Commission members.
When does Council qualified-majority voting help make collective decisions possible?
When unanimity would be difficult or could block action.
What must each EU institution respect under the principle of institutional balance?
The powers conferred by the Treaties and the competences of the other institutions.
What does the European Parliament represent?
EU citizens through elected representatives.
What role does the Council play in EU legislation under Article 16 TEU?
It is one of the Union’s legislative chambers.
What did the Council adopt on 21 April 1970?
The own-resources decision, establishing financial autonomy for the European Communities.
Which resources initially flowed directly into the Community budget?
Customs duties, agricultural levies, and a VAT-based resource.
What mechanisms accommodate Member State differences while pursuing EU integration?
Derogation protocols or opt-outs, and enhanced cooperation.
What legal status and effect do EU derogation protocols have?
They have Treaty-level legal value and create exceptions to general membership obligations for one or more states.
What does a net-budget calculation exclude besides a Member State’s EU revenue and expenditure balance?
Benefits such as EU citizenship rights and cross-border mobility.
Which acts does Article 288 TFEU identify as adopted by EU institutions to carry out EU policies?
Regulations, directives, decisions, recommendations, and opinions.
What makes an EU regulation directly applicable across the Member States?
It is binding in its entirety and directly applicable in every Member State.
What discretion does an EU directive leave to national authorities?
The choice of form and methods for achieving the required result.
What conditions allow an EU provision to have direct effect?
It must be sufficiently clear and precise, and unconditional because no further discretionary measure is needed.
What do Articles 51(1) and 52(5) of the Charter distinguish?
Rights, which must be respected, from principles, which must be observed and do not themselves create immediate rights to positive action.
How was EU law primacy established, and was it enshrined in the treaties?
The Court of Justice established it through case law; it was not enshrined in the treaties.
What principle did the Court establish in Costa v ENEL on 15 July 1964?
Community law takes primacy over conflicting national legislation.
What did French courts accept about treaty primacy over statutes, but reject about EU law?
They accepted treaty primacy over statutes but rejected EU law’s primacy over the Constitution.
Which constitutional review power did the Conseil constitutionnel identify in IVG?
Article 61 permits review of statutory constitutionality, not treaty compatibility under Article 55.
Which 2004 decision treated directive transposition as a constitutional requirement under Article 88-1?
The Conseil constitutionnel’s decision on the law on confidence in the digital economy, June 2004.
Which 2007 Conseil d’État ruling established an equivalence test when reviewing decrees transposing directives?
Arcelor, 8 February 2007.
Who may legislate in an exclusive competence area?
Only the Union, unless it empowers Member States or they implement Union acts.
What does subsidiarity require before EU action in non-exclusive competence areas?
Member States cannot sufficiently achieve the objectives, and they can be better achieved at Union level because of the action’s scale or effects.
What does Article 5(4) TEU require under the principle of proportionality?
Union action’s content and form must not exceed what is necessary to achieve the Treaties’ objectives.
What does proportionality determine, unlike subsidiarity?
The type and extent of EU action, favouring the measure least restrictive for Member States.
Across which EU competences does proportionality apply?
All EU competences.
What purpose does Article 13 TEU assign to the EU institutional framework?
To promote Union values and objectives, serve the Union, its citizens and Member States, and ensure policy consistency, effectiveness and continuity.
Which bodies count as EU institutions in the strict sense under Article 13 TEU?
Only the seven institutions listed in Article 13 TEU.
Which Council formation does the High Representative chair?
The Foreign Affairs Council.
How is each Member State represented in the Council under Article 16 TEU?
By one ministerial-level representative empowered to commit its government.
Which issues reveal challenges or limits of European integration?
Brexit, democratic and liberal-democratic crises, economic and social crisis, migration, health, the war in Ukraine, and environmental crisis.
What framework did states establish after the Second World War for collective action and preventive diplomacy?
International organisations.
How did the EU’s international legal personality differ before and after the Treaty of Lisbon?
It was described as informal before Lisbon and formalised by the Treaty of Lisbon.
Which treaty introduced the EU, and in what year?
The Treaty of Maastricht introduced the EU in 1992.
Which treaty established the EEC, and in what year?
The Treaty of Rome in 1957.
What ratification condition applies to EU treaty changes across Member States?
Unanimous consent across the Member States.
Which Danish referendum rejected the Maastricht Treaty?
The June 1992 referendum.
What legal personality did the Communities possess before Lisbon?
The Communities had their own legal personality.
What did the Treaty of Lisbon do to the Union and the Community?
It merged them and clarified the Union’s legal structure.
What shapes EU enlargement, and what is its general character?
Political opportunity shapes it, and it is lengthy and complex.
When did Spain and Portugal join the EEC?
1986.
After rights are suspended, what obligations must a Member State continue to meet?
All obligations arising from Union law.
Whom do Article 7 sanctions target, and whose consequences must the Council consider?
They target the responsible State, and the Council must consider consequences for private individuals.
Under Article 50(4) TEU, what participation is barred for the withdrawing state’s representative?
Participation in European Council or Council discussions and decisions concerning its withdrawal.
Which expression did Pierre Pescatore use for principles characterising the distinctive nature of EU law?
“European integration law.”
What forms can a state’s relationship with the European Union take?
Membership, applicant or candidate status, partnership, or association.
Which 1973 judgment held that Member States cannot selectively apply Community regulations?
Commission v. Italy, Case 39/72.
What does the positive aspect of sincere cooperation require Member States to do?
Take appropriate general or particular measures to fulfil Treaty obligations and obligations arising from Union acts.
Which case and year concerned EU values and national judicial systems?
Case C-430/21 RS (2022).
What does Article 7 TEU provide for responding to threats to EU values?
A political procedure for responding to a clear risk of seriously breaching, or a breach of, EU values.
What objective shapes equal Member State participation rights in the Council and European Council?
The objective of EU integration.
What does classical one-state-one-vote require for equal Member State voting rights?
Unanimity, giving each State a veto.
Which case and year does the course link to institutional balance?
The Court of Justice’s Meroni affair, 1958.
Which resource was later developed to supplement the Community’s own resources?
A resource based on Member States’ Gross National Income.
How did the ECSC and EEC initially differ in their budget financing?
The ECSC had Treaty of Paris own resources, while the EEC relied on national contributions allocated by national parliaments.
Which provisions are identified as having direct effect?
Articles 101 and 102 TFEU and rights in the Charter of Fundamental Rights.
How did Costa v ENEL characterize the EEC Treaty’s legal system?
It created its own legal system, integrated into Member States’ systems from entry into force and binding on their courts.
Which Conseil d’État decision rejected setting aside a conflicting later statute?
Syndicat général de fabricants de semoule, 1 March 1968.
Which 2021 Conseil d’État ruling affirmed correct transposition while treating the Constitution as supreme domestically?
La Quadrature du Net / French Data Network, 21 April 2021.
Which competence categories did the Treaty of Lisbon enshrine?
Exclusive, shared, and supporting competences.
What autonomy concern prompted the development of subsidiarity?
Expanding EU competences could reduce Member State, regional, and federal autonomy and leave national parliaments merely registering EU decisions.
What three outcomes can subsidiarity oversight produce?
Action can remain at Member State level, occur at EU level, or be divided between them without unnecessary interference with national action.
Who has served as High Representative since December 2024?
Kaja Kallas.
How does the European Council appoint the High Representative under Article 18 TEU?
By qualified majority, with the Commission President’s agreement.
What may the Commission do during Council sessions when participating?
It may explain or defend proposals, respond to amendments, and modify proposals.
What does Coreper coordinate and prepare for the Council?
Coreper coordinates the Council’s day-to-day work and prepares meetings of all configurations.
Answer 94 questions on EU Competences and Institutions.
1. Which description best captures European integration as a process that EU law helps explain?
2. What approach did the Schuman speech set out on 9 May 1950 to overcome national antagonisms?
Go over the full study guide for EU Competences and Institutions.
Read the study guide →Upload your class notes and Revizly writes your flashcards in about a minute.
Flashcard maker